Connect with us

NIL

Alabama attorney, former UA athlete weigh in on NCAA, power conference's potential NIL settlement

NEWS AT SIX STARTS NOW. AND THANKS SO MUCH FOR JOINING US HERE AT 6:00. I’M BRITTANY DECKER I’M GUY RAWLINGS TONIGHT. THE CONVERSATION AROUND NAME, IMAGE AND LIKENESS CONTINUES AS COLLEGES ACROSS THE COUNTRY STRUGGLE TO RETAIN STUDENT ATHLETES. THE UNIVERSITY OF ALABAMA RE-EMPHASIZING THEIR YEE ALABAMA PROGRAM, WHERE FANS CAN MAKE A ONE […]

Published

on

Alabama attorney, former UA athlete weigh in on NCAA, power conference's potential NIL settlement

NEWS AT SIX STARTS NOW. AND THANKS SO MUCH FOR JOINING US HERE AT 6:00. I’M BRITTANY DECKER I’M GUY RAWLINGS TONIGHT. THE CONVERSATION AROUND NAME, IMAGE AND LIKENESS CONTINUES AS COLLEGES ACROSS THE COUNTRY STRUGGLE TO RETAIN STUDENT ATHLETES. THE UNIVERSITY OF ALABAMA RE-EMPHASIZING THEIR YEE ALABAMA PROGRAM, WHERE FANS CAN MAKE A ONE TIME CONTRIBUTION OR SEND IN MONEY ONCE A MONTH TO GET EXCLUSIVE MERCHANDISE AND ACCESS TO EVENTS. ALL THE MONEY WOULD GO TO THE SCHOOL’S NIL FUND. THE UNIVERSITY HOPES TO GET MORE PEOPLE TO JOIN THE PROGRAM. OUR WVTM 13 ZOE BLAIR SPOKE TO FANS TODAY WHO SUPPORT YEE ALABAMA, BUT STILL HAVE SOME FRUSTRATIONS. NAME, IMAGE AND LIKENESS. NIL HAS CHANGED THE WORLD OF COLLEGE ATHLETICS. I THINK IT’S GREAT FOR THE STUDENT ATHLETE. I THINK IT’S GREAT FOR THE UNIVERSITY. LONGTIME ALABAMA FAN TODD LOGAN SUPPORTS THE NEW SYSTEM FOR THE MOST PART. TO ME, IT SEEMS LIKE THERE’S MORE RESTRICTIONS IN THE NFL THAN THERE IS IN COLLEGE, AND THAT’S WHAT’S A JOKE TO ME. HE’S TALKING ABOUT THE TRANSFER PORTAL. LOGAN SAYS IF ATHLETES ARE GOING TO GET PAID, THEN THERE SHOULD BE STRICTER RULES. I DON’T KNOW A TON ABOUT IT, BUT I DO THINK THAT THAT’S THE ONE THAT NEEDS TO BE CONTROLLED. WHETHER IT’S A LIMIT ON HOW MANY TRANSFERS YOU CAN DO OR, YOU KNOW, I DON’T WANT TO SAY A SALARY CAP, BUT IT’S JUST A LOT, A LOT INVOLVED TO TO MAKE IT ALL WORK. RIGHT. BUT IT’S NOT ALL BAD. HE SAYS HE’S A FAN OF THE SYSTEM THE CRIMSON TIDE HAS IN PLACE. I THINK ALABAMA HAS A GREAT NIL PROGRAM WITH YEE, ALABAMA. IT’S VERY WELL RUN. THE UNIVERSITY IS HOPING MORE PEOPLE JOIN THAT PROGRAM. ATHLETIC DIRECTOR GREG BYRNE PUT THIS STATEMENT OUT ON SOCIAL MEDIA ON WEDNESDAY, EXPLAINING WHY THEY NEED FAN SUPPORT TO CONTINUE TO BE COMPETITIVE ACROSS THE BOARD. BYRNE SAYS IN PART, A SUBSCRIPTION TO YEE ALABAMA ISN’T ABOUT THE NAIL, IT’S ABOUT THE FUTURE. IT’S ABOUT ROSTER RETENTION FOR FUTURE SEASONS. LOGAN AGREES, SAYING IT’S IMPORTANT TO INVEST IN EVERY SPORT, NOT JUST FOOTBALL. WE’RE SEASON TICKET HOLDERS FOR BASKETBALL AND I THINK THAT’S VERY IMPORTANT. ALSO, EVERYBODY THINKS ABOUT FOOTBALL, BUT YOU KNOW, YOUR BASKETBALL, YOUR BASEBALL, EVERYTHING ELSE GYMNASTICS. I MEAN IT’S ALL AFFECTED. IT’S NOT JUST YOUR FOOTBALL PLAYERS. LOGAN ISN’T THE ONLY ONE VOICING CONCERNS. EARLIER THIS YEAR, FORMER CRIMSON TIDE HEAD COACH NICK SABAN SPOKE TO LAWMAKERS ABOUT HIS CONCERNS WI

Advertisement

Local attorney, former UA athlete weigh in on NCAA, power conference’s potential NIL settlement

Video above: University of Alabama seeking support for NIL collective A U.S. district judge in California is conducting a hearing Monday to hear arguments about a proposed settlement that would end a five-year lawsuit against the NCAA and five power conferences. If approved, it would allow colleges and universities to pay athletes. That’s beyond the money student-athletes are already allowed to make from name, image and likeness.Birmingham sports attorney Rick Davis played for Bear Bryant at the University of Alabama and then went on to play in the NFL. He has paid attention to the huge changes college sports have gone through in recent years since players have been allowed to profit from their names, images and likenesses. He said, “It’s changed the whole game. It’s becoming more of a professional, you know, than it is going to school to play for the school and get your education.” The settlement that a U.S. district court judge will soon make a ruling on could mean even more changes. Referred to as the “House” settlement, it would allow colleges and universities to pay players directly. Davis wants it to include some restrictions as well that would keep players from making so many transfers. He said, “The restrictions that used to be in place are no longer in place. And that’s what hopefully this will address that and make it to where you can’t have a merry-go-round every year of players, or it’s a revolving door for guys to come here for one year, and then they’ll go somewhere else in the next year.”It’s expected that this settlement will give the NCAA, along with the SEC, ACC, Big 10, Big 12 and Pac-12, more name, image and likeness oversight. But Davis doesn’t think it will end the lawsuits. He added, “There’ll be other lawsuits even once this settlement is done. There’ll be people that they’re not, they’re not a part of it.”

Video above: University of Alabama seeking support for NIL collective

A U.S. district judge in California is conducting a hearing Monday to hear arguments about a proposed settlement that would end a five-year lawsuit against the NCAA and five power conferences.

Advertisement

If approved, it would allow colleges and universities to pay athletes. That’s beyond the money student-athletes are already allowed to make from name, image and likeness.

Birmingham sports attorney Rick Davis played for Bear Bryant at the University of Alabama and then went on to play in the NFL. He has paid attention to the huge changes college sports have gone through in recent years since players have been allowed to profit from their names, images and likenesses. He said, “It’s changed the whole game. It’s becoming more of a professional, you know, than it is going to school to play for the school and get your education.”

The settlement that a U.S. district court judge will soon make a ruling on could mean even more changes. Referred to as the “House” settlement, it would allow colleges and universities to pay players directly. Davis wants it to include some restrictions as well that would keep players from making so many transfers. He said, “The restrictions that used to be in place are no longer in place. And that’s what hopefully this will address that and make it to where you can’t have a merry-go-round every year of players, or it’s a revolving door for guys to come here for one year, and then they’ll go somewhere else in the next year.”

It’s expected that this settlement will give the NCAA, along with the SEC, ACC, Big 10, Big 12 and Pac-12, more name, image and likeness oversight. But Davis doesn’t think it will end the lawsuits. He added, “There’ll be other lawsuits even once this settlement is done. There’ll be people that they’re not, they’re not a part of it.”

NIL

Oregon Ducks, Ohio State Surprising Rankings

On the 2025 Oregon Ducks football team, senior wide receiver Evan Stewart looks to be the biggest Name, Image, Likeness (NIL) earner. The six-foot Texas native has a valuation worth $1.7 million and roster value placed at $761K which ranks as the No. 26 highest from a recruit in the country, on On3 NIL Valuations. […]

Published

on


On the 2025 Oregon Ducks football team, senior wide receiver Evan Stewart looks to be the biggest Name, Image, Likeness (NIL) earner. The six-foot Texas native has a valuation worth $1.7 million and roster value placed at $761K which ranks as the No. 26 highest from a recruit in the country, on On3 NIL Valuations.

Next for the Ducks is Tulane Green Wave transfer running back Makhi Hughes. The redshirt junior is ranked No. 58 among his peers with both an NIL valuation and roster value of $1.1 million.

Tulane Green Wave running back Makhi Hughes (21) runs the ball as Memphis Tigers defensive back Cameron Smith (29)

Oct 13, 2023; Memphis, Tennessee, USA; Tulane Green Wave running back Makhi Hughes (21) runs the ball as Memphis Tigers defensive back Cameron Smith (29) makes the tackle during the second half at Simmons Bank Liberty Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Petre Thomas-Imagn Images / Petre Thomas-Imagn Images

Across the Big Ten Conference’s NIL average per recruit in the 2026 class, Oregon coach Dan Lanning’s team is ranked No. 3. A surprising team is No. 1, topping Oregon and College Football Playoff National Champions Ohio State Buckeyes.

Here are how the 18 college football programs stack up with each other:

No. 1 Maryland Terrapins ($190K)

No. 2 Ohio State Buckeyes ($158K)

No. 3 Oregon Ducks ($152K)

“I think it’s impressive that guys like Kirby (Smart) have been signing the number one class in the nation without any NIL money this entire time… But if you want to be a top 10 team in college football, you better have great support. We have that. It’s our alignment with our entire university that makes our recruiting work.”

– Dan Lanning via The Pat McAfee Show

Oregon coach Dan Lanning oversees his team as the Fighting Ducks face off against Mighty Oregon in the spring game

Oregon coach Dan Lanning oversees his team as the Fighting Ducks face off against Mighty Oregon in the Oregon Ducks spring game on April 26, 2025, at Autzen Stadium in Eugene. / Ben Lonergan/The Register-Guard / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

No. 4 USC Trojans ($143K)

No. 5 Michigan Wolverines ($134K)

No. 6 Washington Huskies ($95K)

No. 7 Penn State Nittany Lions ($70K)

Penn State football head coach James Franklin greets recruits and their families following the Blue-White game

Penn State football head coach James Franklin greets recruits and their families following the Blue-White game at Beaver Stadium on Saturday, April 26, 2025, in State College. The White team defeated the Blue team, 10-8. / Dan Rainville / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

Tied for No. 8 Rutgers Scarlet Knights ($40K)

Tied for No. 8 Nebraska Cornhuskers ($40K)

No. 10 UCLA Bruins ($39K)

No. 11 Michigan State Spartans ($38K)

No. 12 Iowa Hawkeyes ($37K)

No. 13 Minnesota Golden Gophers ($25K)

Tied for No. 134 Illinois Fighting Illini ($22K)

Tied for No. 13 Northwestern Wildcats ($22K)

No. 16 Indiana Hoosiers ($19.6K)

Indiana Head Coach Curt Cignetti watches as the Hoosiers get ready before the start of the Indiana football spring game

Indiana Head Coach Curt Cignetti watches as the Hoosiers get ready before the start of the Indiana football spring game at Memorial Stadium on Thursday, April 17, 2025. / Rich Janzaruk/Herald-Times / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

No. 17 Wisconsin Badgers ($13.9K)

No. 18 Purdue Boilermakers ($13.3K)

MORE: Dallas Cowboys Wide Receiver Traeshon Holden ‘Hurt’ After Going Undrafted

MORE: 5-Star Quarterback Jared Curtis To Commit To Oregon Ducks, Georgia Bulldogs?

MORE: Best Uniforms In Big Ten Ranked: Oregon Ducks, Michigan Wolverines, Ohio State Snubbed?

The Big Ten was arguably the most competitive league in college football in 2024, ahead of the Southeastern Conference. That’s simply based on the fact that the Big Ten had four teams invited into the 2024 College Football Playoff field (No. 1 Oregon, No. 6 Penn State, No. 8 Ohio State, No. 10 Indiana), one more than the SEC’s three teams (No. 2 Georgia Bulldogs, No. 5 Texas Longhorns, No. 9 Tennessee Volunteers).

Within On3’s top 100 NIL valuations, 23 total recruits come from the Big Ten. The SEC has 37 total recruits. Texas junior quarterback Arch Manning of the SEC is the No. 1 ranked player with a valuation worth a whooping $6.6 million and roster value placed at $4.2 million. Ohio State sophomore wide receiver Jeremiah Smith of the Big Ten stands at $4 million and $3.2 million, respectively.

Ohio State Buckeye head coach Ryan Day looks away from the field

Ohio State Buckeye head coach Ryan Day looks away from the field of play after a dropped pass in the 2nd half during the spring game at Ohio Stadium on April 12, 2025. / Kyle Robertson/Columbus Dispatch / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

The Buckeyes and coach Ryan Day won the national championship after an opening round win by taking care of the No. 12 Clemson Tigers, upsetting the Ducks at the Rose Bowl in the next round, then beating the Longhorns at the Cotton Bowl, and finally overcoming the No. 7 Notre Dame Fighting Irish to win it all.



Link

Continue Reading

NIL

Report: Saban expected to co-chair Trump’s commission on college sports

Former Alabama head coach Nick Saban is expected to co-chair President Donald Trump’s commission on college sports, a source told Sam Khan Jr. of The Athletic. The commission would examine issues surrounding college sports, including NIL payments, conference alignment, and more, Yahoo Sports’ Ross Dellenger reports. Trump is also considering an executive order to scrutinize […]

Published

on


Former Alabama head coach Nick Saban is expected to co-chair President Donald Trump’s commission on college sports, a source told Sam Khan Jr. of The Athletic.

The commission would examine issues surrounding college sports, including NIL payments, conference alignment, and more, Yahoo Sports’ Ross Dellenger reports.

Trump is also considering an executive order to scrutinize NIL that could involve Saban, according to Josh Dawsey, Rachel Bachman, and Laine Higgins of the Wall Street Journal. Saban and Trump met late last week as the ex-Crimson Tide coach delivered a commencement speech at Alabama.

The potential commission and executive order are being discussed as the House v. NCAA settlement is expected to be entering its final stages.

Saban spent 28 seasons as an NCAA head coach, 17 of which were spent with Alabama. The 73-year-old amassed a 297-71-1 record with Toledo, Michigan State, LSU, and the Crimson Tide. He also won seven national championships.

Texas Tech board chair Cody Campbell is also expected to lead the commission, sources told Dellenger. Campbell’s previous business ventures include selling an oil gas company for $4.1 billion, according to On3’s Pete Nakos.



Link

Continue Reading

NIL

Compton’s Home Run Sends Shockers to Quarterfinals

Story Links Next Game: vs. North Texas 5/8/2025 | 11:00 A.M. May. 08 (Thu) / 11:00 A.M. vs. North Texas History TAMPA, Fla. – Camryn Compton’s three-run home run in the bottom of the sixth pushed No. 5 seed Wichita State to a […]

Published

on


TAMPA, Fla. – Camryn Compton’s three-run home run in the bottom of the sixth pushed No. 5 seed Wichita State to a 5-2 win over No. 8 seed Tulsa in the second round of the American Athletic Conference Championship Wednesday afternoon.

Wichita State (29-24-1) advances to Thursday’s American quarterfinals where they will face No. 4 North Texas at 11 a.m. CT on ESPN+.

The Shockers were limited to just four hits in the game, but Compton’s 12th home run of the season proved to be the difference. Taylor Sedlacek doubled and scored two runs, Ellee Eck singled and drove in a run and Brookelyn Livanec singled to round out the hits.

Co-Freshman of the Year Ryley Nihart (11-7) went the distance in the circle, allowing only one earned run on seven hits and three walks.

A leadoff double to start the game turned into an early run on a Camryn Compton throwing error, giving Tulsa a 1-0 lead after the first inning.

Tulsa doubled its lead to 2-0 in the top of the second on a one-out, solo home run.

Wichita State cut the deficit in half in the bottom of the third on Eck’s RBI single after a Livanec single and Sami Hood sac bunt.

In the bottom of the fourth, the Shockers tied the game at 2-2 on Jodie Epperson’s sac fly. Sedlacek led off the inning with a double and then moved up to third on Compton’s sac bunt.

To open the bottom of the sixth, Eck and Sedlacek both reached on hit by pitches to set the scene for Compton. On the very first pitch of the at bat, Compton smashed a no-doubter over the wall in left.

 



Link

Continue Reading

NIL

Nick Saban Joins Donald Trump In Move To Back Up NIL Claims

© Gary Cosby Jr./Imagn Nick Saban believes the college athletics landscape, particularly in college football, is broken. The legendary Alabama head coach believes NIL is a large reason that it is broken. He believes that someone needs to step in quickly in order to fix it, lest we risk the sport imploding altogether. And as the saying […]

Published

on


© Gary Cosby Jr./Imagn

Nick Saban believes the college athletics landscape, particularly in college football, is broken. The legendary Alabama head coach believes NIL is a large reason that it is broken. He believes that someone needs to step in quickly in order to fix it, lest we risk the sport imploding altogether. And as the saying goes, if you want something done right, sometimes you have to do it yourself.

Ralph Russo of The Athletic reports that Saban will serve as the co-chair of the President Donald Trump’s commission for college sports. Saban is expected to serve alongside Texas Tech board of regents chairman Cody Campbell in the position. The commission is expected to examine several issues facing the future of college sports, not the least of which is how NIL is regulated.

Back in January, Saban spoke passionately about his concern for the future of college athletics should NIL continue to go unregulated.

Nick Saban Expressed Concerns About Unregulated NIL Prior To Taking New Position

“All I’m saying? The people out there need to know this model is unsustainable,” he said during an appearance on the Pat McAfee Show ahead of Monday’s national championship game. “It’s not good for players.”

“Players need to get compensated, no doubt. But it has to be done in a way where, you know, in some kind of way, have competitive balance, you know, and that every school has the same thing,” he continued. “One school can’t spend $30 million for players while another school’s spending $3 million.”

His comments drew criticism from fans who believed he enjoyed a similar advantage while at Alabama. But they’re also not without merit. Administrators at several universities have expressed concerns about the future viability of their programs. Ohio State president Ted Carter already acknowledged his intent to cut programs in order to further spend on revenue sports, and other schools are widely expected to follow suit.

Who knows whether Saban and the commission find a solution within the law? But it’s nice to see that someone is at least trying.





Link

Continue Reading

NIL

What Can Come From The New College Sports Commission?

In a move that could reshape the landscape of college athletics, Texas Tech collective founder Cody Campbell is stepping into a new role alongside legendary football coach Nick Saban. The two will serve as co-chairs of President Donald Trump’s college sports commission. This panel is designed to tackle the evolving challenges of collegiate athletics. The […]

Published

on


In a move that could reshape the landscape of college athletics, Texas Tech collective founder Cody Campbell is stepping into a new role alongside legendary football coach Nick Saban. The two will serve as co-chairs of President Donald Trump’s college sports commission. This panel is designed to tackle the evolving challenges of collegiate athletics. The most important topic they hope to address is Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) deals and other financial deals for college athletes.

A Powerhouse Duo

Campbell is a former Texas Tech football player and current Board of Regents chairman. He is also one of the most prominent donors for the Red Raiders. He is the co-founder and co-executive of Double Eagle Energy Holdings. It is an oil and gas company that operates extensively in the Permian Basin region of West Texas. Campbell made headlines when he sold Double Eagle for a staggering $4.1 billion in April of this year. His contributions financial to the school have landed his name on the field at Jones AT&T Stadium in Lubbock.

Meanwhile, Saban, the former LSU and Alabama head football coach, has been a vocal critic of the current state of college athletics. Specifically, he has been advocating for more structure and regulation in the NIL era. It’s become commonplace to see Saban ranting about the need for change on College GameDay in the fall. Together, these two figures bring a unique blend of business acumen and coaching expertise. Campbell’s experience in high-stakes financial deals and Saban’s deep understanding of college athletics could prove instrumental in shaping policies that ensure fairness, sustainability, and competitive balance.

Cody Campbell
Texas Tech University System Board of Regents Chairman Cody Campbell listens to U.S. Department of Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins speak to other Texas Tech leaders at the USDA Agricultural Marketing Service Cotton Classification Complex. Photo courtesy: Mateo Rosiles/ Avalanche-Journal / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

The Commission’s Mission

The commission, spearheaded by President Trump, aims to address key issues plaguing college sports. This includes unrestricted player movement via the NCAA transfer portal, unregulated booster payments, athlete employment status, and Title IX implications. Calls on Congress to get involved are not new to any of these situations in the history of college athletics. But once NIL deals became a part of the landscape, the calls to D.C. grew in number and volume. The commission’s work could set the foundation for a more structured approach to collegiate sports governance.

Why Would Campbell Join?

It’s no secret that the wild, wild West nature of NIL and collectives has greatly benefited Texas Tech. Campbell, head football coach Joey McGuire, and his Red Raider team have burst into the national landscape. After seemingly coming out of nowhere to be the most active team in the fall portal window, Texas Tech has continued to add key pieces in the spring window. So why would Campbell want to actively corral the NIL landscape. Why change when it has positioned his alma mater in a position it’s never been in before? Campbell has called for reform publicly multiple times in the past. His most recent came in light of the Nico Iamaleva unceremonious exit from Tennessee. Campbell’s public comments appear to be looking out for the rest of college athletics beyond the big revenue sports (football and men’s basketball).

In a piece penned on The Federalist on April 14th, Campbell said, “Lost in all of this are the 500,000+ student athletes who are not receiving multi-million dollar deals and have no voice at the table”. Campbell is calling for rules that allow NIL contracts to be enforced. In addition, he is seeking one set of laws to be followed, and not state legislature ruling the day. He also wants to ensure athletes remain student-athletes and not employees. Campbell argues, “establishing this non-employee status will help to limit the cost burden of sponsoring an intercollegiate sport, and ensure that benefits like a scholarship are not taxable as income.” Perhaps the most significant reason, though he is calling on action, is to get everyone to play on the same money field.

Searching For Equal Money Sharing

“College sports do not currently have the right to take the same approach [as the NFL], as they do not have protection under the Sports Broadcasting Act of 1961, as do the professional leagues. Through inclusion in the Sports Broadcasting Act, colleges would gain the right to pool and jointly market their media rights, and install a media revenue distribution system that would significantly increase total revenue and would promote parity.” Campbell’s quest to protect all of college athletics appears noble. The cynic would argue that if Campbell played is football at a Big 10/SEC school, he would not have this same stance.

What’s Next?

There is no way to determine the exact impact the commission would have on the college sports landscape. After all, there are still potential landmark agreements to settle in a trio of antitrust lawsuits facing the NCAA. Most notably, it would allow for the first time a system of direct payments from schools to athletes.

Campbell and Saban’s leadership will be pivotal in shaping the future of college athletics. As the commission begins its work, all eyes will be on these two. College athletics will see how, or even if, they can properly steer the future of college athletics in a direction that works for all.

Main Image: Gary Cosby Jr.-Tuscaloosa News



Link

Continue Reading

NIL

Season of major parity for college football in 2025? Deep contender field looks to break glass ceiling

There’s a better-than-decent chance the preseason AP Top 25’s release will represent a shift in the college football landscape. The last decade has seen only four teams — Ohio State (1), Alabama (5), Clemson (2), Georgia (2) — hold the distinction of preseason No. 1. That’s likely to change in a few months.  Texas is […]

Published

on


There’s a better-than-decent chance the preseason AP Top 25’s release will represent a shift in the college football landscape. The last decade has seen only four teams — Ohio State (1), Alabama (5), Clemson (2), Georgia (2) — hold the distinction of preseason No. 1. That’s likely to change in a few months. 

Texas is the favorite to start in the top spot. It did so in 247Sports’ post-spring Top 25. CBS Sports’ Brandon Marcello has Ohio State at No. 1 in his post-spring top 25. Penn State could find itself ranked No. 1 like it did in Joel Klatt’s post-spring Top 25.

LSU, Oregon, and Notre Dame at least belong in the conversation. Clemson, which hasn’t really been part of the national title discussion since the advent of NIL, got my vote for preseason No. 1 in 247Sports’ too-early Top 25 voting.

There’s a fluidity among the 2025 projected contenders we haven’t seen in the last decade. Obviously, Ohio State, Georgia and Alabama haven’t gone away. But it no longer feels obvious that one of those recruiting juggernauts — they’ve made up the top three of the 247Sports Team Talent Composite rankings for seven straight years — is destined to win the national championship.

There’s a new era of parity in college football … sort of.  

Parity to a degree

Yes, NIL and the transfer portal have closed the gap in college football. But it also depends on what gap you’re talking about. In the end, high school recruiting remains the ultimate separator.

Have portal boons led to leaps in talent level for teams like Arizona State or Texas Tech? Absolutely. But there’s a reason why every national champion since 2013 reached Bud Elliott’s Blue Chip Ratio (in which 50% of its roster made up of four-star recruits or better). There’s a baseline of talent required to win in college football, especially in an era where teams must win three or four playoff games to earn a national title. Last year, Arizona State came within an eyelash of upsetting Texas, but the Sun Devils still had Ohio State and Notre Dame between them and a national title.

But it’s worth noting the difference between Georgia at No. 2 in the 2024 Team Talent Composite and say, Penn State at No. 11, is smaller than it’s ever been. That’s not because of the number of five-stars on each roster. Georgia is still more top heavy. Instead, it’s about depth. 

Blue Chip Ratio for 2024 season

Take Texas, for example.

The Longhorns — which came in at No. 4 in the 2024 Team Talent Composite — had two defensive tackles drafted on Day 2 of the 2025 NFL Draft. No problem, right? Just plug and go thanks to your recruiting wins. 

Not so fast. 

Seven DTs played 10-plus snaps behind that drafted pair for Texas last season. Two graduated. Four entered the transfer portal.

That’s how you get to a place where Texas, after four straight top-six recruiting classes, must sign FIVE defensive tackles in the portal. 

You can see examples like that across all the top rosters. Georgia lost the No. 3 player in the portal, Damon Wilson, to Missouri. Alabama lost its starting right tackle Elijah Pritchett to Nebraska. Clemson lost part-time starting DT Tre Williams to Michigan.

The top programs still have more talent than anyone, but other teams spend big to upgrade their rosters through the transfer portal. That makes keeping

depth pieces happy more difficult than it was a decade ago — when Nick Saban could basically stash a high-profile recruit for two or three years before they emerged as fully formed monsters. In this era, those players transfer after a season or two to get on the field. 

So, yes, there’s a still a gap in talent between Georgia and Penn State. But it’s a lot smaller than it was five years ago.

Legit roster questions for the usual favorites

Let’s run through the usual list of favorites — all of which ranked in the top five of the 2024 Team Talent Composite — and poke some holes in their 2025 chances.

Ohio State: The Buckeyes will either start Julian Sayin (12 career pass attempts) or Lincoln Kienholz (22 career pass attempts) at quarterback. They’re replacing two first-round picks on the offensive line, two Day 2 picks at running back and eight draft picks on defense. I haven’t even mentioned the loss of offensive coordinator Chip Kelly and defensive coordinator Jim Knowles. That’s a lot!

Georgia: Gunner Stockton solidified the starting QB role for Georgia in the Sugar Bowl. But it’s worth noting the Bulldogs were hunting transfer portal quarterbacks before that performance. He’s got a lot to prove. So do his receivers in a reworked room that suffered from drop issues a season ago.

Georgia faces questions along its defensive front after losing four starters to the NFL. The Bulldogs also produced their worst pass defense since 2020 last season and lost starting safeties Malaki Starks and Dan Jackson to the draft.

Alabama: We all watched the Vanderbilt and Georgia games from last season. Alabama, despite returning the 35th most production in the FBS, has a ton to prove next season in Year 2 under Kalen DeBoer.

Texas: Yep, the Longhorns belong here after two straight trips to the CFB semifinals. But Arch Manning, despite all the hype, has only really played significant snaps against UTSA, ULM and Mississippi State. His receivers are unproven. Both Texas’ offensive tackles got drafted. The defensive tackle room — the source of Texas’ defensive dominance the last two years — is completely reworked.

Will those teams be fine? Probably! I’d be shocked if any won fewer than nine or 10 games. But their rosters present enough questions to ponder some teams outside the usual suspects. 

Texas QB Arch Manning is uber talented, but the Longhorns are breaking in a group of new receivers and offensive linemen in 2025.
Getty Images

The other options

Penn State: NIL usually is mentioned with roster acquisitions: “Who can my favorite team go out and buy in the portal?” But Michigan and Ohio State have shown retention is the key over the past two seasons. Not necessarily retention with portal, though that’s important. Instead, retention with the NFL Draft.

Both Michigan and Ohio State convinced critical starters to return to school, largely because the NIL dollars they received were comparable to what they could have earned in the pros. This year Penn State quarterback Drew Allar, running backs Nicholas Singleton and Kaytron Allen and defensive lineman Dani Dennis-Sutton and Zane Durant all passed on the draft.

Thus, Penn State has the 33rd-most returning production in college football coming off a season where they were a few snaps away from a national title berth. Throw in a few key acquisitions in the portal, particularly at wide receiver, and the Nittany LIons are in the best position they has ever been under James Franklin.

Clemson: The latest CBS Sports mock draft has two Clemson players going in the top 10 next year, and other outlets have as many as six Tigers going in the first round. That shows the level of talent in Death Valley for a program brings back the most production of any team in the FBS. Throw in a few key portal additions — Dabo Swinney’s first ever non-walk-on-QB transfer takes — and the Tigers have the most proven roster in college football, including the potential No.1 overall pick in the 2026 NFL Draft in Cade Klubnik. 

Again, I have Clemson right now as the best team in college football and believe the Tigers are a strong favorite to win the ACC. Clemson being +1400 to win the national championship is tasty. There’s great value there. The Tigers are also +145 to win the ACC, per FanDuel Sportsbook. 

LSU: There’s an argument that Garrett Nussmeier is the top returning quarterback in college football this season. Add his presence to the No. 1 transfer portal class in the country, and the Tigers have filled almost every roster hole you can think of this offseason. If a re-armed defense can take a step forward, Brian Kelly will have a playoff team (and maybe much more) in Year 4. 

Meanwhile, Oregon and Notre Dame both also profile as contenders once again if their new QBs pan out the way the recruiting industry expects them to. That’s nine legit contenders entering 2025, and that’s not even counting teams like Auburn, Florida, Miami, Michigan and Texas A&M that all have an outside chance to force their way into the conversation if things break right. 

The run up to the preseason feels different for a reason. For the first time in a decade, more than just a handful of teams profile as contenders. It’s not true parity. It’s still very difficult to imagine a team outside the top 20 of the Team Talent Composite winning a national title. But for a sport so long occupied by just a handful of programs, the door finally feels like it’s cracked open for a few more. 





Link

Continue Reading

Most Viewed Posts

Trending