Jake Paul isn’t new to controversy, but his latest move lit up the sports world like few others. In a clip that went viral, the social media star rattled off a list of athletes he believes are, in his words, “overrated.” Shockingly, the names included legends, champions, and household favorites.

Cristiano Ronaldo

Credit: Instagram

Paul knew this pick would upset millions. He even said so before dropping Cristiano Ronaldo’s name. The five-time Ballon d’Or winner has scored over 800 goals, won titles in England, Spain, and Italy, and just helped Portugal win another Nations League. Yet Paul shrugged all that off. To him, Ronaldo is overhyped. He didn’t elaborate, but calling one of the sport’s most consistent icons overrated? That did plenty on its own.

Anthony Joshua

Credit: Instagram

Once a unified heavyweight champion, Anthony Joshua has lost steam lately. Paul didn’t waste time calling him out, especially after Anthony’s knockout loss to Daniel Dubois in 2024. While Anthony hasn’t fought since the Dubois bout, Paul believes the boxer’s name still carries more weight than his recent performances justify.

Conor McGregor

Credit: Instagram

Despite being one of the UFC’s most famous figures, Conor McGregor hasn’t won a fight in more than five years. That’s the stat Paul leaned on when dropping Conor’s name. Their rivalry is well-documented, and the two have teased a future clash.

Canelo Alvarez

Credit: Instagram

Paul isn’t impressed that Canelo Alvarez has held titles in four weight classes. He’s been vocal about it, especially after a rumored fight between the two fell through. Canelo instead signed a deal with the Riyadh Season series. Paul views him as a legacy fighter whose current relevance is inflated. For someone with nearly 60 pro fights, Canelo still couldn’t dodge this jab from Jake.

Ryan Garcia

Credit: Instagram

Ryan Garcia’s recent headlines haven’t helped his case. Paul criticized the boxer for his high expectations and underwhelming follow-through; even his win over Devin Haney was overturned due to a failed test. For Paul, Ryan’s image as the future of boxing never quite matched the reality in the ring.

Babe Ruth

Credit: ebay

It’s not every day someone calls Babe Ruth overrated, but Paul did exactly that. Ruth’s seven World Series wins and 714 home runs are etched in baseball history. But Paul pointed to the era Ruth played in, long before modern training, competition, or television, as a reason to question his legacy.

Dak Prescott

Credit: Wikimedia Commons

The Dallas Cowboys quarterback made the list, probably for one glaring reason: his playoff record. At 2–5 in the postseason, Dak Prescott hasn’t lived up to the hype he now earns, at least according to Paul.

Tua Tagovailoa

Credit: Instagram

Miami Dolphins QB Tua Tagovailoa was another NFL name Paul went after. He’s shown flashes of brilliance, but injury setbacks and an uneven career arc likely made him an easy pick. Tua ranked among the NFL’s top 100 players in 2023, but that didn’t stop the influencer from calling him out.

Trevor Lawrence

Credit: Instagram

Even the football star’s potential hasn’t shielded him from criticism this harsh. Trevor Lawrence came into the NFL as a can’t-miss prospect. After being drafted first overall in 2021, he led the Jaguars to one playoff win and a division title in 2022. Still, his 20-30 career record and $55 million annual salary were enough for Paul to call him “overpaid and overrated.”

Anthony Edwards

Credit: Instagram

Though relatively young, Anthony Edwards is already turning heads in the NBA. He won Olympic gold in 2024 and made history with the most single-season three-pointers in Timberwolves franchise history. But Paul still put him on blast. He didn’t go into detail, but some believe the controversial influencer is jumping the gun here. Considering he’s only 23, Edwards might make Paul regret this pick in a few short seasons.

Tommy Fury – Honorable Mention

Credit: Instagram

Jake Paul and Tommy Fury shared one of boxing’s most hyped grudge matches in 2023. The latter won by split decision, but Jake downplayed the loss, calling Tommy “basic” and “overprotected.”

Nate Diaz – Honorable Mention

Credit: Instagram

When Jake Paul fought Nate Diaz in 2023, it was more like an internet crossover than a real boxing match. Diaz, an MMA legend, looked out of place in a boxing ring. Jake won on points but later dismissed Nate’s performance as sluggish and outdated. Despite Nate’s cult following, Jake doesn’t buy the hype.

Logan Paul – Honorable Mention

Credit: Wikipedia

Even brothers aren’t safe. Jake has occasionally jabbed at Logan Paul’s combat credibility, especially after Logan’s exhibition with Floyd Mayweather. While Logan shifted toward WWE and PRIME hydration deals, Jake hinted that Logan’s fight record and ring skills don’t live up to the spotlight he enjoys.

Ben Askren – Honorable Mention

Credit: Instagram

Jake Paul knocked out Ben Askren in under two minutes back in 2021, but the drama didn’t stop there. The influencer often mocks Askren’s physique and downplays the win, saying it proved how overhyped the former MMA wrestler was as a striker. Askren’s decorated MMA résumé didn’t impress Jake.

Dillon Danis – Honorable Mention

Credit: Instagram

Before his boxing debut, Jake Paul called out Dillon Danis repeatedly, even pelting him with water balloons during an infamous drive-by taunt. Danis talked plenty but never signed a contract. Paul took that as proof of bluffing.