Connect with us
https://yoursportsnation.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/call-to-1.png

NIL

Transfer Portal troubles

Published

on

Transfer Portal troubles


Credit Jason Hill – Co-Photo Editor // The Miami Hurricanes stand for the national anthem before their game against Ball Srate at Hard Rock Stadium on Sept. 14, 2024.

When Xavier Lucas transferred to Miami in January earlier this year, from the outside it was easy to not bat an eye.

The ‘Canes had closely missed out on the former four-star defensive back during their 2024 recruiting season, narrowly losing out to Wisconsin. And upon the completion of his freshman year, it appeared the South Florida native and former American Heritage star decided to move back home. To most, this was a no-brainer move back home to the sunshine state for the rising star.

But with that being said, the circumstances that surrounded Lucas’ departure from Wisconsin and transfer to Miami have become shrouded in controversy, and now, after much speculation, the Big Ten school announced a lawsuit against the University of Miami on June 21.

Wisconsin alleges that Miami made illegal contact with Lucas prior to his decision to transfer, allegedly days after he signed his NIL agreement with the Badgers.

Wisconsin’s issue stems from Lucas’ 2-year NIL agreement signed on December 2, 2024. Lucas then soon requested to transfer, informing his position coach. According to CBS Sports, it was also reported that his deal was among one of the highest revenue-sharing agreements on the team.

Lucas and his representation originally asked to be put into the transfer portal but claim, as Wisconsin also states, that the team did not allow for him to be officially listed as a transfer.

Wisconsin’s first official statement in response to Lucas’ decision stated, “A request to enter the transfer portal after entering such an agreement is inconsistent with the representations and mutual understanding of the agreement and explains the reason for processing a transfer portal request under these circumstances.” 

Wisconsin alleges that “on multiple occasions after December 2, 2024, and continuing into January 2025, Miami had impermissible contacts with [Xavier Lucas] and his representatives.”

They list out multiple alleged meetings, including visiting a relative’s home with a coach and prominent alumni providing a compensation commitment that “included financial terms more lucrative than those included in the contracts.”

Lucas’ attorney, Darren Heitner, has fought back against these allegations, stating that they are flat-out false. He was hired in January after the team refused to terminate the agreement and allow Lucas to transfer.

When neither side could agree on terms, Lucas withdrew from the university, not officially entering the transfer portal but essentially allowing him the same opportunity to enroll at another institution, which he did with Miami. The NCAA did respond to this, stating that its rules cannot prevent a student-athlete from taking this approach and being able to compete. In the lawsuit, Wisconsin does point out, though, that Lucas was allowed to enroll well after November 1, 2024, Miami’s official deadline for spring transfer enrollment. 

Miami football head coach Mario Cristobal guides players through warm-up drills before their game against Bethune-Cookman at Hard Rock Stadium on Sept. 14, 2023. Photo credit: Alexandra Fisher

What is important to note is that none of the money had been paid out to Lucas, as this was pending the final decision of House V. NCAA, so neither Miami nor Lucas is liable to return any financial compensation to Wisconsin. The Badgers, regardless, have pushed forward with the lawsuit after months of speculation if they would and are backed by the Big Ten.

They officially announced support for Wisconsin, telling Yahoo Sports, “The Big Ten Conference believes that the University of Miami’s actions are irreconcilable with a sustainable college sports framework and is supportive of UW-Madison’s efforts to preserve it.”

The lawsuit states that the Badgers saw Lucas as a cornerstone of their program, leading to their big financial commitment to Lucas. With Miami allegedly swooping in and taking him, not only did that take a big contributor, it disrupted the Badgers’ plans for building their program. 

They allege even more in the lawsuit, claiming that, quote, “in late 2024, Miami continued to recruit a second student-athlete, ‘Student-Athlete B,’ even though Student-Athlete B had made a written commitment to another DI school in late 2024, which commitment had been reflected in the Transfer Portal.” 

The question now is what the potential fallout could be for this case regardless of whether the courts find the allegations against Miami to be true.

For one the NCAA should watch if other student-athletes unenroll and then enroll to avoid the transfer portal. Lucas’ method of getting to Miami could be used in less reasonable circumstances, which would result in chaos between student-athlete and university. Moreover, plenty of student-athletes enter the portal with a “DNC” tag, which means do not contact. In these cases the student-athlete typically already has a school they wish to transfer to, which could lend itself to tampering as the school and athlete often make contact before the athlete enters with a “DNC” tag.

Redshirt sophmore wide receiever Isaiah Horton celebrates after scoring a touchdown in Miami’s game against Virginia Tech at Hard Rock Stadium on Sept. 27, 2024. Photo Credit: Jason Hill – Co-Photo Editor

More importantly, with money officially on the board across the college football landscape, student-athletes are now closer to pros than they have ever been. While they are rightfully earning their share of the pie, the question now is whether these NIL contracts are going to be enforceable and binding. Regardless of whether Miami is at fault, the potential for any team to come in and have similar situations happen is huge for the future of college sports in general. 

As for what this means for Miami, if the allegations are true, Wisconsin is asking for some sort of financial compensation and for the ‘Canes to declare their conduct to be tampering. On the larger scale, it’s uncertain if the NCAA will make an example out of Miami.

When the last situation of this scale happened with the Michigan sign-stealing allegations, the eventual champions faced no repercussions after the NCAA found them to be not guilty. But within the Big Ten, as the investigations continued, both Jim Harbaugh and current head coach Sherrone Moore faced suspensions brought forth by the Big Ten.

With no NCAA investigation currently announced and with this being between conferences, it’s unlikely that Miami, even if found at fault, will face anything more than fines. This could mean more in terms of the team’s reputation, especially at a time when rumored conference realignment or movement could have the ‘Canes looking to places like the Big Ten to get a slice of their lucrative media rights. 

While Miami has yet to officially comment on these allegations, Lucas’ attorney, Heitner, has stated that the intention is still for Lucas to play for the ‘Canes this fall. For the foreseeable future it’s certain to stay that way as the Hurricanes look towards their season starting in just a couple of months. 

Regardless of where this case falls, it will be one of the first big decisions in the post-House v. NCAA landscape, a landmark case in how student-athlete contracts and compensation unfold in the future. 

The Miami Hurricanes take the field at Hard Rock Stadium against the Virginia Tech Hokies on Sept. 28, 2024. // Photo Credit via Emily Rice
Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

NIL

Ohio State QB Julian Sayin Announces NIL News Before College Football Playoff

Published

on


Julian Sayin is looking to lead the Ohio State Buckeyes to the national title alongside several other stars like wide receiver Jeremiah Smith.

Ohio State heads into the College Football Playoff with one of the best rosters in the country, starring Sayin and Smith along with wide receiver Carnell Tate, safety Caleb Downs and linebacker Arvell Reese.

Advertisement

They’re heading into the playoffs as the No. 2 seed after losing to Indiana in the Big Ten title game. The Buckeyes will have a bye week to begin the CFP.

Other teams that will benefit from the bye week include Indiana, Texas Tech and Georgia.

During his time off, Sayin shared some exciting news off the field. The Ohio State Buckeyes quarterback has partnered with Wingstop and Dr Pepper in his latest NIL deal.

“Postseason calls for big plays with @drpepper and @wingstop, had to get the play card out,” Sayin posted.

Advertisement





Link

Continue Reading

NIL

Stars Stay, Others Head to Portal

Published

on





College Football’s QB Carousel: Stars Stay, Others Head to Portal



































Link

Continue Reading

NIL

Texas A&M’s KC Concepcion has ‘not made a decision’ regarding future

Published

on


Dec. 16, 2025, 5:06 a.m. CT

Texas A&M’s 2025 offense finished the regular season ranked 19th nationally, while starting quarterback Marcel Reed threw for a career high 2,932 yards and 25 touchdowns, with 13 going to star wide receivers KC Concepcion and Mario Craver, who completely rejuvenated a passing attack that failed to move the needle in key games down the stretch last season.

While Craver is expected to return next season for his all-important junior year, Concepcion has a choice to make regarding his future, choosing between a final year in College Station or declaring for the 2026 NFL Draft, where he is expected to be a first or second-round selection.

Whatever choice he makes is entirely up to him and his family, and while those of us in the media have written numerous articles about his draft standing, returning for his senior season could benefit his NFL future. Still, Concepcion is as mature as they come and is entirely focused on facing the Miami Hurricanes this Saturday during the first round of the College Football Playoff.





Link

Continue Reading

NIL

Josh Pate defends Joel Klatt amid G5 backlash, proposes second tier to College Football Playoff

Published

on


FOX Sports analyst Joel Klatt found himself in a social media firestorm after comments he made about the Group of Five on a podcast appearance on Next Round Live. Clips of that interview quickly went viral with short snippets of some of the quotes.

The gist of those snippets suggested that Klatt was anti-G5, to the point of wanting the G5 kicked out of the College Football Playoff. Klatt intimated that the only thing keeping the G5 in the playoff currently is the threat of litigation.

College football analyst Josh Pate had his own thoughts on Joel Klatt’s take. He mostly came to the defense of the suddenly targeted analyst.

Pate first played a couple clips from Klatt’s appearance in their entirety. That offered more full context.

“Some of that was insane, I’m going to grant you that,” Pate said of Klatt’s points. “I just want to say the foundation of it I at least understand. The foundation of it is sound. Not all the parts of it. The foundation of it is sound.

“Couple of quotes there. No. 1, the G5 is in the College Football Playoff to avoid litigation is basically true.”

Pate lambasted the use of quote edits in condensing Joel Klatt’s much larger point into a few soundbites. He tried to explain how that’s misleading to his viewers.

“You know sometimes how you see a snapshot or a small soundbite of something and you get outraged by it and then you go on to learn the context of it two weeks later and you’re like, ‘Wow, I probably shouldn’t have gotten as outraged as I did over that,’ Pate said. “That is what is happening to Klatt. Admittedly he brought a lot of this on himself. …

“Now, what you probably saw was you probably saw quote edits like this or quote graphics like this. And if you’re listening on podcast just imagine scrolling through your social feed and there’s a picture of Klatt, looks like he’s somewhere sunny and happy and there’s a quote at the top, and it says, quote, ‘We don’t want Cinderellas. We want the best teams playing each other at the end. It’s the dumbest tournament and the least fair tournament in all of sports.’”

That part from Joel Klatt, obviously, was what many detractors latched onto. But it doesn’t take away from Klatt’s overall point about the G5, Pate pointed out.

So all the moaning over James Madison being in the playoffs is for naught. That’s just the way the current structure is set up.

“They are present in the playoff, they’re granted an auto bid in the playoff because if they are not then lawsuits will be filed immediately,” Pate said. “So that part’s accurate.

“Now whether or not you think it’s morally sound that they’re included in the playoff, that’s your own opinion. He’s got his, I’ve got mine, you’ve got yours. But he is right. Because in no other merit-based world where we just judged these teams on a static scale of quality, of resources and therefore what you do with the resources, and the results on the field and strength of schedule, in no world would James Madison be in the playoff. But the parameters of the playoff right now are that we take the five highest-ranked conference champs. So by every current rule James Madison is in the playoff and should be in the playoff. I don’t disagree with that. Tulane is in the playoff and should be in the playoff. I don’t disagree with the structure. I don’t disagree with the body of the playoff this year based on the current rules.”

So what’s the solution? Well, Joel Klatt also offered an answer for that. It just didn’t happen to go viral with the other stuff.

Klatt believes the G5 should effectively break off from the power conferences and host its own playoff. It would be a playoff tier between the FCS and the FBS.

“That’s been the same point that’s been made on my show,” Pate said. “So you notice if you really hated the G5 you’d just say, ‘Piss on the G5.’ That’s not what he did, despite the fact that that part didn’t get shared widely and it’s not what I’ve ever done on this show.

“Any time you have a problem with something, you ought to have a solution for it. So if your problem is, ‘Man, it makes little sense that we’ve got 136 teams pretending to play the same caliber of the sport’ you need to have a solution. That solution he just presented is the same one we’ve shared on this show, and that is a G5 playoff.”



Link

Continue Reading

NIL

How NIL has transformed Ohio State’s recruiting from star-chasing to strategic roster building

Published

on


COLUMBUS, Ohio — The days of simply collecting as many five-star talents as possible in college football recruiting are over.

In a revealing Buckeye Talk podcast episode, Ohio State analysts Stephen Means and Andrew Gillis detailed how the program has shifted to a more sophisticated “roster construction” approach that mirrors NFL team building more than traditional college recruiting.

“I think that because the financial aspect has come into this but also just logical roster building that has become more of a focal point than star, star, star, star, stars,” explained Stephen Means. “Because for a long time, college football was like, get as much talent as you humanly can, develop it, cuz you were living in a world where the top 1% of college football had all the talent. And that’s not true anymore.”

This fundamental shift in philosophy is perhaps most evident in how Gillis described Ohio State’s running back recruiting needs for the 2027 class. While five-star David Gabriel Georgees tops their board, the approach is more nuanced than just stacking elite talent.

“If they got three five stars running backs, the odds that we got on this podcast and said that’s actually probably not that good is higher than it might seem because we were saying why is your asset management this? Like because hey, look at your your receiver recruiting was down. You couldn’t have spent some of that money on a receiver,” Gillis explained.

The financial component of recruiting has transformed how Ohio State approaches each position group and recruiting class. It’s no longer just about who’s the best player available, but whether investing heavily in one position might shortchange another.

“It is a math equation. It is a money equation at this point. You’re not going to go get three five stars at running back in a single class,” Gillis emphasized.

Means further elaborated on how NIL money has forced this change: “You can’t pay a fivestar recruit, fivestar recruit money and then have the guy sitting on the bench because there’s another guy with there’s only so much money to go around.”

This strategic approach has Ohio State looking at players through different lenses: “ready to go” immediate contributors (typically five-stars and top-100 recruits), “developmental” prospects (usually ranked 200-350 nationally), and “depth” pieces who might be ranked lower but fill specific roles.

The analysts identified several instances where this approach is evident in Ohio State’s 2027 planning. At quarterback, they’re content with a developmental prospect in Brady Edmonds rather than chasing another five-star. At wide receiver, despite already having five-star Jir Brown committed, they believe Ohio State needs another elite receiver plus two depth pieces to properly structure the room.

“Now we are talking about roster construction,” Means said. “And the reason why we structured it this way is okay, they went and got a devel they have a developmental quarterback in 2027. They probably need a ready to go quarterback in 2028 and they probably need a depth quarterback in 2029. And the cycle continues, right?”

This staggered approach ensures Ohio State will have players at different stages of development at every position, creating a sustainable pipeline of talent ready to contribute when needed.

“Everybody everybody’s running the same race, but they can’t be running it at the same pace or you’re not going to have a team to field every single year,” Means added.

The conversation revealed how Ohio State’s recruiting approach now more closely resembles NFL roster management, with considerations for “salary cap” (NIL budget), positional value, and development timelines all factoring into decisions that previously might have been simply about collecting the highest-ranked players available.

As college football continues to evolve in the NIL era, this strategic roster construction philosophy may become the new standard for elite programs looking to maintain sustainable success.

Here’s the podcast for this week:



Link

Continue Reading

NIL

Texas Tech announces football staff contract extensions

Published

on


LUBBOCK, Texas – Texas Tech announced Tuesday it has come to terms on contract extensions for four key members of its football coaching staff: general manager James Blanchard, offensive coordinator Mack Leftwich, associate head coach and special teams coordinator Kenny Perry and defensive coordinator Shiel Wood.

Texas Tech agreed to the extensions with Blanchard and its three coordinators in recent weeks, pushing each of their contracts through the 2028 season with significant financial investments included as well as a revised buyout structure. McGuire, himself, agreed to a new seven-year contract following the regular season, only days prior to leading the Red Raiders to their first Big 12 Conference title in school history.

“I appreciate Kirby Hocutt and our administration for proactively investing in the future of our football program,” McGuire said. “Our expectation is to compete annually for championships with this staff and the resources we have in place here at Texas Tech. While we still have goals in front of us this season, we’re thankful to have the support of an incredible fan base and administration that believes strongly in the future of this program.”

Texas Tech enters the College Football Playoff Quarterfinal at the Capital One Orange Bowl with a 12-1 record, having already snapped the single-season school record for wins ahead of a potential matchup with either No. 5 Oregon or No. 12 seed James Madison. The Red Raiders are in the College Football Playoff for the first time in program history following a 34-7 rout over previously-No. 11 BYU in the Edward Jones Big 12 Championship.

Texas Tech has dominated opponents this season with all 12 wins coming by at least 20 points. In the process, the Red Raiders joined only Alabama in 2018 as the only teams in the Associated Press era (since 1936) to record 12 or more wins by 20-plus points prior to a bowl game. The 12 wins by that margin are already both a Texas Tech and Big 12 Conference record and are one shy of the FBS record that was set by Clemson in 2018.  

The Red Raiders’ success has stemmed from all three sides of the ball with a stingy defense, another high-scoring offense and an aggressive approach on special teams. To date, Texas Tech is the only team in the country to rank in the top five for scoring offense (42.5), scoring defense (10.9), total offense (480.3 yards per game) and total defense (254.4 yards allowed per game). The Red Raiders are also the FBS leaders in both takeaways (31) and rush defense (68.5 yards allowed per game) and rank 10th for passing offense (289.4 yards per game), creating the balance McGuire desired upon his hiring four years ago.

On special teams, the Red Raiders have combined to block five kicks this season, which is tied with Penn State for the most in the FBS. Texas Tech has been among the most-aggressive teams in the country under Perry, blocking a total of 14 kicks during his four seasons, which leads all Big 12 programs during that span and ranks in the top five nationally. Texas Tech is also the only team in the country to rank in the top 20 for both kick return average and kickoff return defense this season, all while boasting a Paul Hornung finalist in running back and returner J’Koby Williams and a Lou Groza semifinalist in kicker Stone Harrington.

Perry was a charter member of McGuire’s staff upon his hiring prior to the 2022 season as he has been part of four-consecutive bowl appearances and 25 wins over Big 12 opponents, the most in the conference during that span. Both Leftwich and Wood are completing their first seasons on staff after arriving this past offseason on three-year contracts.

Kickoff for the Capital One Orange Bowl is set for 11 a.m. CT on New Year’s Day with coverage provided on ESPN and the Texas Tech Sports Network.



Link

Continue Reading

Most Viewed Posts

Trending