NIL
‘Bizarre System’ – Paul Finebaum Warns NIL Could Eventually Break College Football, Backs Kirby Smart’s Concerns
As Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) deals and the transfer portal reshape the College Football landscape, analyst Paul Finebaum sounds the alarm, warning of the potential decline of a sport that is very close to America’s heart. In a recent interview on McElroy and Cubelic in the Morning, Finebaum called the current state of college […]

As Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) deals and the transfer portal reshape the College Football landscape, analyst Paul Finebaum sounds the alarm, warning of the potential decline of a sport that is very close to America’s heart.
In a recent interview on McElroy and Cubelic in the Morning, Finebaum called the current state of college football an “existential threat,” referring to concerns raised by Georgia Bulldogs head coach Kirby Smart.
The ‘Bizarre System’ of College Football Can Break the Sport Says Paul Finebaum
Finebaum didn’t mince words when asked about the health of college football.
“I think college football is at a tipping point,” he said, pointing to the massive shifts in the sport’s landscape brought by NIL and the transfer portal.
While the 2024 season delivered some of the most thrilling moments in the sport’s history, like Alabama’s upset over Georgia and Michigan’s gritty Big Ten title run, it also highlighted off-field issues that are creating a slow-burning disconnect.
Finebaum noted that older fans, the backbone of college football’s loyal base, are growing frustrated. The lack of player loyalty, fueled by a transfer portal that allows athletes to leave “at a moment’s notice,” is eroding the emotional ties that bind fans to their teams.
Finebaum’s claims aren’t bogus; the numbers from the previous season show how on the money the analyst’s claims are. For example, in 2024, over 3,000 players entered the transfer portal, a 20% increase from 2022. This churn, combined with NIL deals that can see freshmen earning six-figure sums, has created what Finebaum calls a “bizarre system.”
Kirby Smart, speaking at a Regions Bank event in October 2024, highlighted the absurdity, saying, “It’s not right for a freshman to be paid more than an upperclassman.” Finebaum agrees with the statement, arguing that the issue isn’t players earning money but the lack of commitment to schools that makes the fans cheer for a team.
The Fan Disconnect
College football thrives on tradition. Rivals like Ohio State-Michigan or the Iron Bowl carry the emotions of generations of fans. But according to Finebaum, when players can switch teams with ease, that connection drops.
He acknowledges that the sport’s on-field product remains compelling for sponsors, as the viewership for the 2024 College Football Playoff hit 22.6 million for the championship game. Still, the disconnect can potentially “break” the sport off-field.
KEEP READING: Paul Finebaum Rips New CFP Format
Television executives and administrators may shrug off these concerns, but Finebaum believes the trickle-down effect is inevitable.
In the end, College football isn’t doomed, but it’s at a crossroads. Finebaum’s hope lies in the games themselves, which still captivate millions each Saturday. Yet, as Kirby Smart’s concerns highlight, the sport must address its “bizarre system” to preserve its soul. Without reforms, the disconnect could grow.
College Sports Network has you covered with the latest news, analysis, insights, and trending stories in college football, men’s college basketball, women’s college basketball, and college baseball!
NIL
Permitted, prohibited or under consi
Texas just passed a bill for NIL for ages 17 and up, but still hasn’t approved high school athletes to profit. The Lone Star State is one of seven states that still has not approved NIL, but nearly 40 have already passed into law some sort of Name, Image and Likeness guidelines to all high […]

Texas just passed a bill for NIL for ages 17 and up, but still hasn’t approved high school athletes to profit.
The Lone Star State is one of seven states that still has not approved NIL, but nearly 40 have already passed into law some sort of Name, Image and Likeness guidelines to all high school school athletes to profit.
Here’s where all 50 states (and one district) stand on allowing NIL at the high school level, divided into three categories whether it’s permitted, prohibited or under consideration, according to Eccker Sports’ website for tracking states.
Alaska
Arkansas
Arizona
California
Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
Florida
Georgia
Idaho
Illinois
Iowa
Kansas
Kentucky
Louisiana
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
Minnesota
Mississippi
Missouri
Nebraska
Nevada
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New Mexico
New York
North Carolina
North Dakota
Oklahoma
Oregon
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
South Carolina
Tennessee
Utah
Vermont
Virginia
Washington
District of Columbia
Alabama
Hawaii
South Carolina
Texas
West Virginia
Wisconsin
Wyoming
Indiana
Michigan
Montana
Ohio
Follow High School On SI Florida throughout the 2025 high school football season for Live Updates, the most up to date Schedules & Scores and complete coverage from the preseason through the state championships!
Be sure to Bookmark High School on SI for all of the latest high school football news.
To get live updates on your phone – as well as follow your favorite teams and top games – you can download the SBLive Sports app: Download iPhone App| Download Android App
— Andy Villamarzo | villamarzo@scorebooklive.com | @highschoolonsi
NIL
Dame Sarr chose Duke to play on ‘biggest stage’ in college basketball
Dame Sarr, the No. 17 overall ranked player in the 2025 recruiting class, committed to Duke earlier this year on May 22. The 6-foot-6 shooting guard from Italy had most recently been playing with FC Barcelona, where he averaged 5.8 points and 1.7 rebounds in 12.8 minutes per game this season. Sarr hopped on “The Brotherhood […]

Dame Sarr, the No. 17 overall ranked player in the 2025 recruiting class, committed to Duke earlier this year on May 22.
The 6-foot-6 shooting guard from Italy had most recently been playing with FC Barcelona, where he averaged 5.8 points and 1.7 rebounds in 12.8 minutes per game this season.
Sarr hopped on “The Brotherhood Podcast” with assistant coach Emanuel Dildy last month and discussed his decision to head to college basketball and play at Duke.
“It was always a dream to play in a school like Duke,” Sarr said. “When I saw the guys from last year that went to the Draft and I saw that there was this chance for me. Talking with coach [John] Scheyer and coach [Emanuel Dildy], I had a very clear picture of what they saw in me and the team. I liked that picture and thought it was great. I was playing for Barcelona in the FIBA cup so I wanted to be in a big college. So I think this is the biggest stage and I want to play with and against the best players and win. I think it was a very easy decision. I’m very happy that I made the decision and that’s what I felt in my heart.”
The Oderzo, Italy native joins the No. 1 ranked recruiting class in the country. He is surrounded by a talented group, consisting of five-star forward Cameron Boozer, four-star forward Nikolas Khamenia, four-star guard Cayden Boozer and four-star forward Sebastian Wilkins.
“I saw that college basketball is a big opportunity,” Sarr said. “You can play in these big stages and be an important player and improve a lot. For me that was key. And I think that having played overseas and being able to have this experience is also going to help me a lot with college work and professional work. If I combine them it’s going to be great for my career and I’m so excited to start.”
Sarr is just one of a few elite international talents to commit to Duke in recent seasons, joining Khaman Maluach, Tyrese Proctor and RJ Barrett.
“The Brotherhood is a big family,” Sarr continued. “I think everybody wants to succeed in basketball and things other than basketball. I talk to people who have had only good words about this program and I felt really good about it.”
Duke is the No. 3 ranked team in On3’s Way-too-early Top 25 college basketball rankings 7.0.
NIL
Kirby Added As Assistant Baseball Coach
STARKVILLE – Mississippi State head baseball coach Brian O’Connor has added another key piece to his inaugural coaching staff in Starkville, announcing the hiring of longtime Virginia assistant Matt Kirby as an assistant coach for the Bulldogs. Kirby spent the past 14 seasons at Virginia, including 12 years as a volunteer assistant before being […]

Kirby spent the past 14 seasons at Virginia, including 12 years as a volunteer assistant before being promoted to full-time assistant and recruiting coordinator in 2023. Known for his work with position players – particularly catchers and outfielders – Kirby played a key role in developing talent for one of the most consistent programs in college baseball. He also served as the Cavaliers’ first base coach.
“Matt has been a steady and trusted presence throughout my time as a head coach,” O’Connor said. “He’s an elite teacher, recruiter, communicator and innovative thinker who has helped build championship teams. He will pour everything he has into Mississippi State, and I’m glad that he is joining our efforts in Starkville.”
In his first season as a full-time assistant, Kirby helped Virginia reach its seventh College World Series appearance since 2009 and guided the Cavaliers through a late-season surge that saw them win 20 of their final 27 games. Over his 14 years in Charlottesville, UVA reached the NCAA Tournament nine times, captured five regional championships, and won the 2015 national title.
Virginia was named the program of the decade (2010–19) by D1Baseball.com, with O’Connor earning Coach of the Decade honors. Kirby helped UVA rack up 467 wins during his tenure in Charlottesville, the eighth most of any college baseball program in that span.
A former catcher at William & Mary, Kirby has been instrumental in developing some of the top backstops in college baseball. Under his guidance, four catchers earned All-ACC recognition, including first-round MLB Draft picks Matt Thaiss (16th overall, 2016) and Kyle Teel (14th overall, 2023). Overall, UVA produced 30 All-ACC position players and nine All-Americans during his time on staff.
Prior to Virginia, Kirby held coaching roles at Georgetown, Villanova, Brown, William & Mary and VMI. He served as a recruiting coordinator at both Georgetown and Villanova, where his 2008 signing class was ranked among the nation’s top 100 by Collegiate Baseball.
Kirby is a 2003 graduate of William & Mary, where he was a four-year letterman and two-time team captain. He led the Tribe to a CAA Tournament title in 2001 and was a Second-Team All-CAA selection in 2002 while catching for future major leaguers Chris Ray and Bill Bray.
“I’m incredibly grateful for the opportunity to join Coach O’Connor’s staff at Mississippi State,” Kirby said. “The minute you step onto Dudy Noble Field, you immediately feel the rich tradition and can sense the passion and unrelenting excitement of the fanbase. I’m excited to help build something special in StarkVegas.”
Kirby and his wife, Mallory, have one daughter, Renate.
Visit www.HailState.com for the latest news and information on the baseball program. Fans can also follow the program on social media by searching ‘HailStateBB’ on X, Facebook and Instagram.
NIL
SB | Taylor Lane and Chelsea Bennett Honored as CSC Academic All-District Team Members
Story Links GREENWOOD, IN — Congratulations to Saint Mary’s Softball’s very own Taylor Lane and Chelsea Bennett on being named members of the College Sports Communicators Academic All-District Team. The Academic All-District Softball teams, selected by College Sports Communicators, recognize the nation’s top student-athletes for their combined performances on the diamond and […]

GREENWOOD, IN — Congratulations to Saint Mary’s Softball’s very own Taylor Lane and Chelsea Bennett on being named members of the College Sports Communicators Academic All-District Team. The Academic All-District Softball teams, selected by College Sports Communicators, recognize the nation’s top student-athletes for their combined performances on the diamond and in the classroom.
In her fourth year with the program and third of competition, Taylor Lane continued to provide a solid pop of power in the Gaels lineup this year. The redshirt junior hit 0.255 for the year with four doubles, a triple, three home runs and 20 driven in while starting primarily at first base in 33 games. Lane graduated this spring with a degree in special education and a 3.68 GPA, but does have an additional year of eligibility after redshirting her first year in Moraga. Lane was also a WCC Honorable Mention All-Academic team member.
Chelsea Bennett put up her best season to date in the circle, serving as one of the Gaels top bullpen arms in 2025. The Warriewood, Australia native made 14 appearances, 10 of which were in relief in her junior campaign, working 37 innings and putting up a career-low 3.78 ERA. She finished her third year as a biology major at Saint Mary’s, maintaining a 3.75 cumulative GPA. Bennett was named a first team member of the WCC All-Academic team this past season for the first time in her career as well.
#GaelsRise
NIL
Amid North Carolina NIL Spending Rumors, Basketball HC Hubert Davis Faces Huge Expectations
A recent report from Inside Carolina set off alarm bells among college basketball fans when it claimed that North Carolina had allocated an astonishing $14 million to its basketball program. Even considering the NCAA’s new reality — full of massive NIL contracts, transfer portal decisions, and the upcoming result of the House vs. NCAA lawsuit […]

A recent report from Inside Carolina set off alarm bells among college basketball fans when it claimed that North Carolina had allocated an astonishing $14 million to its basketball program.
Even considering the NCAA’s new reality — full of massive NIL contracts, transfer portal decisions, and the upcoming result of the House vs. NCAA lawsuit — this sum far exceeds what many expected.
Basketball Insider Says 2025 is the “Ultimate ‘No Excuse’ Year for Hubert Davis”
In the Inside Carolina reports, writer Greg Barnes explained that multiple sources have confirmed that the North Carolina Tar Heels have spent over $14 million in NIL deals for next basketball season.
College basketball analyst Tim Donnelly was surprised by the report. The host of “The Drive” on 99.9 The Fan, he stated that Davis is at a crucial moment in his leadership of the Tar Heels.
“This is the ultimate ‘no excuse’ year for Hubert Davis,” Donnelly explained. “This is the ultimate no-excuse year for the brain trust that is running UNC basketball right now.”
He continued, “With great money comes great responsibility,” he added. “If you give a coach $14 million to put together a roster and the roster is not stellar at the end of the year, you look at that coach and you go, ‘I don’t know if I’m ready to give you $14 million again.’ Right?”
Donnelly shared his vision for the future of Davis and his team after receiving $14 million.
“If you give a coach $14 million and they come back the next year and say, ‘Hey, I need another 14, $15 million,’ ‘Hey, what’d you spend the last 14 on?’”
“You better have a trophy, you better have something worth, you better have a long run into the NCAA tournament, cuz if not, I’m not giving you more money… You better win with $14 million, is what I’m saying, you better win with $14 million.”
RELATED: Analysts ‘Miffed’, Fans ‘Betrayed’ by Ven-Allen Lubin’s Decision to Transfer from North Carolina to NC State
According to the report, the $14 million sum is nearly triple what UNC Basketball spent last season.
The report also states that the expenditure includes adding six new players, including Montenegrin guard Luka Bogavac, guards Kyan Evans and Jonathan Powell, and center Henri Veesaar.
While massive NIL deals aren’t a new phenomenon in the world of college sports, this investment into Carolina basketball is a big move, considering they are also seemingly going “all in” on Bill Belichick and the football team.
College Sports Network has you covered with the latest news, analysis, insights, and trending stories in college football, men’s college basketball, women’s college basketball, and college baseball!
NIL
No. 1 College Basketball Recruit AJ Dybantsa Receives Massive $4.1 Million NIL Update
No. 1 College Basketball Recruit AJ Dybantsa Receives Massive $4.1 Million NIL Update originally appeared on Athlon Sports. BYU Cougars signee AJ Dybantsa is one to watch for as he enters college basketball next season. As a high school recruit, he was a five-star and rated as the No. 1 player in the class of 2025 […]

No. 1 College Basketball Recruit AJ Dybantsa Receives Massive $4.1 Million NIL Update originally appeared on Athlon Sports.
BYU Cougars signee AJ Dybantsa is one to watch for as he enters college basketball next season. As a high school recruit, he was a five-star and rated as the No. 1 player in the class of 2025 (On3 Sports).
Advertisement
Back in December, the 6-foot-9 small forward announced his commitment to BYU, choosing the Cougars over three of college basketball’s biggest names: UNC, Kansas and Alabama.
Meanwhile, on Thursday, Dybantsa saw a significant jump in his On3 NIL valuation—up $274k to a total of $4.1 million.
We are living in a new era of college sports, with the leading beneficiaries being the players and the schools with big-market athletic programs. Including his landing of brand deals with Nike and Red Bull, Dybantsa is on a contract with BYU to receive over $7 million this season, according to Adam Zagoria of the New York Times.
The Cougars have emerged as an NIL juggernaut, especially after the hiring of head coach Kevin Young back in April. Young, in fact, was reportedly one of the biggest reasons Dybantsa elected to take his talents to Provo, Utah.
Advertisement
“A lot stood out during my visit,” the Massachusetts native said on ESPN’s “First Take.” “Obviously, coach Kevin Young’s there. My ultimate goal is to get to the NBA, and he coached my favorite player of all time, Kevin Durant.”
BYU Cougars signee AJ Dybantsa (3).Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images
When asked who he models his game after, Dybantsa listed household names like Tracy McGrady and Shai Gilgeous-Alexander, the current front-runner for finals MVP (-550, ESPN Bet).
“KD, my favorite player, I take a lot from his game, but I don’t think I play like him,” Dybansta added. “I think he really one of one… I play like a mix of Tracy McGrady and Shai.”
Related: BYU Basketball moves up in ESPN’s early top 25 preseason poll
This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jun 5, 2025, where it first appeared.
-
College Sports2 weeks ago
Portal Update – Basketball and Gymnastics Take Hits
-
College Sports2 weeks ago
Portal Update – Basketball and Gymnastics Take Hits
-
Professional Sports2 weeks ago
Jon Jones answers UFC retirement speculation as fans accuse champion of 'holding the belt …
-
Health2 weeks ago
BYU women's basketball guard injures ACL twice
-
NIL1 week ago
2025 NCAA Softball Tournament Bracket: Women’s College World Series bracket, schedule set
-
Youtube2 weeks ago
Xavier Legette taught Marty Smith his signature celly
-
High School Sports2 weeks ago
Today in the MHSAA
-
College Sports2 weeks ago
NCDC Commitment Profiles: Cyclones’ Martins Moving On to Saint Anselm College • USPHL
-
College Sports2 weeks ago
IU basketball recruiting
-
Motorsports2 weeks ago
Why IHOP Rode With Dale Earnhardt Jr. In Amazon NASCAR Debut