Why States Are Beginning to Approve NIL for High School Athletes from NOCAP Sports

The wave that reshaped college sports is now pressing on the doors of high school athletics, and the pressure is coming from several directions at once. Cultural energy, parental awareness, athlete empowerment, and brand interest have all played a role. But if you strip away the noise, the real driver behind the next phase of NIL adoption is something much simpler: legal reality.

Find out more about NOCAP Sports HERE

States are beginning to approve name, image, and likeness rights for high school athletes because the alternative is becoming legally indefensible. The recent situation in Ohio provides a clear example of how quickly momentum shifts once litigation enters the conversation.

Earlier this month, an Ohio athlete who had been offered an NIL deal filed a lawsuit against the state high school athletic association after being denied the ability to accept it. Within days, the association reversed course. The timing was not accidental. The rule was unlikely to withstand legal scrutiny because it restricted a fundamental economic right. Once the lawsuit exposed that vulnerability, the association understood that maintaining the ban would almost certainly lead to a loss in court.

Across the country, state high school associations operate independently from legislatures. They write their own eligibility rules and they vote on their own policy changes. This structure gives them a great deal of autonomy, but it also means they hold responsibility for ensuring those rules do not violate state or federal law. NIL restrictions have increasingly crossed that line.

At its core, NIL is not a competitive issue. It is an economic one. Preventing a teenager from monetizing their own name is not meaningfully different from preventing them from earning money through music, social media, or part-time work. The athlete in Ohio did not challenge a competitive imbalance. They challenged the idea that a governing body could unilaterally block a young person from participating in the broader economy. That is why lawsuits are becoming the most powerful forcing mechanism in the high school NIL debate.

Every state association is watching the same trend unfold. Courts have been overwhelmingly clear that athletes, whether college or high school aged, have enforceable publicity rights and economic rights. Associations can try to maintain legacy guardrails, but they cannot deny fundamental liberties indefinitely. The result is a slow but inevitable policy migration toward NIL permissiveness.

This shift is not driven by a desire to commercialize youth sports. In many states, the governing bodies know full well that approving NIL does not mean every high school athlete becomes a brand partner on day one. What it does mean is that associations recognize their own legal exposure. When you add cases like Ohio to the list of earlier developments in California, Illinois, Alaska, New York, and others, the picture becomes clearer. States are not acting because they want to innovate. They are acting because the cost of standing still is too high.

There is also a secondary factor accelerating change. Brands are increasingly cautious about entering environments where the rules are unclear. When a state approves NIL, it sends a signal of stability. It does not promise a gold rush, but it does establish a legitimate framework where athletes can participate safely and brands can operate with confidence. Associations may not be financially motivated to embrace NIL (more on taxation in later issues), but they are motivated to reduce uncertainty. Approving NIL rights eliminates ambiguity and protects the ecosystem.

Critics often argue that NIL at the high school level invites chaos. The fear is that wealthy schools, ambitious collectives, or recruiting-driven communities will leverage NIL to tilt competition. But in practice, that has not been the trend. Most high school NIL deals are modest, often tied to local businesses, community supporters, or digital content. States that have adopted NIL have not seen rapid erosion of competitive balance. They have simply acknowledged that economic participation exists, and that ignoring it does more harm than good.

The more meaningful question is not whether states will approve NIL. It is what the pace of adoption will look like. Some have moved preemptively, understanding the legal and cultural momentum. Others will hold their ground until a lawsuit forces their hand. But the destination is already clear. High school associations cannot justify denying athletes rights that every other teenager in their state enjoys.

The Ohio situation did not create a new standard. It revealed the one that already existed. When an athlete challenges a rule that restricts their ability to earn income from their identity, the courts will side with the athlete. Associations can wait for that ruling, or they can write policy that respects economic freedom and protects the integrity of their governance structures.

The smart states are choosing the latter. The rest will follow. The only remaining variable is time.

About Youth Sports Business Report

Youth Sports Business Report is the largest and most trusted source for youth sports industry news, insights, and analysis covering the $54 billion youth sports market. Trusted by over 50,000 followers including industry executives, investors, youth sports parents and sports business professionals, we are the premier destination for comprehensive youth sports business intelligence.

Our core mission: Make Youth Sports Better. As the leading authority in youth sports business reporting, we deliver unparalleled coverage of sports business trends, youth athletics, and emerging opportunities across the youth sports ecosystem.

Our expert editorial team provides authoritative, in-depth reporting on key youth sports industry verticals including:

• Sports sponsorship and institutional capital (Private Equity, Venture Capital)
• Youth Sports events and tournament management
• NIL (Name, Image, Likeness) developments and compliance
• Youth sports coaching and sports recruitment strategies
• Sports technology and data analytics innovation
• Youth sports facilities development and management
• Sports content creation and digital media monetization

Whether you’re a sports industry executive, institutional investor, youth sports parent, coach, or sports business enthusiast, Youth Sports Business Report is your most reliable source for the actionable sports business insights you need to stay ahead of youth athletics trends and make informed decisions in the rapidly evolving youth sports landscape.

Join our growing community of 50,000+ industry leaders who depend on our trusted youth sports business analysis to drive success in the youth sports industry.

Stay connected with the pulse of the youth sports business – where industry expertise meets actionable intelligence.

Sign up for the biggest newsletter in Youth Sports – Youth Sports HQ – The best youth sports newsletter in the industry 

Follow us on LinkedIn

Follow Youth Sports Business Report Founder Cameron Korab on LinkedIn

Are you a brand looking to tap into the world’s most passionate fanbase… youth sports?

Introducing Play Up Partners, a leading youth sports marketing agency connecting brands with the power of youth sports. We specialize in youth sports sponsorships, partnerships, and activations that drive measurable results.

About Play Up Partners

Play Up Partners is a leading youth sports marketing agency connecting brands with the power of youth sports. We specialize in youth sports sponsorships, partnerships, and activations that drive measurable results.

Why Sponsor Youth Sports?

Youth sports represents one of the most engaged and passionate audiences in sports marketing. With over 70 million young athletes and their families participating annually, the youth sports industry offers brands unparalleled access to motivated communities with strong purchasing power and loyalty.

What Does Play Up Partners Do?

We’ve done the heavy lifting to untangle the complex youth sports landscape so our brand partners can engage with clarity, confidence, and impact. Our vetted network of accredited youth sports organizations (from local leagues to national tournaments and operators) allows us to create flexible, scalable programs that evolve with the market.

Our Approach

Every partnership we build is rooted in authenticity and value creation. We don’t just broker deals. We craft youth sports marketing strategies that:

• Deliver measurable ROI for brand partners
• Create meaningful experiences for athletes and families
• Elevate the youth sports ecosystem

Our Vision

We’re positioning youth sports as the most desirable and effective platform in sports marketing. Our mission is simple: MAKE YOUTH SPORTS BETTER for athletes, families, organizations, and brand partners.

Common Questions About Youth Sports Marketing

Where can I sponsor youth sports? How do I activate in youth sports? What is the ROI of youth sports marketing? How much does youth sports sponsorship cost?

We have answers. Reach out to info@playuppartners.com to learn how Play Up Partners can help your brand navigate the youth sports landscape.

Youth sports organizations: Interested in partnership opportunities? Reach out to learn about our accreditation process.