I enjoy college football, but the College Football Playoff Selection Committee just killed my postseason viewing. I’ll only watch the Utah Utes in the Las Vegas Bowl, but I’m supporting Notre Dame’s bowl boycott after it was cheated out of a spot in the College Football Playoff. The University of Alabama was chosen instead, despite having poorer performance stats and losing big in its conference championship game. The University of Miami was also elevated above Notre Dame despite its less impressive stats — with the exception of having narrowly beaten The Fighting Irish in the season opener.
In recent years, the National Collegiate Athletics Association has made a mess of college football, but if the NCAA wants to redeem itself, it could:
1. Expand the playoff to 16 teams with no byes which would have eliminated this year’s fiasco.
2. Realign conferences to have no more than ten teams. The conference champion would be the team with the best record in nine conference games. No conference championship game needed.
3. Eliminate publishing CFP rankings before the end of the season. The committee embarrasses itself when it reorders those without cause.
4. Put income limits on Name Image Likeness as it grossly enriches some players. NIL has turned college football into the NFL Lite.
5. Fix the transfer portal. Allow players only one transfer and perhaps a second if a coach moves on.
6. Convince the Heisman Trophy Trust to award its statue at the end of the playoffs eliminating the embarrassment when an awardee fizzles in postseason play.
7. Consider eliminating conferences altogether. Create leagues of 60 or so teams in upper and lower divisions like European sports are structured with fluidity between the divisions based on teams’ previous year’s performance.
To do all this would just require some good will.
Jim Catano, Salt Lake City
Submit a letter to the editor







