When Penn State hockey pioneer Roy Scott arrived on campus in 1971, he was disappointed the school didn’t have a hockey team.
To address that issue, former coach Joe Battista said Scott went around and received nearly 5,000 signatures from students, petitioning to create a club hockey team.
As Scott and his teammates began to play as a club team, initial thoughts swirled around about elevating the team to Division I status. At the time, however, they were just happy to have a competitive place to play hockey.
“We just wanted to play,” Scott told The Daily Collegian. “It seemed like whether it was going to be a true Division I or not were immaterial at the very beginning.”
Fast forward 15 years, and Battista had joined Penn State as a coach for the club team. From the moment he set foot on campus in 1986, Battista began pushing for Division I status from the moment he stepped foot on campus.
“We put together proposals in the early 80s, in the late 80s, in the early 90s, in the late 90s, in the early 2000s, in the mid 2000s,” Battista told the Collegian. “We had done the groundwork, the feasibility studies, of what it would cost to make the program Division 1.”
Those dreams started tiptoeing their way to reality when athletic director Tim Curley was appointed seven years later. Scott returned to the program for an alumni event years later, where Curley approached him about the future of the program.
“I remember Tim Curley coming up to me on some alumni weekend,” Scott said. “And he said, ‘Scotty, I love hockey. Penn State would really love to have a full Division I team. All we need from you is $30 million dollars.’”
The team won its first ACHA National Championship a few years later in 1997. Five years later, Penn State had itself another four league championships.
As the club team racked up success under Battista, administration began looking for donors to support the program in becoming a Division I sport.
In comes Terry Pegula. Although Pegula didn’t play hockey for the university, Scott said he showed interest in funding Penn State’s project after growing his love for hockey as a volunteer youth coach. On top of that, Pegula was also a Pennsylvania native.
In 2011, Pegula donated $88 million to elevate the Nittany Lions to Division I status after nearly 40 years of efforts — a donation that wound up reaching $102 million.
At the reception ceremony where the university accepted Pegula’s gift, Scott met Craig Patrick, the assistant coach of the Pittsburgh Penguins and the Team USA squad that won a gold medal, a run that became known as the 1980 Miracle on Ice.
“I went up to Mr. Patrick and introduced myself,” Scott said. “I told him, ‘Tonight, Penn State hockey fans believe in miracles.’”
Penn State began its first season as a Division I program in 2013, where it unveiled the newly built Pegula Ice Arena. It opened back-to-back years with losing records, but in Year 3, coach Guy Gadowsky — who initially coached the club team beginning in 2011 — did what he was hired to do: win.
“(When I interviewed him), I was so blown away by him, I called the Pegulas up,” Battista said. “They were in Philadelphia at a Sabres (versus) Flyers playoff game, and so coach Gadowsky and I drove to Philadelphia. We went and met the Pegulas before the game, and they interviewed him. After a half hour, Kim (Pegula) walked up and said, ‘Guy’s awesome.’”
Over the next three years, the Nittany Lions built on their record as they fought for postseason success. In 2017, the next step of the dream came true as the blue and white won its first Big Ten Tournament title and earned its first NCAA Tournament appearance.
“I just thought the blueprint was laid out perfectly to have a really competitive hockey (team),” John Davis, a former player, told the Collegian.
As the postseason wins stacked up and the Nittany Lions gained newer and hotter recruits, fans and players alike knew a turning point was coming soon where they would officially put themselves on the map.
“They’ve been close for a couple years now,” Chase Berger, a former player, told the Collegian. “You want to see the program go to new heights.
While the 2024-25 season ultimately ended in new heights, the path there was unlike most.
Through the first two months of the season, Penn State was 0-8 in conference play and 7-9 overall — a poor position for a team seeking a bid into the NCAA Tournament.
“I had buddies texting me like, ‘What’s going on,’” Alex Limoges, a former player, said. “It seemed like a down year, and then at Christmastime, they started getting hot and couldn’t lose for a while.”
After falling to Notre Dame in a shootout at Wrigley Field to open 2025, the Nittany Lions began to turn their record around. Over the next three months, Gadowsky’s squad won two shootouts over No. 1 Michigan State, defeated No. 2 Minnesota in overtime and tallied only three losses in 17 games.
“These guys were waiting to get over the hump,” Berger said. “They’ve been knocking on the door for a while. I think they broke through.”
As the blue and white entered the Big Ten Tournament, it swept No. 4-seeded Michigan in the best-of-three quarterfinals before falling in overtime to Ohio State in a semifinal heartbreaker.
“The turning around is phenomenal,” Davis said. “I think that’s what they should be most proud of.”
The Nittany Lions earned a bid to the NCAA Tournament, beginning with a first-round matchup against Maine in Allentown.
With a dominating 5-1 victory over the Black Bears, Penn State was set up for the regional final and NCAA quarterfinal contest versus UConn with a spot to the Frozen Four on the line.
“There was just an energy and an excitement,” Battista said. “It was everything we’d always dreamed about when we dared to dream that we’d be a Division I hockey program.”
The blue and white had been in that same spot before in 2023 when it was just an overtime goal away from the last four against Big Ten rival Michigan. However, it was the Wolverines who put the Nittany Lions to bed and still searching for a first Frozen Four.
But Penn State was determined to change that two years later. After tying up with the Huskies going into the final five minutes of regulation, sophomore Matt DiMarsico put the Nittany Lions ahead en route to their first-ever Frozen Four appearance with an overtime winner.
“I just remember the moment when they scored that goal,” Battista said. “I just left my feet, grabbed my wife, hugged her and jumped up and down. I’m crying, and it’s like I don’t know, it was just years of wow, what an amazing turn around.”
While Penn State ultimately fell in its Frozen Four appearance against Boston University, the team provided a once-in-a-lifetime experience to its faithful fans.
“I think obviously the players and coaches are really excited, but I think it’s also just really nice to award the fans that have always been so good in Penn State hockey,” Berger said. “They’ve always traveled, they’ve always supported.”
As the Frozen Four match put Penn State on the map and earned high-level transfers and recruits like Mac Gadowsky, Kevin Reidler, Luke Misa and Jackson Smith, the final step of Penn State’s goal appears closer to its reach.
“I don’t think we’ll have to wait too much longer for a national championship,” Limoges said.
MORE HOCKEY CONTENT
Last Friday night, all in attendance at the Peacock Theatre — home of the 2025 NHL Entry Dra…