James Hagens is no stranger to the Utah Mammoth.
When asked which players he has looked to in the NHL to model his game after, a familiar name surfaced.
“I grew up watching Patrick Kane, I grew up watching John Tavares. Now, Jack Hughes and Logan Cooley,” Hagens said. “The way [Cooley] has been able to jump in the league and the things he’s done, it’s special. He’s a special player. He’s always been so good in the way he controls the game and the way he thinks it — it’s something that separates him.”
Hagens, who is one of the top players in the 2025 draft class, has taken a path that somewhat resembles Cooley’s. Both centers played for the United States National Team Development Program (USNTDP) before jumping to NCAA hockey. Each went into their drafts as highly-touted, undersized options, too. Cooley went third overall in 2022 to the Arizona Coyotes.
Utah now has the fourth overall selection this year and Hagens sees landing in Salt Lake City as an option.
“I’ve watched a ton of the Utah games,” Hagens said. “I’m a big fan of the new logo as well, the Mammoth. It’d be super cool to be able to be a draft pick for the new logo Mammoth.”
(Bethany Baker | The Salt Lake Tribune) Utah Hockey Club center Logan Cooley (92) brings the puck down the ice at Delta Center in Salt Lake City on Monday, March 24, 2025.
A year ago, Hagens was widely viewed as the No. 1 overall pick in the 2025 NHL Draft. Since then, Matthew Schaefer, Michael Misa and Caleb Desnoyers have drawn more attention and bubbled to the top of mock orders.
Part of it is because players like Misa, a 6-foot-1 center, tore it up in the Ontario Hockey League this season. Misa had 134 points (62 goals, 72 assists) in 65 games. Hagens played for Boston College last year and had 37 points (11 goals, 26 assists) in 37 games. It is not a fair comparison, though. The level of the NCAA sport — particularly in Hockey East, which is one of the best conferences — is much more of a challenge than the Canadian Junior routes.
Hagens has also been knocked for his size. The 18-year-old stands at 5-foot-11, 176 pounds. His draft-class counterparts are bigger.
There has been a lot of noise around Hagens. He is trying to stay grounded.
“You just kind of have to be grateful about it. Being able to hear your name in those conversations. Obviously, leading up to the draft now — having the opportunity to get drafted to any organization in the league, it’s something you have to be grateful for,” Hagens said. “The noise will always be there, but you just have to make sure you’re living in the moment and taking it day by day.”
(Rick Egan | The Salt Lake Tribune) Utah Hockey Club General Manager Bill Armstrong answers questions during media day at the Delta Center, on Wednesday, Sept. 18, 2024.
The ambiguity around Hagens’ ranking makes the possibility of him being available for Utah at No. 4 real. If it were up to his former head coach, Nick Fohr, who had Hagens at the USNTDP, the decision would be easy.
“I’ve had NHL teams calling and talking to me about him. I tell them all, ‘If you get a chance to pick him, pick him. You’re not going to be disappointed,’” Fohr said. “This kid has just proven it over and over again everywhere he goes.”
Fohr and his staff knew about Hagens far before his name started hitting the NHL headlines. The USNTDP selects the best 16- to 18-year-old players around the country for its U-17 and U-18 teams. Accordingly, scouts and coaches are following these guys through their youth careers.
Some players don’t pan out. Others take the opportunity and run with it. That is what Hagens did.
“I think his coming out party for everybody on the world stage was the Under-17 World Challenge where he set the record for the most points in the history of that tournament,” Fohr said. “I think that’s when everybody went, ‘Oh boy, this kid’s pretty good.’ They started talking about him being a really high pick for this coming draft.”
Hagens posted 102 points (39 goals, 63 assists) in 58 games with the U18 Team in 2023-2024 before transitioning to Boston College. He was dominant in all three zones against older, stronger opponents. Fohr never saw Hagens’ size as a deterrent.
“It hasn’t affected his game at the younger levels at all. His intelligence, his hockey IQ, his skating ability, his ability to make plays and to think the game at a higher level — size doesn’t impact him with those types of assets and attributes,” Fohr said.
“People fall in love with size because it’s size and you can’t coach it, but I think you see guys like Jack Hughes, Clayton Keller and Logan Cooley — the success that they’re having as undersized guys. There’s a place for him in the game.”
While Hagens no doubt got knocked around a bit more in college hockey, he still centered Boston College’s first line between Gabe Perreault and Ryan Leonard (who are both now in the NHL).
“I love making plays. I love being able to find a guy backdoor. That’s something that I feel like is a big part of my game my whole entire career here. I wouldn’t say that I ever deflect away from shooting the puck,” Hagens said. “I know when to shoot and when to pass. Just something that really helps take my game to the next level is the way I’m able to find other guys.”
Some were expecting Hagens to make a bigger splash in terms of production in the NCAA, though.
In the past few years, centers like Macklin Celebrini and Adam Fantilli played in college ahead of their respective drafts. Celebrini had 64 points (32 goals, 32 assists) in 38 games with Boston University in his freshman season in 2023-2024. Fantilli had 65 points (30 goals, 35 assists) in 36 games in his freshman season with the University of Michigan in 2022-2023. Both won the Hobey Baker Award (given to the top men’s ice hockey player in the NCAA Division I). Celebrini was selected first overall in 2024 by the San Jose Sharks; Fantilli went third overall in 2023 to the Columbus Blue Jackets.
Hagens did not close in on any of those numbers or accolades. He still took lessons from his first year with the Eagles. Hagens said no decision has been made if he will return for his sophomore campaign; that will be discussed after the draft. But he will be focused on “maturing [his] game — especially off the ice as well, making sure you’re doing all those little things that help you get ready for the games and prepare.”
Hagens’ focus now shifts to the NHL Scouting Combine, which will take place in Buffalo, New York, from June 2 to 7. All of the top prospects attend and go through interviews with prospective organizations and fitness testing. Hagens will meet with Utah general manager Bill Armstrong and his staff.
FILE – William Smith participates in the vertical jump during the NHL hockey combine June 10, 2023, in Buffalo, N.Y. Smith could go anywhere between fourth and seventh in the upcoming NHL draft. (AP Photo/Jeffrey T. Barnes, File)
What does he want to get across in these conversations?
“Going into these meetings just really expressing how hard I compete and how badly I want to be on a team and hopefully win a Stanley Cup one day,” Hagens said. “I love winning. I will do anything to win. Something that’s helped me get to the point where I am today is just how hard I’ve been able to work my whole life. Nothing’s ever come easy. I’ve had to work for everything that I’ve ever gotten before.”
There is no saying for certain where Hagens will end up. Utah has been looking for size, but with the recent signing of Daniil But, its mindset going into the draft could change. Cooley and Hagens as the No. 1 and No. 2 centers could be the makeup of a contending team.
It seems Hagens wouldn’t mind playing with one of his role models, either.
“It is one step in your process but you just have to be ready. Getting drafted has been my dream my whole entire life,” Hagens said. “That’s why I started playing hockey, that’s why I still play. I’m really just grateful for everything right now.”