University of North Carolina midfielder Evelyn Shores isn’t taking a break this summer.
Six months after helping the Tar Heels capture their 23rd NCAA title, she scored the winning goal last month for the U.S. women’s national team against Germany at under-23 level. And on Monday, she found the back of the net again, winning $1million for the US Women at The Soccer Tournament (TST) staged just miles from her university.
Recruited by former USWNT midfielder Heather O’Reilly, 20 years her senior, Shores joined a team of American legends, including O’Reilly, Carli Lloyd and Ali Krieger, for the seven-a-side, winner-takes-all competition.
“I was sprinting back to recover on defense, saw Heather (O’Reilly) win the ball, and just went. I was exhausted, but I had to go,” Shores tells The Athletic. “She put it on a platter for me. I had to finish it.”
Though still jetlagged from her trip across the Atlantic Ocean with the under-23s, Shores went straight into training alongside players she’d watched win World Cups and Olympic gold medals.
“Playing one-v-one in practice with Carli Lloyd the day after flying in from Germany? That was insane,” she says. “They made us feel like equals. That was the craziest part.”
She was one of the five North Carolina (UNC) players O’Reilly invited to join her and the other World Cup winners at TST, which takes place over a week in Cary, North Carolina.
“I have always liked Evelyn as a player, from the first minute I saw her play at Carolina,” O’Reilly tells The Athletic. “I’m thrilled that she had that goal, because she had a very good tournament and does a lot of nuanced work for the team that maybe isn’t flashy, but she had her moment, and we are all so happy about that.”
For Shores, TST was a refreshing change of pace.
“It’s such a fun tournament,” she says. “The ball moves fast, everyone’s pressing, you sub out the second you’re tired, and fans are basically on top of the field. It’s a different kind of soccer — and maybe more exciting for people who aren’t into the traditional 11 v 11 (format).”
Evelyn Shores was one of five UNC players to join USWNT legends at TST. (The Soccer Tournament)
The 20-year-old from Atlanta, Georgia, began her soccer journey at age four at Tophat FC, an elite youth academy in her home state. For Shores, soccer is a family tradition. Her mother, a former North Carolina player, was her first coach. Her grandpa had coached her mom.
“I wrote a letter to myself in fifth grade saying I hoped I’d get a scholarship to UNC. I committed in eighth grade (a child’s aged 13 or 14 year),” Shores said. “I always knew I wanted to come here.”
That commitment has paid off. In her rookie year, she appeared in 13 matches, finishing that season ranked third on the team with four goals, three assists and 11 points, to lead all UNC freshmen. She scored her first college brace in a three-minute stretch against the University of South Carolina, which included her first goal.
But in the October, her promising first season came to a halt. While attempting a tackle near the sideline against Wake Forest, she got tangled up with an opposition player and collapsed, clutching her right knee, unable to stand without help. Five days later, Shores announced she’d torn her ACL and that her season was over.
Amid the heartbreak, she had support from her family and friends throughout the recovery process and she counted the days to her comeback. After two surgeries and a difficult rehabilitation period, Shores returned in 2024 to play in the final 10 games of the season, with her first appearance back coming against No. 1-ranked Duke in the regular-season finale.
“My first goal back from my injury was very special,” she tells The Athletic.
She scored against Duke, UNC’s biggest rival, with her left foot in the 44th minute.
“After such a long time off the field, coming back and scoring was like a huge deal to me,” she says.
Just over a month later, Shores played 44 minutes as UNC beat Wake Forest 1-0 to win the NCAA title.
After recovering from an ACL tear, Evelyn Shores helped UNC to an NCAA title (Bob Donnan/Imagn Images)
Announcing herself with a goal is a habit now.
When Shores was named to the USWNT Under-23 camp last month, she was the only player there not signed to a professional contract. But that didn’t matter on the field. In the final minute of stoppage time on May 30 in the German town of Aspach, after a scramble in the box, Seattle Reign center back Jordyn Bugg lifted a ball over Germany’s defense. Shores got on the end of the looping pass and one-timed the ball into the net.
“It was a surreal experience,” Shores tells The Athletic. “Honestly, I couldn’t even really celebrate after the goal, because I was just so relieved.”
The U.S. split results during the window, losing 2-1 to the Germans a couple of days later, and Shores flew directly back to North Carolina to represent the U.S. in a different capacity. She, again, introduced herself with a game-winning goal.
For now, Shores is focused on a healthy return, another trip to the NCAA College Cup, and if the stars align, TST again next year.
As for the $1million she helped win, for not just herself but the players she’s looked up to? Unfortunately for Shores, NCAA rules prohibit student-athletes from accepting prize money. “I’m not actually sure where my portion goes,” she says with a shrug. “But I’m just happy to be a part of it.”
A spokesperson for TST confirmed that the money that could not be awarded to the college players was divided evenly among the rest of the group.
While her TST goal may be the most high-profile moment yet, it’s likely just the beginning for the rising college junior. She’s still undecided about whether she’ll pursue a professional career in the U.S. or abroad, but one thing’s clear: she’s got options.
“I’ve always wanted to be a pro. That’s been the dream since I was little,” she said.
“This will be my first healthy preseason in a while,” Shores said, speaking about her immediate future. “Just being back on the field, competing, playing with teammates I love, it’s all been surreal.”
(Top photo: The Soccer Tournament)