NASCAR’s Evergreen Charter Victory May Have Just Created a Bigger Problem for the Sport

On paper, NASCAR’s recent antitrust settlement with 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports appears to be a significant win for the owners. After more than a year of legal battles, the deal finally delivered exactly what teams wanted: long-term security.

However, the new “evergreen” charters might have done more than stabilize the business. They may have quietly built a wall around the Cup Series that no one else can climb.

How Did the Settlement Change NASCAR’s Economics?

When charters arrived in 2016, they provided teams with guaranteed race entry and a share of the TV money. NASCAR initially handed them out for free, and they were never supposed to be permanent franchises. Instead, they existed only as long as NASCAR said so, leaving teams stuck with short-term contracts and long-term worry.

That uncertainty fueled the lawsuit, with 23XI and Front Row Motorsports fighting against the system’s lack of permanence and the heavy-handed leverage held by the sanctioning body.

The concept of permanent charters dominated the trial discussions. NASCAR executives admitted that making charters permanent would bring stability, but they also warned that it would skyrocket their value. That prediction is already coming true. Early estimates suggest that valuations could exceed $50 million, with some projections reaching even higher.

The price history tells the whole story. Less than a decade ago, you could pick up a charter for barely more than $1 million. By 2019, that price tag climbed past $5 million. Then things got crazy. Recent seasons have seen deals reach $28 million, $40 million, and, most recently, around $45 million. If permanence doubles those numbers as expected, even mid-tier charters could soon approach $100 million.

For the big teams, this is a jackpot. Powerhouse organizations with multiple charters now hold assets worth hundreds of millions, transforming race teams into serious investment vehicles. From a business perspective, the sport finally gave its most committed owners absolute security.

MORE: Why NASCAR’s Take-It-Or-Leave-It Gamble Collapsed Against Michael Jordan

But that win creates a serious problem. As prices explode, the door to the Cup Series slams shut for almost everyone else. Entering the sport isn’t just hard anymore; it’s nearly impossible. New owners or top-tier Xfinity squads face a financial barrier that makes moving up a pipe dream.

Even well-funded groups with great cars might stay on the sidelines simply because the upfront cash is too high. While the lower series still lets new blood rise through the ranks, the Cup Series is looking more and more like a closed club.

Ultimately, the evergreen charter fixed one issue but triggered another. Now, NASCAR must answer a tricky question: Can they maintain stability in the sport without excluding everyone else?