Baseball and gymnastics: Two sports that couldn’t be more different. Yet both sports have recently seen a similar trend in how the effects of relying on human judgement can impact competitive outcomes and fan frustrations.
College Sports
Oklahoma AD Joe Castiglione Steps Down; What’s Next for Sooners Athletics?
Joe Castiglione announced his retirement as Oklahoma’s athletic director after 27 years, ending the longest tenure of any current AD in major college sports. He’ll transition to Athletic Director Emeritus while the Sooners search for his replacement. What does this news mean for the “OU” football team? Will the school find a replacement by the […]

Joe Castiglione announced his retirement as Oklahoma’s athletic director after 27 years, ending the longest tenure of any current AD in major college sports. He’ll transition to Athletic Director Emeritus while the Sooners search for his replacement.
What does this news mean for the “OU” football team? Will the school find a replacement by the beginning of football season?

What Does AD Joe Castiglione’s Retirement Mean for Oklahoma Athletics?
Joe Castiglione built one of college sports’ most successful programs during his time in Norman. The numbers tell the story: 26 national championships across all sports, including eight softball titles and five Final Four appearances in basketball. He also guided Oklahoma through its move from the Big 12 to the SEC, a transition that reshaped college athletics.
ESPN’s Pete Thamel broke the news that Castiglione will step down during the 2025-26 academic year. The timing gives Oklahoma several months to find its successor while keeping him on campus as Athletic Director Emeritus.
Sources: Oklahoma AD Joe Castiglione will retire from his full-time role during the upcoming school year, bringing an end to the longest-tenured run for a current AD in major college sports. Upon the hiring of his successor, he will stay on as athletic director emeritus. pic.twitter.com/ZHHgMEiITT
— Pete Thamel (@PeteThamel) July 7, 2025
Thamel reported that Castiglione discussed retirement with university officials a month ago. “The timing of the move will allow OU to make a hire in the upcoming months and transition with Castiglione on campus,” he posted on X.
How Did Castiglione Transform Oklahoma Into a National Power?
When Castiglione took over in 1998, Oklahoma football had fallen from its championship heights of the 1970s and 1980s. He hired Bob Stoops in 1999, a move that paid off immediately when the Sooners won the national title in 2000. That championship marked the beginning of Oklahoma’s return to elite status.
His coaching hires shaped the program’s identity. After Stoops retired, Castiglione brought in Lincoln Riley, who led the Sooners to three College Football Playoff appearances. When Riley left for USC, he hired Brent Venables to rebuild the defense-first culture that made Oklahoma famous.
The softball program became Castiglione’s crown jewel. Those eight national championships made Oklahoma the premier destination for elite softball talent. The women’s basketball team reached multiple Final Fours, while men’s basketball had its moments under different coaches throughout his tenure.
HOW WELL WILL OKLAHOMA DO IN YEAR 2 OF SEC PLAY? CHECK OUR SEC SEASON PREDICTIONS
Beyond wins and losses, Castiglione navigated massive changes in college athletics. He managed the transition from the Big 12 to the SEC, a move that will generate millions more in revenue for Oklahoma. The shift to the SEC represents the biggest conference realignment move in school history.
Who Could Replace Castiglione at Oklahoma?
Finding Castiglione’s replacement won’t be simple. The new AD will inherit a program with high expectations across multiple sports and the pressure of competing in the SEC. They’ll also need to handle Name, Image, and Likeness deals, transfer portal management, and facility upgrades.
Yahoo Sports’ Ross Dellenger reported that Castiglione and university officials will hold a press conference Tuesday at 9 a.m. local time to discuss the transition and his new emeritus role.
Oklahoma announces that AD Joe Castiglione will hold a news conference Tuesday, with other school officials, to announce his retirement. It ends one of the longest running AD stints in the history of major Division I athletics. pic.twitter.com/P7DBBJLqSv
— Ross Dellenger (@RossDellenger) July 7, 2025
The search committee will likely target candidates with Power Five experience and proven fundraising abilities. Oklahoma’s athletic budget exceeds $200 million annually, requiring someone comfortable managing large-scale operations. Experience with conference realignment and media negotiations could also factor into the decision.
Castiglione’s emeritus role should help smooth the transition. His institutional knowledge and relationships with donors, coaches, and conference officials will be valuable resources for whoever takes over. The 28th year of his tenure will serve as a bridge to the next era of Sooners athletics.
College Sports
NCAA Gymnastics holds judges accountable for inaccurate scoring. Could their system be used for MLB umpires?
Baseball and gymnastics: Two sports that couldn’t be more different. Yet both sports have recently seen a similar trend in how the effects of relying on human judgement can impact competitive outcomes and fan frustrations. NCAA women’s gymnastics is perhaps the sport that’s benefitted the most from the Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) policy change […]

NCAA women’s gymnastics is perhaps the sport that’s benefitted the most from the Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) policy change that now allows collegiate athletes to profit from endorsements and sponsorships. Unlike in baseball where players have the potential to make money for a decade or more, the window of opportunity for gymnasts to earn money doing their sport is significantly smaller. Previously, the top gymnasts in the country typically competed for the national team at world championships or the Olympics between the ages of 16-19, and often had to make the difficult decision to relinquish their NCAA eligibility in favor of signing sponsorship deals. With the change to the NIL policy, those elite gymnasts no longer have to make a choice.
While correlation does not equate to causation, this influx of top international competitors also aligned with a widespread tendency towards inconsistent judging and leniency for certain schools and athletes. In the same way that an established All Star pitcher like Zack Wheeler might benefit from a slightly larger strike zone compared to a rookie, a former world championship or Olympic team member might get fewer deductions based on their reputation alone. This culminated in programs with multiple former national members seeming to get undeservedly high team scores and preferential treatment from judges.
Regardless of if the change in consistency was an unconscious attempt to reward those athletes and programs perceived as “better,” or even just a coincidence entirely, it led to an outcry from fans for the Women’s Collegiate Gymnastics Association (WCGA) to address the obvious issues with judging very similar to how baseball fans are now begging MLB to address its umpiring issue.
Whether baseball or gymnastics, it’s important to recognize that no judge or umpire is perfect and that human error will always play a factor in sports competitions, especially those with subjective components to them. But when blatant errors and inconsistent leniency are left unaddressed and allowed to continuously impact games and competitions, it becomes a fundamental flaw in the system.
Here’s how the WCGA has started to address that flaw:
Ahead of the 2024-2025 collegiate season, the WCGA announced new changes to the gymnastics scoring system and process. Among the changes included a new eight-person panel that evaluates the accuracy of each individual judge’s scores– essentially, a group of judges who judge the judges. Each individual gets scored against an “ideal” and is rewarded points for their accuracy, while also being deducted points for egregious errors. These points are then used to rank the judges, with the highest rated individuals favored to receive future postseason assignments. The evaluations are also used to provide targeted education to all judges regarding common errors and other issues.
It would definitely be possible for Major League Baseball to adopt this type of checks-and-balances system to oversee its umpiring. Similar to the WCGA’s system, a team of officials could be tasked with reviewing individual performances by umpires and rating their accuracy. Top performers could be rewarded with postseason assignments, while poor performers could be required to attend additional training or even face demotion to the minors. With actual rewards and consequences at stake, this could be a first step towards holding umpires accountable for their performance.
There are, of course, challenges to this type of system. With almost 400 meets in the collegiate gymnastics season, that equates to approximately 20,000 routines to be reviewed. And with an average of about 300 pitches thrown in each of the 2,430 MLB games per regular season, that comes out to nearly 800,000 pitches – and that’s just for the home plate umpire, that doesn’t even take into consideration calls made in the field. Creating a system to sample a database that large and provide accurate feedback for as many umpires as possible would not be an easy task. But, it wouldn’t be impossible.
The social media account “Umpire Scorecards” has already developed a way to determine strike zone accuracy and consistency, and identify impactful missed calls. Take the scorecard from this past Monday’s game against the Reds for example. Of the 125 called balls and strikes (256 pitches total) this system identified 15 that were inaccurate, giving home plate umpire Alfonso Márquez an 88% accuracy rating and an overall bias of +0.25 runs in favor of the Phillies. If each game produced an average of even double that at 30 calls for review, that would come out to about 73,000 reviews per season. That’s a far more reasonable task, especially for an organization with the resources to hire the required personnel.
It’s not a perfect system, by far. But what WCGA has implemented at least shows a willingness to take that first step in addressing the flaws of a human-based judging system. With a similar issue facing them, MLB should take notes.
College Sports
Bill O’Brien discusses decision to name Dylan Lonergan as Boston College’s starting QB
Boston College football head coach Bill O’Brien finally settled on a starting quarterback on Tuesday morning. Before the start of practice, Alabama transfer Dylan Lonergan was named the starter. After Tuesday’s practice where Lonergan got all the first team reps, O’Brien spoke about his decision. Pete Thamel was the first to report the news. “After careful […]

Boston College football head coach Bill O’Brien finally settled on a starting quarterback on Tuesday morning. Before the start of practice, Alabama transfer Dylan Lonergan was named the starter. After Tuesday’s practice where Lonergan got all the first team reps, O’Brien spoke about his decision. Pete Thamel was the first to report the news.
“After careful consideration throughout the winter, spring and summer, and now into training camp, we decided to go with Dylan Lonergan as the starter,” O’Brien said. “Look, it was a true competition give a lot of credit to Grayson James.” This seemingly ends an eight month battle in which the incumbent James, tried to hold off the new quarterback. James, also a transfer who originally committed to Jeff Hafley earned a lot of respect last year after he took over for Tommy Castellanos, winning three out of the final four regular season games for the Eagles and helping them become bowl eligible.
O’Brien has carefully watched the two quarterbacks at practice, and there were a few factors that came into his decision. “Dylan’s got a great feel for the game and he’s got a really good arm,” the head coach said after Tuesday’s practice. “He’s got good anticipation, good accuracy. He’s very calm, very poised. I just think at the end of the day, in the passing game. You know, Dylan was a little bit ahead of Grayson.”
Lonergan has deep roots with Bill O’Brien, who originally recruited him to Alabama to play under Nick Saban. He was part of a quarterback room that was flooded with talent including Ty Simpson (Alabama), Julian Sayin (Ohio State), Eli Holstein (Pitt) and others. This offseason, Lonergan jumped into the portal and re-united with his former offensive coordinator in Chestnut Hill.
On Tuesday, both quarterbacks were on the field, Lonergan zipping passes to Lewis Bond and Ty Lockwood and commanding the offense. But James also worked hard on Tuesday too, as he will give Boston College a veteran behind Lonergan in case the need arises. Boston College has had more than quarterback play meaningful snaps in every season for almost a decade due to injuries and other factors.
“[James] was obviously disappointed, but, was just like, ‘Coach, I’m gonna be a great teammate.'” O’Brien said about the former starter. “That’s what you’re looking for at Boston College. I can’t say enough about the guy. I think he’s got a future in football, he’ll be ready to play if called upon.”
Boston College will return to practice on Wednesday morning.
Sign up for our daily Boston College newsletter to get all of your Eagles news delivered directly to your email
– Follow AJ Black on Twitter, and check out the site Twitter handle as well, for updates and analysis.
The video player is currently playing an ad. You can skip the ad in 5 sec with a mouse or keyboardThe video player is currently playing an ad. You can skip the ad in 5 sec with a mouse or keyboard–Become a VIP, right now we have a great deal that will get you elite coverage and scoops you won’t find anywhere else!
— Don’t miss any of our new video content on our daily Eagles podcast “Locked on Boston College: Subscribe to the show on YouTube and hit the notification bell so you know when new videos drop.
– Need a go-to Eagles podcast? Listen to Locked on Boston College here, watch earlier episodes here and don’t forget to subscribe to IMS Radio on iTunes | Spotify | Web Based| Amazon Music (ad free!)
College Sports
Ice Hockey Announces 2025-26 Nonconference Schedule
Syracuse University women’s ice hockey team announced its nonconference schedule for the 2025-26 season. The Orange welcome UMD to a two-game series slated for Thursday Sept. 25 and Friday Sept. 26 at Tennity Ice Pavilion. The opening road series for Syracuse is set on Friday Oct. 3 and Saturday Oct. 4 at Stonehill […]

Syracuse University women’s ice hockey team announced its nonconference schedule for the 2025-26 season.
The Orange welcome UMD to a two-game series slated for Thursday Sept. 25 and Friday Sept. 26 at Tennity Ice Pavilion.
The opening road series for Syracuse is set on Friday Oct. 3 and Saturday Oct. 4 at Stonehill in Easton, Massachusetts.
Back at home, ‘Cuse host Quinnipiac on Friday Oct. 10 and Saturday Oct. 11 before beginning conference play.
The Orange hit the road for a Tuesday night matchup against Cornell in Ithaca, New York on Oct. 28, before hosting the Big Red for another game at home on Tuesday Nov. 8.
Finishing non-conference play, Syracuse split a series with RPI, hosting the first game at home on Friday Nov. 28 and facing the Engineers in Troy, New York. on Saturday Nov. 29.
Game times for the 2025-26 season will be announced at a later date.
For more on Syracuse Women’s Ice Hockey, follow @CuseIce on Instagram and X.
College Sports
Herd Men's Soccer Picked as Favorites in SBC Preseason Coaches Poll
Buy Men’s Soccer Season Tickets Here | Championship Fund HUNTINGTON, W.Va. – The Marshall Men’s Soccer team was picked to finish first in the 2025 Sun Belt Conference Preseason Coaches Poll, as announced by the league office on Wednesday. In addition to being picked atop the poll, junior defender Takahiro Fujita was named SBC Preseason Defensive Player of […]


Buy Men’s Soccer Season Tickets Here | Championship Fund
HUNTINGTON, W.Va. – The Marshall Men’s Soccer team was picked to finish first in the 2025 Sun Belt Conference Preseason Coaches Poll, as announced by the league office on Wednesday.
In addition to being picked atop the poll, junior defender Takahiro Fujita was named SBC Preseason Defensive Player of the Year and as a member of the conference’s all-preseason team.
Marshall received eight first place votes out of 10 in the poll coming in ahead of second-place WVU by five points after a run to the 2024 College Cup Championship match in 2024.
A native of Nara, Japan, Fujita was a Second-Team All-SBC selection in 2024 and was taken in the third round of the 2025 MLS SuperDraft by Orlando. Fujita tallied a pair of assists and a goal during the 2024 season while helping The Herd to 11 shutouts.
MU concludes the preseason with an exhibition at Maryland on Friday at 7:30 p.m. before opening the regular season at Hoops Family Field on August 22 at 7:15 p.m. against George Mason.
To donate to the Championship Fund for Marshall men’s soccer, please click HERE. All proceeds go directly to the Marshall men’s soccer team.
For all the latest information about Marshall men’s soccer, follow @herdmsoccer on Twitter and Instagram.
To follow all Thundering Herd sports and get live stats, schedules and free live audio, download the Marshall Athletics App for iOS and Android.
—HerdZone.com—
College Sports
Sherrone Moore reveals timetable for naming Michigan football’s starting QB
The post Sherrone Moore reveals timetable for naming Michigan football’s starting QB appeared first on ClutchPoints. The entire college football world expects Bryce Underwood to be Michigan’s starting quarterback in 2025, but Sherrone Moore is not ready to commit to that just yet. Advertisement While the entire country expects Underwood to get the nod, Moore […]

The post Sherrone Moore reveals timetable for naming Michigan football’s starting QB appeared first on ClutchPoints.
The entire college football world expects Bryce Underwood to be Michigan’s starting quarterback in 2025, but Sherrone Moore is not ready to commit to that just yet.
Advertisement
While the entire country expects Underwood to get the nod, Moore will not make an official announcement until the week leading into Michigan’s Week 1 matchup with New Mexico, according to 247 Sports’ Brice Marich. Underwood is the clear leader, but the Wolverines also have Fresno State transfer Mike Keene and former four-star prospect Jadyn Davis.
Even if it is not Underwood, Michigan expects a significant quarterback upgrade in 2025. The Wolverines bounced back-and-forth between Davis Warren, Alex Orji and Jack Tuttle in 2024, throwing just 1,678 passing yards as a team on the year. As a result, the Wolverines leaned heavily on their running back tandem of Kalel Mullings and Donovan Edwards and were as one-dimensional as a Power Five team could be.
Michigan is currently a 36-point favorite to beat New Mexico, suggesting multiple quarterbacks should see the field in Week 1. Assuming that the game goes the way Moore hopes, he will get a better gauge of the talent he has in the locker room between Underwood, Keene and Davis.
Bryce Underwood continues to lead Michigan’s quarterback room
Junfu Han / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images
While Sherrone Moore continues to be vague on Michigan’s quarterback room ahead of the 2025 college football season, the writing is already on the wall. If there were odds for the announcement, Bryce Underwood would be an overwhelming favorite to win the job.
Advertisement
Underwood has the least amount of experience of the group, but landed in Ann Arbor as one of the most-hyped prospects in program history. The terms of his $10 million NIL deal shook up the college football world and added more fuel to the ongoing debate.
Underwood has yet to prove himself on the field, but those in and around the team have done nothing but praise his development. The freshman enrolled early and is preparing for his second semester in the fall. He has impressed the coaching staff and his teammates on and off the field with his confidence, leadership, athleticism and maturity.
The prodigy will get one warm-up game of sorts against New Mexico before jumping into the fire in Week 2. Michigan will hit the road to face Oklahoma, Moore’s alma mater, on Sept. 6 in one of the top early-season heavyweight battles. The Sooners will begin the year ranked No. 18 in the preseason AP poll, four spots behind the Wolverines, who will debut at No. 14.
Related: Insider reveals reason for optimistic outlook on 2025 Michigan football season
Related: AP Poll history shows BYU is most underrated football team since 2014
College Sports
Providence College Athletics Has Record Year For Fundraising And Ticket Sales
PROVIDENCE, R.I. – The Providence College Athletics department raised $12.7 million in the fiscal year that concluded on June 30th. This exceeds the previous record of $10.8 million generated in 2023-24. This figure represents cash raised and does not include pledges, commitments or contributions to the Friar Family Collective. This milestone is highlighted by two […]

This milestone is highlighted by two $1 million gifts and record-breaking participation. This generosity from alumni, sponsors, parents, family and friends fuels the Providence College student-athlete experience and helps our teams compete for BIG EAST, Hockey East titles and national championships.
“Thanks to the unwavering support of the Friar Family—including our donors, alumni, partners, and fans—our momentum in revenue generation and ticket sales continues to drive our mission forward,” Athletic Director Steve Napolillo said. “These resources are vital as we compete for BIG EAST, Hockey East, and national championships. A special thank you to Father Sicard, our teammates, colleagues, dedicated coaches, staff and student-athletes. Their belief in and investment in Providence College are the foundation of our continued success.”
Additionally, Providence College Athletics achieved a standout year, generating $9.3 million in ticket revenue from men’s and women’s basketball, men’s ice hockey, and the signature Late Night Madness event—surpassing last year’s record of $8.5 million. Men’s basketball once again sold out its season ticket allotment at the Amica Mutual Pavilion and secured a strong 95-percent renewal rate for the 2025–26 season, with the waitlist now exceeding 1,800 seats. The women’s basketball program saw a 48-percent rise in fan attendance and hosted a game at the Amica Mutual Pavilion for the first time since 2010. Men’s ice hockey heads into the upcoming season boasting its largest season ticket holder base since 2016–17.
The Providence College ticket team was awarded the 2025 Ticket Team of the Year by the National Association of Athletic Ticket Sales & Operations (NAATSO). This honor recognizes institutions who have driven exceptional revenue growth, sparked innovation and championed collaboration in their departments setting an example across collegiate athletics.
“I’m incredibly proud of how our team shows up every day to serve our community,” Andrew Schoepfer, Associate AD of Revenue Generation and Business Intelligence said. “We have the best fans in the country, and we appreciate all the support they give our student- athletes. Being named NAATSO Ticket Team of the Year is a well-deserved honor and reflects the standard that our team strives to maintain, giving our fans the best experience. Ultimately, it is the hard work and talent of our Athletic Department that brings this all together creating a fantastic experience for our students, families, alumni, and the entire Friar community. It is also the growing revenue which allows us to make our commitment to athletic excellence.”
“We are incredibly grateful to all of the benefactors of Providence College Athletics, who, through their generosity, helped us accomplish this milestone,” Eric Burtchell ’13, Associate AD of External Relations/Major Gifts Officer said. “In the ever-changing landscape that is college athletics, we are fortunate to have so many passionate and committed donors who are helping elevate our student-athlete experience. Together, we will continue to bring Friartown to the next level.”
-end-
-
Technology2 weeks ago
Ally Runs New Game Plan in WNBA All-Star Rookie Debut
-
Health2 weeks ago
The Women Driving A New Era In U.S. Ski & Snowboard
-
High School Sports3 weeks ago
100 days to men's college basketball
-
NIL2 weeks ago
ESPN Announces 'dont wait run fast' by mgk as New College Football Anthem for 2025
-
College Sports3 weeks ago
City rows to sporting destination goal on boats of new complexes & old strengths
-
Sports2 weeks ago
Ntekpere honored as Second Team Academic All-American | APG State News
-
Health3 weeks ago
Trump administration investigates Oregon's transgender athlete policies
-
Rec Sports1 week ago
Swimming & Diving Comments on the Rules – 2025-26
-
Technology1 week ago
Amid Sports Chaos, ‘Known’ Data and Outcomes Help Agency Win
-
Sports3 weeks ago
More State Schools of the Year