Connect with us

NIL

Former NFL Player Says NIL Needs To Change To Save College Football

PublishedMay 10, 2025 2:37 PM EDT•UpdatedMay 10, 2025 2:37 PM EDT Facebook Twitter Email Copy Link College football has a serious problem on its hands. After years of players having no ability to earn money as a result of their status as athletes, as well as little freedom of movement between schools, they now have […]

Published

on


College football has a serious problem on its hands. After years of players having no ability to earn money as a result of their status as athletes, as well as little freedom of movement between schools, they now have arguably the most free and open system in sports. 

Athletes can now move between schools each year, at will. Think you can get more Name, Image and Likeliness money elsewhere? The floodgates are open. Though of course, as Nico Iamaleava can tell you, searching for money doesn’t always work out.

There are some benefits to this both for players, and for certain schools who can now pull recruits away from big-name programs with better financial offers. But it’s also created a system where the “student-athlete” designation is essentially a farce. And former NFL player Jack Brewer thinks the sport needs a complete overhaul in order to return to how it used to be.

Former NFL Player Warns ‘Student Athletes’ Disappearing

Brewer, who played in the NFL from 2002 to 2006, spoke to Fox News Digital about the new era of NIL in college football and how, in his mind, it’s negatively impacted the sport and the players.

“We need to get back to student-athletes,” Brewer said.

“If a person wants the freedom to make as much money as they want and can leverage the sport to do that, they should absolutely be able to — and they can, in our professional leagues. But there’s no place for an unlimited amount of money to be paid to people in college sports. They should be student-athletes, which is what they signed up to be.”

And this is the delicate balance that college athletics is facing in the modern era; players are putting their health and careers on the line, in a sport that’s generating billions of dollars, and schools and administrators have historically taken advantage of it.

READ: Big Ten Conference Dominating On And Off Field, With Massive Revenue Increase

The system we have now though, all but eliminates the “student” part of “student-athlete.” Brewer agrees.

“You’ll continue to see students who are no longer focused on school because their incentive for going to college is no longer to get an education, but to make money,” Brewer said. “It’s not right for universities to exploit this loophole, recruiting student-athletes who no longer have to focus on being students.”

Where critics like Brewer are right is that the unrestricted transfer system and complete lack of regulation in NIL give college football players more freedom than virtually any other sport. NFL players have contracts; they aren’t able to switch between teams at the drop of a hat, even after the NIL distribution based on a presumed commitment.

President Donald Trump has reportedly discussed an executive order to put a stop to unrestricted NIL after speaking to legendary head coach Nick Saban.  The free-for-all era seems to be coming to a rapid end.





Link

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

NIL

Current NIL system has ‘become pay for play,’ ‘a little bit off the rails’

Former Alabama football coach Nick Saban was in Hoover last week for the Regions Tradition, and the legendary coach spoke with the cast of local radio show “The Next Round” about the state of college football. Saban, who has been vocal about the landscape of college football with name, image and likeness (NIL), the transfer […]

Published

on


Former Alabama football coach Nick Saban was in Hoover last week for the Regions Tradition, and the legendary coach spoke with the cast of local radio show “The Next Round” about the state of college football.

Saban, who has been vocal about the landscape of college football with name, image and likeness (NIL), the transfer portal, and other aspects leading to his seemingly abrupt retirement, has been rumored to help lead President Donald Trump’s commission on college athletics.

RELATED: Saban: ‘I don’t really know’ what presidential commission on college athletics would do

In speaking with “The Next Round,” Saban criticized what NIL has become, saying it had gone “a little bit off the rails. He emphasized the importance of getting all state laws to mirror each other to “level the playing field.”

“Look, I want everybody to know. I’m not against players making money. I think they deserve to do that. I think name, image and likeness is no longer name, image and likeness; it’s become play for pay. So, the system that we’re paying players right now probably is a little bit off the rails. And we probably need to do something to get all the state laws the same so that everybody competes on a level playing field, authentic name, image and likeness, which means it really and truly is like a marketing opportunity. And when this House settlement comes down, there will probably be some revenue sharing and some guidelines that we can build around hopefully to make the game a little better.

To connect with the author of this story or to comment, email [email protected].

Don’t miss out! Subscribe to our newsletter and get our top stories every weekday morning.



Link

Continue Reading

NIL

Nico Iamaleava domino effect among ESPN’s top storylines for 2025 season

Nico Iamaleava’s very public departure from Tennessee last month remains one of the defining stories of the NIL era to this point. So does the fallout from it. TALK ABOUT IT IN THE ROCKY TOP FORUM Iamaleava’s decision to skip out on the Vols’ final spring practice amid reports of contract negotiations before entering the […]

Published

on


Nico Iamaleava’s very public departure from Tennessee last month remains one of the defining stories of the NIL era to this point.

So does the fallout from it.

TALK ABOUT IT IN THE ROCKY TOP FORUM

Iamaleava’s decision to skip out on the Vols’ final spring practice amid reports of contract negotiations before entering the transfer portal and ending up at UCLA after two years in Knoxville was highly publicized and put Tennessee at the center of the latest chapter in the ever-changing NIL saga.

ESPN listed it among its 10 “must know” storylines 100 days before the start of the 2025 college football season.

“Tennessee transfer Nico Iamaleava and his brother, Arkansas transfer Madden Iamaleava, aren’t officially enrolled at UCLA yet,” ESPN’s Dave Wilson wrote. “But during UCLA’s Spring Showcase, they watched as Luke Duncan took first- and second-team reps while Nick Billoups, who is in the transfer portal, also took some snaps, according to the Los Angeles Times. Meanwhile, Joey Aguilar, who had transferred to UCLA initially after a standout year at App State, is now transferring to Tennessee to replace Nico. By this fall, Aguilar will be in Knoxville and the Iamaleava brothers could be Nos. 1 and 2 on the Bruins’ depth chart.

Coach DeShaun Foster said ‘it’s just comforting’ having Nico around, which is not the way Tennessee felt after a dispute over NIL money. He heads to Los Angeles after throwing for 2,616 yards with 19 TDs and 5 INTs. The soap opera will continue into the fall.”

Josh Heupel and the program’s decision not to cave on a reported new contract for Iamaleava, a former five-star prospect who started just one season, was largely supported nationally and potentially set a precedent that could lead to even more changes in the landscape.

But Tennessee was left with a void to fill in its quarterbacks room, which at the end of the spring featured just two scholarship players in redshirt freshman Jake Merklinger and freshman George MacIntyre.

Enter Joey Aguilar, a record-breaking quarterback at Appalachian State two years ago before transferring to UCLA in January.

In an ironic twist, Iamaleava bolting from the Vols led Aguilar to Tennessee where he will he will compete for the starting job with Merklinger and MacIntyre in fall camp.

Though it remains to be seen who will start for the Vols once they open their season against Syracuse in the Aflac Kickoff Game at Mercedes-Benz Stadium in Atlanta on Aug. 30 (Noon ET, ABC), Aguilar holds the edge in experience.

Aguilar set single-season passing and scoring records with 3,757 yards and 33 touchdowns with the Mountaineers in 2023.

He passed for 3,003 yards, 23 touchdowns and 14 interceptions last season.

“(Aguilar) has starts. He’s played at a high level. He’s the got the ability to throw the ball vertically,” Heupel told reporters last month. “He’s accurate and on time in the intermediate passing game. He has the ability to use his feet to extend plays and in the quarterback run game too. It’s similar to the traits that we have with guys on campus right now.”



Link

Continue Reading

NIL

Tennessee ‘Athlete-Friendly’ NIL Law Takes Shot at House Settlement

Earlier this month, Tennessee signed Senate Bill 536 into law, giving major protection to college sports programs in the state as they traverse the new, chaotic NIL landscape. As college football and basketball programs in Tennessee strategize for the future amid the absence of federal NIL legislation or final approval on the House settlement, they […]

Published

on


Earlier this month, Tennessee signed Senate Bill 536 into law, giving major protection to college sports programs in the state as they traverse the new, chaotic NIL landscape.

As college football and basketball programs in Tennessee strategize for the future amid the absence of federal NIL legislation or final approval on the House settlement, they can do so without fear of the NCAA.

In what’s considered one of the most “athlete-friendly” NIL laws in the country, as On3 Sports reports, the law will protect schools from antitrust lawsuits while taking some shots at the terms within the settlement.

Under S.B. 356, which went into effect May 1, athletes in Tennessee will be able to receive compensation from NIL collectives until explicitly told otherwise by federal law, antitrust law, or a valid court order.

The NCAA cannot “create anticompetitive restrictions that lessen, or tend to lessen, full and free competition in trade or commerce affecting this State or to otherwise violate state and federal law.”

In addition, the NCAA shall not “establish, adopt, promulgate, implement, or enforce any rule, standard, procedure, policy, or guideline that violates an applicable state or federal antitrust law,” and it should make sure it’s “legally exempt from applicable antitrust laws” before doing so.

It shields Tennessee schools from legal issues arising over any alleged violations, as the NCAA “shall fully indemnify and hold harmless the state, its institutions, and intercollegiate athletes from any damages, losses, claims, or remedies of any kind arising from its noncompliance or failure under such applicable law.”

It also provides protections for grant-in-aid and athletic eligibility that may arise from any disputes.

While the date for final approval of the House settlement is July 1, there’s growing skepticism that it will curtail all the problems within the college sports landscape.

By shifting liability to the NCAA, Tennessee lawmakers are allowing in-state schools to work toward that assumed future without fear of facing legal repercussions.

They aren’t the only state to enact protections, with Louisiana recently joining the charge with an executive order granting schools the ability to directly pay athletes for NIL.

However, Tennessee might offer the strongest shield, as reported by Adam Sparks of the Knoxville News Sentinel (subscription required) based on analysis by NIL expert and sports attorney Mit Winter.

“This Tennessee law goes further than the others because it was specifically drafted in a way that says schools in the state of Tennessee and their athletes don’t have to adhere to any restrictions on NIL compensation, except in certain limited circumstances,” Winter said.

Now, unlike some universities that may have concerns, those in Tennessee can operate without worrying about becoming defendants.



Link

Continue Reading

NIL

Tennessee 'Athlete

Earlier this month, Tennessee signed Senate Bill 536 into law, giving major protection to college sports programs in the state as they traverse the new, chaotic NIL landscape. As college football and basketball programs in Tennessee strategize for the future amid the absence of federal NIL legislation or final approval on the House settlement, they […]

Published

on

Tennessee 'Athlete

Earlier this month, Tennessee signed Senate Bill 536 into law, giving major protection to college sports programs in the state as they traverse the new, chaotic NIL landscape.

As college football and basketball programs in Tennessee strategize for the future amid the absence of federal NIL legislation or final approval on the House settlement, they can do so without fear of the NCAA.

In what’s considered one of the most “athlete-friendly” NIL laws in the country, as On3 Sports reports, the law will protect schools from antitrust lawsuits while taking some shots at the terms within the settlement.

Under S.B. 356, which went into effect May 1, athletes in Tennessee will be able to receive compensation from NIL collectives until explicitly told otherwise by federal law, antitrust law, or a valid court order.

The NCAA cannot “create anticompetitive restrictions that lessen, or tend to lessen, full and free competition in trade or commerce affecting this State or to otherwise violate state and federal law.”

In addition, the NCAA shall not “establish, adopt, promulgate, implement, or enforce any rule, standard, procedure, policy, or guideline that violates an applicable state or federal antitrust law,” and it should make sure it’s “legally exempt from applicable antitrust laws” before doing so.

It shields Tennessee schools from legal issues arising over any alleged violations, as the NCAA “shall fully indemnify and hold harmless the state, its institutions, and intercollegiate athletes from any damages, losses, claims, or remedies of any kind arising from its noncompliance or failure under such applicable law.”

It also provides protections for grant-in-aid and athletic eligibility that may arise from any disputes.

While the date for final approval of the House settlement is July 1, there’s growing skepticism that it will curtail all the problems within the college sports landscape.

By shifting liability to the NCAA, Tennessee lawmakers are allowing in-state schools to work toward that assumed future without fear of facing legal repercussions.

They aren’t the only state to enact protections, with Louisiana recently joining the charge with an executive order granting schools the ability to directly pay athletes for NIL.

However, Tennessee might offer the strongest shield, as reported by Adam Sparks of the Knoxville News Sentinel (subscription required) based on analysis by NIL expert and sports attorney Mit Winter.

“This Tennessee law goes further than the others because it was specifically drafted in a way that says schools in the state of Tennessee and their athletes don’t have to adhere to any restrictions on NIL compensation, except in certain limited circumstances,” Winter said.

Now, unlike some universities that may have concerns, those in Tennessee can operate without worrying about becoming defendants.

Continue Reading

NIL

Former USC RB LenDale White speaks on transfer portal impact for current players

There is a lot going on in college football. USC is trying to regain their place in the sport in terms of modern-day contexts. In terms of historical significance and the power of the Trojan emblem, the university continues to be a top school in the NCAA. Only the record as of late has not […]

Published

on

Former USC RB LenDale White speaks on transfer portal impact for current players

There is a lot going on in college football. USC is trying to regain their place in the sport in terms of modern-day contexts. In terms of historical significance and the power of the Trojan emblem, the university continues to be a top school in the NCAA. Only the record as of late has not matched that of some of the past teams that have walked through the Coliseum.

An excellent example of a familiar face from a past, more successful era is LenDale White. The former running back won back-to-back titles and was on the team that came close to achieving a three-peat.

The retired player sat down with The Coach JB and Big Smitty Show and discussed part of why he joined USC and why he believes the Trojans are close to being annual contenders again.

For White, he knew that the power and connection of being a member of the USC football team would go further than anywhere else. Not to mention that he played on a roster that had an embarrassment of riches in the RB room alone.

From Joe McKnight to Reggie Bush, USC brought in top talent at all positions and was the force to be reckoned with on a national level.

While the program has taken a sizable dip since the days of coach Pete Carroll, White believes that there is a resurgence happening now under coach Lincoln Riley. According to him, it starts with the current recruiting classes and how the staff is winning those battles. It won’t be too long before the future wins also translate to increases in the win column.

White did discuss an important difference between when he was a player and now. NIL gets a lot of attention, but the transfer portal affects the relationship with players in a different way between them and their schools.

As mentioned, White played in a great position group room. In today’s era, most likely, many would have sought the door after the first season or had flipped on a commitment once finding out who their teammates would be.

Certainly, there are positive cases of the transfer portal, and athletes have benefitted from this newfound freedom. It does, however, give a bad look when the only apparent reason for transferring out is due to lack of initial playing time or fear of competition at the same position.

Important distinction mentioned by former USC player

That’s something that was not as readily an option back in the day compared to now. Again, all circumstances have individual factors to consider. There is something to be said for sticking with a program and fighting for a spot and earning playing time after learning and working behind the scenes.

One advantage that older players have compared to now, as White mentioned, is that when he returns to Los Angeles, he is unquestionably a Trojan. That isn’t to bemoan those who transfer for a season and find themselves in a good situation. It should be something of a stronger consideration point for all athletes as to the why when deciding to move to a different school.

Players like White have a legacy and are immortalized at USC forever. It feels different when comparing those who hop around, changing their school colors every semester.  

 

  

    

 

 

Continue Reading

NIL

Delaware head coach Martin Ingelsby Leads the Blue Hens into Conference USA

Coach Martin Ingelsby has built Delaware into a solid program; after a tough regular season, the Blue Hens moved into the Coastal Athletic Association Tournament and won four games in a row before losing a tough 76-72 decision to UNC Wilmington in the championship. Delaware moves into Conference USA on July 1. Coach Ingelsby discusses […]

Published

on

Delaware head coach Martin Ingelsby Leads the Blue Hens into Conference USA

Coach Martin Ingelsby has built Delaware into a solid program; after a tough regular season, the Blue Hens moved into the Coastal Athletic Association Tournament and won four games in a row before losing a tough 76-72 decision to UNC Wilmington in the championship. Delaware moves into Conference USA on July 1. Coach Ingelsby discusses his ideas on how to rebuild as the Blue Hens are a program that builds quality players.

Topics of Conversation Include:

  • Winning the 4 games to get into the CAA Championship Final
  • The impacts of the move to Conference USA
  • Bringing over Providence transfer Justyn Fernandez and former Temple Owl Jameel Brown
  • The return of Cavan Reilly for a fourth season

… and much more!

Continue Reading

Most Viewed Posts

Trending