QUILCENE — In a closely split decision, the Quilcene School District board has voted to prohibit transgender students from participating in school sports in accordance with their gender identity. The vote, held during a May 7 meeting, passed 3-2 and sparked heated debate among board members, parents, and students in the small Jefferson County community.
Located south of Port Townsend, Quilcene is one of the first school districts in Washington to adopt such a ban, putting it at odds with the state’s interscholastic sports policy.
During the meeting, strong opinions were voiced from both sides of the issue. Board members Ron Frantz and Viviann Kuehl engaged in a pointed exchange over how Title IX—the federal law prohibiting sex-based discrimination in education—should be interpreted.
“Title 9 is the law,” Frantz stated firmly, implying that gender-based sports divisions should align with biological sex.
“This is an interpretation, this is not the law,” countered Kuehl. “The law nowhere in it says only biological males can play biological male sports, by tradition. That is not in Title 9.”
Frantz replied, “I’m probably the only one who’s read the whole thing of Title 9.”
“I did myself,” Kuehl said. “It doesn’t say that.”
The decision comes despite a longstanding policy from the Washington Interscholastic Activities Association (WIAA), which has since 2007 allowed students to participate in sports consistent with their gender identity. The WIAA policy emphasizes inclusion and equal access for transgender athletes, and it remains in effect for member schools across the state.
It is unclear whether the Quilcene School District’s new rule will trigger any legal challenges or sanctions from the WIAA. State officials and advocacy groups have not yet issued public statements in response to the vote.
For now, the decision underscores the broader national debate playing out at local school boards over the participation of transgender youth in competitive athletics.
Source: FOX 13





