Connect with us
https://yoursportsnation.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/call-to-1.png

NIL

Missouri Valley Football Conference coaches skeptical NCAA settlement will change retention concerns – Grand Forks Herald

Published

on


GRAND FORKS — When Southern Illinois head football coach Nick Hill has an alum stop by practice, he hears about the glory years and tales of a time when players stuck out the entirety of a college career in one program.

Hill’s current reality is much different. The current reality is rampant transferring.

“Those days are pretty much over,” the 40-year-old SIU alum Hill said. “Some people are living in the past of even 15 years ago.”

College football is entering a new era in 2025, when universities can share revenue directly to college athletes following the House vs. NCAA legal case.

At this summer’s Missouri Valley Football Conference meeting in Sioux Falls, coaches and the league’s commissioner weren’t so sure the changes will solve the NCAA’s retention problem. Most MVFC leaders said “no,” although some of their answers may be better categorized as “not yet.”

“The best way to retain our guys is to do a great job with relationships,” UND first-year head coach Eric Schmidt said. “Guys have to believe they’re going to get developed here. They have to believe they can make life-changing money in the NFL and that’s the reason to stay. I don’t think before House or after House will change that.”

As reported by Reuters and other national news outlets, House vs. NCAA was started by Arizona State University swimmer Grant House and others, who filed an antitrust suit against the NCAA and its restrictions of athletes to benefit financially from their name, image and likeness.

In June, the NCAA agreed to pay nearly $2.8 billion to former and current Division I athletes who were unable to profit through NIL between 2016 and 2024. Going forward, schools can directly share revenue with their athletes.

As part of the agreement, there will be new oversight added to NIL deals, including a clearinghouse that will vet deals worth more than $600 to ensure they represent fair-market value and are not simply pay-to-play deals.

With House-regulated salary caps, roster caps and tighter NIL regulation, the hope among FCS coaches is that the new system can help stem the annual exodus of players from FCS rosters to FBS schools that can offer bigger and better deals.

In the offseason leading up to the 2025 season, 514 FCS players indicated a transfer to an FBS school, according to data collected by Sam Herder of Hero Sports, an online publication that covers the FCS level.

The Missouri Valley Football Conference, widely considered the top league in the FCS, has been raided in recent years by larger power conferences. Ahead of 2025, North Dakota State’s CharMar Brown left for Miami, South Dakota State quarterback Mark Gronowski left for Iowa and Illinois State’s Hunter Zambrano left for Texas Tech, among many others in this category.

At UND, high-end talent has departed in the last few years in offensive lineman Easton Kilty (Kansas State), quarterback Tommy Schuster (Michigan State), defensive end Ben McNaboe (Ohio) and offensive lineman Cade Borud (Iowa).

With the new revenue sharing model, the governance system will be run by the College Sports Commission, an independent entity separate from the NCAA, charged with enforcing all rules related to the settlement, including revenue sharing caps for schools at the highest level of college football.

Some have hoped this new era could be a turning point in the transfer culture. The CSC is tasked with returning name, imagine and likeness (NIL) athlete deals back to their organic beginnings – before essentially pay-for-play became the norm for NIL contracts.

For example, a third-string tight end who rarely plays but is paid $100,000 in NIL money isn’t necessarily earning it based on his marketability. Instead, he’s likely being paid that sum simply to play football. The NIL deal at that price was therefore a mask of its original business intent but programs, coaches and collectives couldn’t actually call it pay-for-play without breaking the rules.

The CSC and this new era of the House settlement want to rein in that previous unregulated NIL movement, which caused bidding war after bidding war and fueled the massive levels of transferring seen across the entire college athletic world.

MVFC coaches at this summer’s media day in Sioux Falls were skeptical the House settlement era would solve any of their retention woes.

Schmidt, a former UND captain and defensive coordinator who left UND in 2019, returns to Grand Forks after coaching stops at Fresno State, Washington and San Diego State. He believes the 2025 system is a short-term solution.

“What does this look like in the next two to four years?” Schmidt said. “It’ll change again with different lawsuits and situations that’ll take place. It’s to be determined. How many of these contracts that are being signed now hold up at the end of the day? Ultimately, I don’t think (the new House system) will change anything at all right now.”

MVFC Commissioner Jeff Jackson is also looking at what’s next in this fluid new era. Like many in his role across the FCS, Jackson would like to see federal involvement to add clarity and direct the next steps.

“You know, the House settlement is not a perfect document,” he said. “We can all read the settlement and find places that we’re uncomfortable with or that we feel doesn’t best serve our interests. However, it’s a good beginning point and that beginning point does lead us into a world where we can have more regulation.

“We still need legislative relief. We still need the ability for Congress to come in and say we can self-govern because that’s the issue. How long does a student-athlete stay at North Dakota? Or Illinois State? That only gets solved if we get to a place where we can actually put in rules and govern what we’re doing. Right now, we can’t. So the House settlement is a great beginning, but being able to get to safe harbor, we’ve got to have legislative relief. How we’re existing right now is not sustainable. You’ve got to have some (rules) with teeth, and that’s where legislative relief comes in.”

Due to the transfer culture in place, Youngstown State coach Doug Phillips, in his sixth season leading the Penguins, has seen the development process need to greatly accelerate.

“What do you tell a young man that can maybe go make $800,000 (at a Power Four program)?” Phillips said. “What would I tell my son? I don’t make that money, you know? What I’ve got to do for my team is have someone ready to replace him, so that’s what I try to focus on. If this young man decides to move on, that can benefit his family and himself … I just want to make sure I have a guy that’s going to step in and be ready to play. That’s what we can control. That’s where you manage a roster. Back in the day, you had to have a guy ready after four years. Now, we need to have guys ready in Year 2. Year 3, they need to star. I’ve got to have them ready sooner.”

At the highest levels of college football, a salary cap will be monitored. At UND and the MVFC level, schools are opting in to the House settlement but that doesn’t dictate how much revenue – if any – will be shared. This could create disproportionate competitive balance.

For the FCS programs, opting in to the revenue sharing model doesn’t negate the FBS advantages if there isn’t much revenue to share.

“Your administration, your school can obviously step up and try to pay the players more, and that’s going to help with some retention,” Hill said. “But, you know, several of our players went to big time Power Four schools and when you weigh those options with them … kids are going to get paid a lot more and have a chance to run out on those SEC fields. Put yourself back in those shoes. Those kids are going to go every year. It’s how it is. You have to be OK with that. They’ve probably played some good football for you, you know? If it were my son, I’d tell you this is a great opportunity. You did us well here.

“It leads you to really appreciate those guys that do make up the core of your team, and we have a lot of them, who have been here five, some six years. It’s about building a team as quickly as you can now.”

Although some FCS programs may find it difficult to find revenue to share with athletes, others may find new avenues to address retention through fundraising.

“I think North Dakota State is going to be in a really good position,” Bison coach Tim Polasek said. “I’m not really concerned with the rest of the FCS; I’m not sure on that. I can’t answer that for them. I don’t know if (the House settlement) will provide (competitive balance).

“College football has been college football for a long time, and there have been a lot of programs that have certain things others don’t, and those things most certainly are important and can provide an edge. We’ll figure out which guys need a little bit of a reward for retention and keep working toward it. I most certainly don’t have all the answers but will Bison Nation answer the bell and keep us competitive? I believe that will be the case.”





Link

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

NIL

NIL, transfer portal has evened playing field and SEC can’t keep up

Published

on


Jan. 9, 2026, 3:31 p.m. ET





Link

Continue Reading

NIL

Rodriguez Names Trickett Director of Player Evaluation

Published

on


MORGANTOWN, W.Va. – West Virginia University football coach Rich Rodriguez announced that Chance Trickett has been hired as the director of player evaluation on the Mountaineer coaching staff.

“Chance has built an outstanding resume of scouting, evaluating and recruiting experience at the FBS, Power Four and NFL levels,” Rodriguez said “His wide-spread experience and knowledge in these areas, along with being a West Virginia football legacy, will make an immediate impact in our program.”  

Throughout his career, Trickett has experience leading player evaluation, roster construction and long-term talent strategy at the college and NFL levels. He has proven his ability to build multi-year roster plans, aligning evaluation with financial strategy, integrating and leveraging analytics and networks to identify top prospects and cultural long-term fits. He has a strong network across high school, college, financial and agency circles with a track record of identifying undervalued talent and maximizing roster efficiency.

 

Trickett joins the WVU football staff after spending almost 10 years as a college area scout in the Los Angeles Rams organization. He served one year as the director of football recruiting at Louisiana Tech and was at Florida State for two years as a recruiting assistant.

While with the Rams, he led comprehensive player evaluations integrating film, analytics, verified measurables and psychological/cognitive components to support draft board construction and roster strategy decisions. He also produced in-depth positional value assessments and roster impact reports for multi-year draft planning and contract strategy. He developed internal valuation reports and roster strategy that models and mirrors current NIL/college market structures. He also integrated advanced scouting technology to enhance accuracy in player projection and long-term roster planning.

Trickett was awarded the BART List Award for scouting excellence in 2025 and given the “inside the league” scout/agent organization’s Best Draft Award in 2024.

A native of Morgantown, he earned his bachelor’s degree from Florida State in 2011.

Trickett, and his wife, Ashley, have two children, Tristan and Matthew.



Link

Continue Reading

NIL

$665K QB faces scrutiny after decision to stay in college football

Published

on


The decision to head to the NFL instead of returning to college can be a complicated choice. Massive NIL payouts, potential NFL landing spots, and the solidity of a returning team are several factors that go into the stay-or-go calculus.

But with the 2026 NFL Draft QB class looking a bit thin already, some are second-guessing one QB’s plan to return to school.

Ole Miss QB Trinidad Chambliss is in the middle of requesting another year of college eligibility from the NCAA. Chambliss is claiming that he missed the 2022 season due to respiratory health issues and is thus seeking one more year to play. His NIL value is likely to end up at several times the $665,000 estimate from On3sports.

ESPN broadcaster Chase Daniel second-guessed Chambliss’s decision to return to school. “Trinidad Chambliss should absolutely think abotu entering the draft after the way he’s played in the #CFBPlayoff,” Daniel Tweeted. “Light QB draft,” he also noted.

The 2026 NFL Draft class is highlighted by Indiana’s Fernando Mendoza and, should he enter, Oregon’s Dante Moore. Many are projecting both of those quarterbacks at or near the top of the Draft. But after Mendoza and Moore, things get increasingly cloudy.

Alabama’s Ty Simpson has indicated his plan to enter the Draft. Other veteran QBs like Carson Beck and Cade Klubnik figure to be in the picture. But it’s entirely plausible that NFL teams could view Chambliss as the No. 3 or No. 4 QB prospect in the 2026 NFL Draft class.

Chambliss

Ole Miss Rebels quarterback Trinidad Chambliss plans to return to school, but ESPN’s Chase Daniel thinks he should strongly consider the NFL. | Joe Rondone/The Republic / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

Chambliss rose to prominence seemingly from nowhere in 2025. He sat for two years at Division II Ferris State and then played mostly as a reserve in 2023. In 2024, though, he passed for 2,901 yards and 26 scores while rushing for 1,019 yards and 25 scores on the ground while leading Ferris State to the national title.

He began 2025 as the backup for Ole Miss’s Austin Simmons. But an ankle injury in Week 2 gave Chambliss a chance to play and he didn’t relinquish the job. Chambliss wound up passing for 3,937 yards and 22 touchdowns against just three interceptions. He ran for an additional 527 yards and eight touchdowns.

Of course, an adverse NCAA ruling might leave Chambliss with no real choice but to go pro. He has inked a tentative NIL deal with Ole Miss based on the premise that he will be given eligibility. That deal has been indicated as likely worth several million dollars. But Daniel thinks even better NFL money could be in Chambliss’s future… if he seeks it.



Link

Continue Reading

NIL

Lane Kiffin due $500,000 payout from LSU after Ole Miss College Football Playoff run

Published

on


Thursday night, Ole Miss’ run in the College Football Playoff came to an end. The Rebels fell to Miami in the final seconds of the Fiesta Bowl.

With the loss, Lane Kiffin will officially receive a $500,000 payout from LSU within 30 days of the end of Ole Miss’ campaign. That was the amount he was due from Ole Miss, per the terms of his contract, and LSU said it would honor it in his deal with the Tigers. The school included “ancillary benefits” in Kiffin’s agreement after his high-profile departure from Ole Miss.

Ole Miss’ advancement in the College Football Playoff bracket increased Kiffin’s payout, which LSU is due to pay 30 days after the Rebels’ postseason run ends. It would have gone up even more if Ole Miss won the title. Here is how the structure is written out in his deal at LSU.

  • Ole Miss first-round game participation: $150,000
  • Ole Miss quarterfinal appearance: $250,000
  • Ole Miss semifinal appearance: $500,000
  • Ole Miss CFP national championship appearance: $750,000
  • Ole Miss CFP national championship win: $1 million

With Thursday’s loss, Ole Miss’ season ended in the College Football Playoff semifinal. As a result, Kiffin is due $500,000. If the Rebels pulled off a win, that figure would have grown to $750,000.

“Coach will be entitled to receive a payment in an amount equal to the amount Coach would have been entitled to receive had he remained Head Coach at Coach’s immediate prior employer and coached the prior employer’s football team through the 2025-26 CFP,” Lane Kiffin’s contract at LSU reads. “… If applicable, the payment under this section may be paid from affiliated foundation funds and shall be paid within 30 days following the prior employer’s team being eliminated from the 2025-26 CFP.”

Miami holds on to beat Ole Miss in Fiesta Bowl

Ole Miss trailed Miami 17-13 at halftime of the College Football Playoff semifinal at the Fiesta Bowl, but mounted a charge in the fourth quarter. The Rebels were able to capitalize on multiple Hurricanes miscues and took their first lead of the game, 19-17, with seven minutes to play.

Miami responded with a touchdown from Malachi Toney, but Ole Miss punched back. After a pass interference penalty extended the drive, Trinidad Chambliss hit Dae’Quan Wright for a touchdown and got the two-point conversion to make it a 27-24 Rebels lead with 3:13 to go.

The Hurricanes didn’t go down easily, though. Carson Beck ran in the go-ahead touchdown with 18 seconds left to make it a 31-27 Miami lead, giving Ole Miss one more shot. But Chambliss’ final Hail Mary fell short, sealing the Hurricanes’ victory and sending the program to the national title game.

However, Miami won’t have to go far for the championship game. The game will be at Hard Rock Stadium Jan. 19. The Hurricanes now wait to find out if they will play Oregon or Indiana.



Link

Continue Reading

NIL

The Transfer Portal Era and Pursuit of NIL Money Is Messy. Are There Solutions?

Published

on


A quarterback reportedly reneging on a lucrative deal to hit the transfer portal, only to return to his original school. Another starting QB, this one in the College Football Playoff, awaiting approval from the NCAA to play next season, an expensive NIL deal apparently hanging in the balance. A defensive star, sued by his former school after transferring, filing a lawsuit of his own.

“It gets crazier and crazier. It really, really does,” said Sam Ehrlich, a Boise State legal studies professor who tracks litigation against the NCAA. He said he might have to add a new section for litigation against the NCAA stemming just from transfer portal issues.

“I think a guy signing a contract and then immediately deciding he wants to go to another school, that’s a kind of a new thing,” he said. “Not new kind of historically when you think about all the contract jumping that was going on in the ’60s and ’70s with the NBA. But it’s a new thing for college sports, that’s for sure.”

Washington quarterback Demond Williams Jr. said late Thursday he will return to school for the 2026 season rather than enter the transfer portal, avoiding a potentially messy dispute amid reports the Huskers were prepared to pursue legal options to enforce Williams’ name, image and likeness contract.

Edge rusher Damon Wilson is looking to transfer after one season at Missouri, having been sued for damages by Georgia over his decision to leave the Bulldogs. He has countersued.

Then there is Ole Miss quarterback Trinidad Chambliss, who reportedly has a new NIL deal signed but is awaiting an NCAA waiver allowing him to play another season as he and the Rebels played Thursday night’s Collge Football Playoff semifinal against Miami. On the Hurricanes roster: Defensive back Xavier Lucas, whose transfer from Wisconsin led to a lawsuit against the Hurricanes last year with the Badgers claiming he was improperly lured by NIL money. Lucas has played all season for Miami. The case is pending.

Court rulings have favored athletes of late, winning them not just millions in compensation but the ability to play immediately after transferring rather than have to sit out a year as once was the case. They can also discuss specific NIL compensation with schools and boosters before enrolling and current court battles include players seeking to play longer without lower-college seasons counting against their eligibility and ability to land NIL money while doing it.

Ehrlich compared the situation to the labor upheaval professional leagues went through before finally settling on collective bargaining, which has been looked at as a potential solution by some in college sports over the past year. Athletes.org, a players association for college athletes, recently offered a 38-page proposal of what a labor deal could look like.

“I think NCAA is concerned, and rightfully so, that anything they try to do to tamp down this on their end is going to get shut down,” Ehrlich said. “Which is why really the only two solutions at this point are an act of Congress, which feels like an act of God at this point, or potentially collective bargaining, which has its own major, major challenges and roadblocks.”

The NCAA has been lobbying for years for limited antitrust protection to keep some kind of control over the new landscape — and to avoid more crippling lawsuits — but bills have gone nowhere in Congress.

Collective bargaining is complicated and universities have long balked at the idea that their athletes are employees in some way. Schools would become responsible for paying wages, benefits, and workers’ compensation. And while private institutions fall under the National Labor Relations Board, public universities must follow labor laws that vary from state to state; virtually every state in the South has “right to work” laws that present challenges for unions.

Ehrlich noted the short careers for college athletes and wondered whether a union for collective bargaining is even possible.


A harder look at contracts

To sports attorney Mit Winter, employment contracts may be the simplest solution.

“This isn’t something that’s novel to college sports,” said Winter, a former college basketball player who is now a sports attorney with Kennyhertz Perry. “Employment contracts are a huge part of college sports, it’s just novel for the athletes.”

Employment contracts for players could be written like those for coaches, he suggested, which would offer buyouts and prevent players from using the portal as a revolving door.

“The contracts that schools are entering into with athletes now, they can be enforced, but they cannot keep an athlete out of school because they’re not signing employment contracts where the school is getting the right to have the athlete play football for their school or basketball or whatever sport it is,” Winter said. “They’re just acquiring the right to be able to use the athlete’s NIL rights in various ways. So, a NIL agreement is not going to stop an athlete from transferring or going to play whatever sport it is that he or she plays at another school.”

There are challenges here, too, of course: Should all college athletes be treated as employees or just those in revenue-producing sports? Can all injured athletes seek workers’ compensation and insurance protection? Could states start taxing athlete NIL earnings?

“What’s going on in college athletics now is trying to create this new novel system where the athletes are basically treated like employees, look like employees, but we don’t want to call them employees,” Winter said. “We want to call them something else and say they’re not being paid for athletic services. They’re being paid for use of their NIL. So, then it creates new legal issues that have to be hashed out and addressed, which results in a bumpy and chaotic system when you’re trying to kind of create it from scratch.”

Employment contracts would not necessarily allow for uniform rules with an athlete able to go to transfer when terms have been met. Collective bargaining could include those guidelines.

“If the goal is to keep someone at a school for a certain defined period of time, it’s got to be employment contracts,” Winter said.

Copyright 2026 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Photos You Should See – December 2025

TOPSHOT - This aerial view shows people carrying images of the Virgin of Guadalupe during the pilgrimage to the Basilica of Guadalupe through Paso de Cortes, near Amecameca, Mexico on December 9, 2025. (Photo by Alfredo ESTRELLA / AFP via Getty Images)



Link

Continue Reading

NIL

NIL contracts with Bison athletes a comprehensive, binding document – InForum

Published

on


FARGO — North Dakota State athletic director Matt Larsen says “never in a million years” did he foresee his position getting into legal agreements like Name, Image and Likeness contracts with student-athletes. Well, a million years suddenly became 2026.

Another step in the different world of college football is alive and well with the Bison, whose players are required to sign either one of two contracts with the athletic department: a student-athlete participation and publicity agreement that allows the university to use the student-athlete for marketing and promotional purposes and a more comprehensive NIL license agreement that is tied to funds players receive directly from the Green and Gold Fund, the collective that pays student-athletes from the athletic department.

Almost 80% of NDSU football players are part of the latter.

Contracts like NDSU’s are most likely the standard in college football these days.

“I don’t know about every school but I think if you’re doing any sort of in-house institutional NIL, these are the types of things you need to do,” Larsen said. “There are probably varying degrees to how extensive they are. We just felt like we wanted to do it right on the front end.”

NDSU’s NIL license agreement is nine pages of legal language. For instance, there are stipulations that do not allow the athlete to enter into a third-party agreement with a competitor of an athletic department or university sponsor (which is nothing new), such as Under Armour, Scheels, Gate City Bank or Sanford Health, among others.

They are not allowed to represent industries related to alcohol, tobacco, anabolic steroids, gambling or sexually-oriented businesses.

Not all football players are paid and not all are paid the same, with preference given to starters or veterans who contribute the most on the field. The contract specifies the student-athlete have a degree of confidentiality with the exception of the student-athlete’s authorized representative, immediate family members, tax adviser or legal counsel.

The contracts between student-athletes and the university are not subject to open records, mainly because of student privacy rights like the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA).

“It’s a completely new world,” Larsen said. “It’s not something I ever thought I would do yet here we are.”

Larsen didn’t want to get into how enforceable the contracts are, although it’s a general assumption that a multi-million dollar agreement with a Power Four athlete is vastly different from a contract with an FCS player.

042225.S.FF.SunderlandOffice9.jpg

North Dakota State athletic director Matt Larsen explains the details of the renovated Sunderland Family Football Office Complex, located inside the Fargodome, on April 21, 2025, during a press conference and ribbon cutting that unveiled the space.

Anna Paige / The Forum

It’s doubtful a school like NDSU would legally go after a player making $10,000 in NIL as opposed to the University of Washington suggesting this week it may take legal action against quarterback Demond Williams Jr., who signed a million-dollar NIL contract last week with the school but said he was entering the transfer portal this week.

All 425 NDSU student-athletes sign the participation and publicity contract, which grants NDSU to use them for promotional purposes. There is no revenue exchanged with the parties.

Both contracts didn’t come about overnight. NDSU met with multiple lawyers, including an external Title IX attorney and the North Dakota University System assistant attorney general, over the summer in creating the agreements.

Football players get paid between two and four times a year depending on their situation with the payments of NIL funds to NDSU athletes being done through a company called Teamworks LLC, an operating system that distributes funds. The company advertises that its platform helps with tax obligations and offers tools for savings and business accounts.

Larsen calls it a general manager tool. More than that, Larsen has become more than a director of his athletic department. Add general manager to that title, too.

“A lot of our terms are all pretty standard,” he said.

Standard, in 2026.

Jeff Kolpack

Jeff Kolpack, the son of a reporter and an English teacher, and the brother of a reporter, worked at the Jamestown Sun, Bismarck Tribune and since 1990 The Forum, where he’s covered North Dakota State athletics since 1995. He has covered all 10 of NDSU’s Division I FCS national football titles and has written four books: “Horns Up,” “North Dakota Tough,” “Covid Kids” and “They Caught Them Sleeping: How Dot Reinvented the Pretzel.” He is also the radio host of “The Golf Show with Jeff Kolpack” April through August.





Link

Continue Reading

Most Viewed Posts

Trending