My crowded inbox included an email from someone who couldn’t understand why I would have only Big Ten and SEC teams in my top 25.
Geez. I thought my explanation was sufficiently simple. It’s not a college football top 25. It’s a Big Ten/SEC top 25. If I did an ACC/Big 12 top 25 (maybe next year), it would include only ACC and Big 12 teams.
1. LSU: I’m not surprised the Tigers are 2-0. I am surprised their defense has looked much better than their potentially high-powered offense.
2. Ohio State: The Buckeyes paid Grambling $1 million for a victory. They pay All-American safeties more than that.
3. Oregon: Mike Gundy, please note: If you’re complaining about NIL payrolls, it’s time to retire, which means he should have retired before the Cowboys came up points poor against NIL-rich Oregon, 69-3.
4. Penn State: The Nittany Lions opened the season with victories over Nevada and FIU. Next comes Villanova, followed by an open date.
Translation: They could spend the first month of the season preparing for their Sept. 27 game against Oregon.
5. Texas: Arch Manning needed fewer than five minutes to throw four touchdown passes in a dazzling first-half stretch against San Jose State. As stout as Texas’ defense is, five minutes of offense might be all the Longhorns need on most Saturdays.
6. Oklahoma: Give the Sooners credit for their Michigan victory, which wasn’t as close as the 24-13 score. But they had better find somebody to share the running load with star quarterback John Mateer, who carried the ball 19 times for 74 yards. The rest of the Sooners combined for 21 carries.
7. Auburn: Tigers quarterback Jackson Arnold didn’t have to sell anybody on his running ability after rushing for 137 yards in an opening win over Baylor. But he gave his legs a rest against Ball State and completed 24 of 28 passes for 251 yards and three touchdowns.
8. Tennessee: Comedian Kevin Hart was at Neyland Stadium on Sept. 6. But the ETSU defense provided the laughs in the Vols’ 72-17 victory.
9. Georgia: The Bulldogs have won 43 consecutive games against unranked teams. But they don’t always look good doing it.
Anyone patient enough to watch Georgia’s rain-delayed 28-6 victory over Austin Peay can attest to that.
10. Southern Cal: The Trojans have scored 132 points and gained 1,352 yards in two games. And there’s more good news ahead for USC.
Up next is Purdue, which gave up more than 45 points in six different Big Ten games last season.
11. Illinois: The Illini finished strong to beat Duke by 26 points at Wallace Wade Stadium. But so few Duke fans were in attendance, Illinois shouldn’t get credit for a road win.
12. Nebraska: The Cornhuskers posted their first shutout in 16 years in a 66-0 rout of Akron, which was shut out for the first time in seven days.
13. Missouri: At the risk of starting a quarterback controversy, how about these stats:
Penn State quarterback Drew Allar has completed 62.7% of his passes and totaled 426 yards running and passing. Missouri quarterback Beau Pribula, a former Penn State backup, has completed 79.1% of his passes and produced 688 yards of offense.
14. Ole Miss: Kentucky keeps costing the Rebels.
Last season, it cost them a berth in the College Football with an upset win. Last week, it cost any Ole Miss fans who bet against Kentucky by kicking a field goal with eight seconds to go in a seven-point loss.
15. Michigan: Quarterback Bryce Underwood had a worse game in Norman, Oklahoma, than Texas’ Arch Manning did in Columbus, Ohio, a week earlier. Michigan’s heralded freshman completed only nine of 24 passes against Brent Venables’ defense.
16. Mississippi State: The Bulldogs needed an entire season to win eight games in 2024. Their last-minute upset of Arizona State gave them two wins in the first eight days of this season.
17. Vanderbilt: I expected the Commodores to beat favored Virginia Tech. But I didn’t expect them to outscore the Hokies by 34 points in the second half.
18. South Carolina: Just two weeks into the season, it’s obvious that anyone who punts to the Gamecocks’ Vicari Swain should lose his scholarship. Swain returned two punts for touchdowns against South Carolina State after returning another punt for a touchdown against Virginia Tech.
19. Texas A&M: Aggies quarterback Marcel Reed has changed his image from a running quarterback to a passing quarterback by throwing for seven touchdowns in two games. That tells me Texas A&M might have a chance at Notre Dame on Sept. 13.
20. Arkansas: As good as Reed’s stats are, they don’t match Taylen Green’s. In two games, the Arkansas quarterback has thrown for 10 touchdowns and rushed for 192 yards.
21. Alabama: For the second consecutive game, the Tide failed to score as many points as Florida State. They scored 73 against UL Monroe, but the Seminoles had 77 against East Texas A&M.
22. Minnesota: The Gophers scored so many touchdowns against Northwestern State they exhausted their fireworks supply in a 66-0 victory.
ADAMS: SEC predictions: Tennessee football will keep Josh Heupel perfect vs in-state teams
23. Wisconsin: Congrats to the Badgers for their 2-0 start, and my heartfelt sympathy for their schedule, which has them playing Alabama, Michigan, Ohio State and Oregon in the next six games.
24. Indiana: Congrats to the Hoosiers for a nonconference schedule comprised of Old Dominion, Kennesaw State and Indiana State – and a Big Ten schedule that doesn’t include Ohio State, Southern Cal or Michigan.
25. Florida: I haven’t decided if the Gators are the fourth or fifth best team in Florida. I need to see more of UCF before I make that call.
John Adams is a senior columnist. He may be reached at 865-342-6284 or john.adams@knoxnews.com.