A familiar face has returned to Fayette with a new mission to bring fitness, community, and youth athletic development to town.
Elijah Nagbe, a 2010 graduate of Central Methodist University with a degree in recreational sports management, opened a 24-hour fitness facility in Eagle Plaza last November, which has since moved to a larger property on the north side of the courthouse square. The Gym opened in its current location on April 21, which more than doubles the size of Nagbe’s original location.
“I’ve always had a goal of opening a gym,” said Nagbe, who spent 15 years in Kansas City working in the fitness industry, training both youth and adult clients. “Kansas City was oversaturated, and even Columbia was close. But Fayette had potential,” he said. “All it needed was someone passionate about fitness who could bring that out in others.”
The Gym is open 24/7 and features a variety of equipment, including treadmills, a stair climber, a rowing machine, a bike, a machine that mimics the movements of skiing, free weights, machines, and a turf area. Members access the facility through a mobile app and can enter and leave at their convenience. Memberships are competitively priced, flexible, with no contracts and easy cancellation. The cost of a single membership is $30 per month. A couple’s membership is $40 a month, and a family membership for two adults and two children up to age 23 (if enrolled in school) is $50 a month.
Already about 110 members have subscribed, and Nagbe says he sees consistent early morning and evening crowds. The busiest time of day is between 5 and 7 p.m., while a loyal group of early risers arrives daily between 5 and 7 a.m.
A professional bodybuilder, Nagbe also offers one-on-one personal training, with rates ranging from $45 to $55 per person based on session frequency. Personal training includes warm-ups, guided workouts with proper form and safety instruction, cool-downs, and ongoing guidance. While not a registered dietitian, Nagbe offers nutritional recommendations and helps clients track their habits.
“Fitness has done a lot for me,” Nagbe said. “I want people to give me a chance to show them what it can do for them.”
The Gym’s current space was originally built as a Dollar General store. After sitting empty since the store moved to a larger location on South Church Street, it was purchased by Central Methodist, housing the Eagles’ e-sports and golf teams. The original location on the west side of the square in the new Eagle Plaza proved to be too small. Later, when a new restaurant, LaFayette on the Square, decided to become the building’s anchor on the southwest corner, it quickly became apparent it needed more space. The university was quick to offer The Gym a larger space in its former e-sports location, which allowed Nagbe to expand his long-term goals to include youth sports performance training.
With a turf area already in place, Nagbe envisions small group training sessions focusing on strength, conditioning, and agility for student-athletes. His prior experience training kids ages 6-18 through in Kansas City is a key part of his vision for expanding youth programs in Fayette.
“I look at places like Harrisburg where youth athletics are thriving,” he said. “Fayette has the kids to do the same. They just need someone to help guide them.”
Nagbe emphasizes communication with members, regularly seeking feedback on what equipment or services to add next. Plans are in motion to add a leg press and possibly more cardio machines soon.
The Gym also features two private bathrooms with showers and offers a $15 guest pass, though first-timers can often try the facility for free by contacting Nagbe directly through The Gym’s website at thegymfayette.com.
In addition to running The Gym, Nagbe also works at Commercial Trust Company and keeps busy with both responsibilities. “I’m here by 4:45 every morning,” he said. “Then I work a full day at the bank and return to the gym in the evening. It’s long hours, but I love it.”
Last week, Nagbe held his first-ever Ladies Night, introducing around a dozen area women to The Gym.
“We’re a place where everyone feels welcome, encouraged, and uplifted, no matter where they are in their fitness journey,” Nagbe said about the special event.
“We’re more than just weights and workouts, we’re building a community.”
The Gym can be found online at thegymfayette.com, on Instagram (@_thegymfayette), and Facebook (The Gym – Fayette). Nagbe also posts motivational content and encourages followers to take part in his personal challenge of spending 30 minutes a day in nature, a streak he intends to personally maintain every day in 2025.
“This isn’t just about weights,” he said. “It’s about showing people that movement, health, and community can change your life.”