Connect with us
https://yoursportsnation.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/call-to-1.png

NIL

College football fans, donors drove the clown car in NIL era, but was that so bad?

Published

on

College football fans, donors drove the clown car in NIL era, but was that so bad?


College sports fans and donors as much power and influence as ever in NIL era that began in 2021.Old model of college sports featuring unpaid athletes is not returning, but more evolution awaits.Fans and boosters enjoyed agency in NIL era. Their donations set the market rate.You’re going to miss this era of college sports, because at least a portion of this so-called “chaos” excites you. It entertains you. It empowered you, the fan.

You’re going to miss this unregulated, unencumbered and ever so slightly unhinged era of college sports. You’ll miss that the absence of “guardrails” meant enjoying the freedom to crank the speedometer as high as you can take it.

You’re going to miss that this era of college sports granted you, the fans, the most influence you’ve ever possessed.

Your dollars determined the market rate. How much you donated (or didn’t donate) dictated a roster’s payroll. You had a seat in the clown car. Heck, you might have been driving it. If your team won big, you could take pride in knowing you (and maybe a few millionaire and billionaire donors whom you don’t know) contributed to that success.

Tennessee defensive back Jalen McMurray (6) pulls down Alabama wide receiver Ryan Williams (2) during their game at Neyland Stadium on Saturday, Oct. 19, 2024, in Knoxville. Tenn.

Maybe you think your team’s quarterback or slot receiver is overpaid, but, your dollars allowed for that payday. If the product stinks, you can snap your wallet shut and withhold NIL donations until the university brass triggers a coaching change.

If you didn’t pony up a single NIL donation and just wanted to watch the games, well, you enjoyed that freedom. Contributing to NIL is entirely optional.

More change is coming within college sports. I don’t know what shape this next system will take, only that it will be different. I’m skeptical fans will retain as much agency as they’ve had these past few years.

BEST OF BEST: Our ranking of college football’s top 25 coaches

RE-RANK: Texas leads college football NCAA 1-136 after spring

Fans, donors took the wheel of NIL era of college sports

Coaches depended on you to fund their roster, but you weren’t obligated to fork over the cash. You controlled the power of the purse.

What does this power look like in action? Consider LSU this offseason. The school’s donors and fans increased their giving these past several months. For return on that investment, coach Brian Kelly assembled the nation’s top-ranked transfer class. Now, the Tigers look more like a playoff team, maybe even a national championship contender. That’s the byproduct of a fan and donor base working to achieve a common goal.

No longer must you depend on the ball coach being an ace recruiter (or good at sliding money under the table in a fast-food bag). Now, fan dollars gathered above the table facilitate roster assembly.

The NCAA’s former system of unpaid athletes isn’t returning, no matter how much reminiscing occurs. The courts deemed that old model illegal and smashed it to bits. Whatever’s next won’t look like 2020, but not like 2024, either.

NIL an optional fan expense; revenue-sharing will be more direct

Athlete empowerment irks a certain portion of College Sports Inc., and coaches understandably crave more roster control, but their grievances don’t end there. They disliked ceding control to third-party collectives. These NIL groups, bankrolled and operated by donors and fans, became college football’s lifeblood these past few years. Coaches and administrators would like nothing more than to tamp down fans’ power while still collecting their cash.

Schools are trying to bring the NIL operation in house and take control of dispensing your dollars.

Revenue-sharing awaits around the bend. That amounts to new expenses. If you think any serious administrative belt-tightening will occur to offset those costs, well, I’ve got a property in Illinois to sell you with a mountain view. Expect at least some of the revenue-sharing costs to be passed to fans. NIL donations were optional. Revenue sharing will be a more direct expense passed on in the form of ticket-price hikes. Athletic directors can dress up these price hikes by dubbing them “talent fees,” but no matter what they call it, this shifts more direct financial burden onto fans, even if your power decreases.

Off in the distance, federal bureaucrats sniff around the hen house. College sports leaders keep begging Congress to provide government regulations that rein in athlete freedoms and dial down the influence fans and donors enjoy in this current landscape.

I won’t try to convince you everything went perfectly these past few years. Stanford being in the same conference as Florida State will never make sense. It’s probably not ideal that athletes can transfer an unlimited number of times without penalty, either.

Overall, though, I wonder whether fans might someday look back on these past few years as the good ol’ days that were underappreciated in the moment.

Coaches, administrators and conference commissioners insist unfettered athlete freedoms, paired with unprecedented fan and donor influence, produced “chaos.” They called it the Wild, Wild West. I see it differently. Maybe, College Sports Inc. just couldn’t stand that you, the fans and donors, became the sheriff in town.

Blake Toppmeyer is the USA TODAY Network’s national college football columnist. Email him at BToppmeyer@gannett.com. Follow him on X @btoppmeyer.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

NIL

Big NIL boost for Carson Beck after Miami’s dominant Week 2 win

Published

on


Carson Beck’s stock is more volatile than GameStop’s. Beck earned huge acclaim in his first season as the Georgia quarterback before disappointing expectations a tad bit in his second season with the Dawgs last fall. Now, after a change of scenery and stepping in the shoes of the No. 1 pick in the 2024 NFL Draft, Beck looks like an acclaimed prospect once again.

Through two starts as the Miami QB1 for Beck, the Hurricanes are 2-0 and have their eye locked on the College Football Playoff after narrowly missing the dance a year ago thanks to a late-season collapse. Even without key losses late in last year’s schedule, the ‘Canes hadn’t built a resume full of quality wins. But this season, they’re already on the board with the Notre Dame victory over the reigning national runner-ups.

Then, in Week 2, Miami crushed Bethune-Cookman to the tune of a 45-3 win, which only further boosted Beck’s profile. Always one of the most valuable players in the country according to On3’s NIL valuations, Beck is rising even higher right now.

According to On3’s data, Carson Beck is the second-highest-valued college athlete in the country, only trailing Arch Manning. On3 had Beck’s value jump 9% this week, adding roughly $400,000 to make it a $4.7 million NIL valuation for the Miami starting quarterback.

Beck’s NIL value held steady around $4.3 million heading into the year and remained there through the first week of the 2025 college football season. But after stringing together two strong performances to open the season, On3 saw fit to bump Beck up by nearly half-a-million bucks.

Carson Beck has a chance to harpoon that value or raise it even higher as the ‘Canes face a South Florida club that’s heading down to Miami at 2-0 and ranked No. 18 in the country by the latest AP Top 25 poll. This very well could be a preview matchup between a pair of teams that wind up making the College Football Playoff come wintertime.



Link

Continue Reading

NIL

Why college football’s biggest battles are now political

Published

on


On this week’s episode of Tying it Together, host Tim Boyum talks with Matt Brown from Extra Points. 

As the college football season heats up, we are talking about the politics of college athletics, from NIL and conference realignment to even video games. Will politicians intervene? 

We tackle it all with the founder and publisher of Extra Points, which tackles all things college sports off the field.

About the Podcast

With the speed of the local news cycle, it’s easy to forget that the politicians who represent us and the influencers in our communities are more than just a sound bite. North Carolina’s veteran reporter and anchor, Tim Boyum, loosens his signature bow tie to give listeners a glimpse behind the curtain, showing us who these power players really are and why they do what they do. Through Tim’s candid conversations on “Tying It Together,” his guests reveal their most fascinating life stories, passions, and help all of us get a better grasp on the issues affecting our communities.

Listen and Subscribe

Apple | Spotify | Stitcher

Join the Conversation

Do you have any thoughts or questions for Tim? Weigh in on X with the hashtag #TyingItTogetherNC. Afterward, rate the podcast and leave a review to tell us what you think!



Link

Continue Reading

NIL

What The NIL Market For Wide Receivers Means For Oregon’s Dakorien Moore

Published

on


Oregon Ducks wide receiver Dakorien Moore is in his true freshman season with the program, but he’s already one of Oregon’s bigger stars. Moore joined the Ducks as a five-star recruit and the No. 1 wide receiver from the class of 2025.

With the addition of Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) deals in college sports, the wide receiver position has been one of the largest markets. On3’s Pete Nakos broke down which wide receivers are making the most money through NIL deals, representing both from the school and the NIL collective, and the amount Moore is estimated to be receiving from Oregon was revealed.

Oregon Ducks Dakorien Moore Jeremiah Smith Ohio State Buckeyes NIL Recruiting Dan Lanning Evan Stewart College Football NIL

Sep 6, 2025; Eugene, Oregon, USA; Oregon Ducks head coach Dan Lanning greets fans before a game against the Oklahoma State Cowboys at Autzen Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Troy Wayrynen-Imagn Images / Troy Wayrynen-Imagn Images

Per On3, sources have indicated that Moore’s deal with the Oregon Ducks is at least $700,000, and he was the only true freshman to be listed. The other players were all either returning players or acquired through the NCAA Transfer Portal.

While he is up there in his earnings, several wide receivers are earning at least $1 million, which could affect Moore in the future. 

Oregon Ducks Dakorien Moore Jeremiah Smith Ohio State Buckeyes NIL Recruiting Dan Lanning Evan Stewart College Football NIL

Ohio State Buckeyes wide receiver Jeremiah Smith (4) catches a pass in the first half of the NCAA football game at the Ohio Stadium on Saturday, Sept. 6, 2025 in Columbus, Ohio. / Samantha Madar/Columbus Dispatch / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

Ohio State wide receiver Jeremiah Smith had a breakout performance as a true freshman in 2024 and is believed to not only be the highest-paid wide receiver but also one of the highest-paid players in the sport.

MORE: Three Reasons Why Bucky Irving Could Catapult Tampa Bay Buccaneers

MORE: Oregon Ducks Battling SEC Program For Five-Star Wide Receiver Recruit Kesean Bowman

MORE: Oregon Ducks Predicted To Host First-Round College Football Playoff Game in Autzen Stadium

MORE: Oregon Ducks’ Dan Lanning Addresses Quarterback Austin Novosad Injury

MORE: Unsuspecting Oregon Ducks Linebacker Among Nation’s Best Defensive Grades

Smith is coming off a season with 76 receptions for 1,315 yards. With Moore in his true freshman season, his performance can lead to higher NIL earnings, especially if he has a similar performance to Smith.

Oregon Ducks Dakorien Moore Jeremiah Smith Ohio State Buckeyes NIL Recruiting Dan Lanning Evan Stewart College Football NIL

Oregon’s Dakorien Moore celebrates with Duck fans during the game against Oklahoma State. / Chris Pietsch/The Register-Guard / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

Moore was one of the most talked-about players on the team throughout the summer. In addition to being the No. 1 wide receiver recruit, the Oregon Ducks lost wide receiver Evan Stewart to a long-term injury. With Stewart missing an extended period of time, it has left room for Moore to be able to step up quickly with the Ducks.

In the first two weeks of the season, Moore already has five receptions for 95 yards and one touchdown. He has also had three carries for 42 yards and one touchdown. The team is only heading into week 3, and Moore is already making key plays for the Ducks.

One of the highlights of Moore this season does not have to do with any catches, but the way he is blocking players. Moore is playing unselfishly and doing what he can to help his team win.

Oregon Ducks Dakorien Moore Jeremiah Smith Ohio State Buckeyes NIL Recruiting Dan Lanning Evan Stewart College Football NIL

Oregon head coach Dan Lanning, right, talks with Oregon wide receiver Dakorien Moore during warmups as the Oregon Ducks host the Oklahoma State Cowboys on Sept. 6, 2025, at Autzen Stadium in Eugene, Oregon. / Ben Lonergan/The Register-Guard / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

“Not only is he electric with the ball in his hands, but he’s electric without the ball in his hands,” Oregon wideout Malik Benson said about Moore. “Now, once people see that on film, they’ll know he’s not just a pass-catching receiver. He can do it all. That’s a young guy doing that. If everyone’s doing that, then we’re going to be a scary group to go against.”

With Moore already estimated to be making $700,000, if he performs at a high level, he could become one of the highest NIL earners among wide receivers by his sophomore season.



Link

Continue Reading

NIL

Inside Villanova’s NIL Strategy Following the 2025 House Settlement – The Villanovan

Published

on


On July 1, 2025, the Villanova Athletic Department’s operations transformed, seemingly overnight.

Federal approval of the House v. NCAA settlement on June 8 legalized direct revenue sharing between universities and student-athletes. As a result, university athletic programs nationwide now have the ability to directly pay student athletes for their Name, Image and Likeness (NIL). At Villanova, the new Strategic Excellence Fund (VASE) will funnel donor contributions to programs and student-athletes.

University Vice President and Director of Athletics Eric Roedl spent the summer establishing his priorities in the wake of the House settlement and strategizing how to make the most of Villanova’s athletic revenue. While it is a concerning time for many coaches and players navigating the new system, Roedl sees a realm of new opportunity to build Villanova’s brand.

Roedl, who started at Villanova in January, had been preparing for the waves of change in the NCAA since he was in his previous role at the University of Oregon.

“There’s a lot more financial pressure on how we operate because of all the new permissible benefits that we can provide to student-athletes,” Roedl said in an interview with The Villanovan. “The challenge we have is that we’ve got a broad-based 24-sport program, and we don’t have unlimited resources, so we have to try to figure out what those levers are that we’re going to pull.”

The settlement’s impact extends beyond revenue sharing, as the NCAA no longer regulates athletic scholarships and instead limits roster sizes in specific sports. Most significantly, the settlement requires back-pay damages for former athletes who were unable to profit from NIL. According to the VASE website, Villanova will have a $500,000 per year reduction in NCAA revenues from 2016 to 2021. 

Since 2021, NIL opportunities for Villanova student-athletes stemmed from its external collective, Friends of Nova, managed by former basketball player Randy Foye and current assistant coach Ashley Howard. The organization will continue to work with the Athletic Department, while its role has evolved.

“Friends of Nova has done a great job with community engagement and personal development opportunities for our student-athletes, whether it’s financial literacy or leadership development,” Roedl said. “They’re really like an NIL maximization partner. They’re still involved with a lot of donor cultivation and relationships that we have, and trying to help raise money for the University.”

VASE, meanwhile, will primarily benefit Villanova’s highest-revenue programs: men’s and women’s basketball. 

The University determines how to distribute its resources based on which athletic programs generate the most revenue and how much funding is required to ensure that Villanova can remain competitive when it comes to recruiting and retaining talented players.

Many of Villanova’s competitors must now split up to $20.5 million — the NCAA’s cap on revenue sharing — between large football and basketball programs. But according to Roedl, the University is in a unique position in which its Division-I Football Championship Subdivision (FCS) program does not demand the same level of funding as FBS programs. This allows Villanova to channel more of its resources toward basketball.

“Football is going to be a really big priority for us,” Roedl said. “There are not a lot of programs out there that are committed to winning championships in basketball that are also supporting FCS-level football at a high level.”

While basketball tends to dominate Villanova’s campus culture around athletics, Roedl sees Villanova’s football program as a major area of growth in terms of marketing and community engagement. 

Bringing his experience from managing Oregon’s Big 10 football powerhouse, Roedl hopes to continue cultivating a game-day atmosphere that will galvanize students, alumni, and local fans alike. The Athletic Department’s efforts will surround the marketing and promotion of football games, in addition to improving the tailgate experience.

“I want students to wake up on a Saturday morning and know that [football] is a big part of what it means to be a Villanovan,” Roedl said. “We need to continue to do a better job of building excitement and energy around our football program.”

As Villanova competes with the most well-funded athletic programs in the country, Roedl is not concerned so much with falling behind as he is with getting ahead of the new demands that the House settlement places on top collegiate athletic departments.

“We’re going to be aggressive, proactive and bold with how we try to position our programs to be successful,” Roedl said. “You can see why Villanova is a national-caliber program that’s won national championships, because we’ve got great alignment here from the campus community.”



Link

Continue Reading

NIL

Top NIL Salaries of College Football Wide Receivers Unveiled

Published

on


The landscape of college football has transformed, particularly for wide receivers, with top earners securing impressive NIL salaries. At least five players command over $1 million, with Jeremiah Smith from Ohio State leading at $5-4 million. The compensation figures reflect earnings from schools or NIL collectives, excluding performance incentives. Notable mentions include Ryan Williams at Alabama with over $1.8 million and Carnell Tate at Ohio State with figures surpassing $1.5 million. This financial boom highlights the increasing importance of wide receivers in the evolving college football ecosystem.

By the Numbers

  • Jeremiah Smith, Ohio State: $5-4 million
  • Ryan Williams, Alabama: Over $1.8 million
  • Carnell Tate, Ohio State: Over $1.5 million
  • Four other top receivers are earning over $1 million each this fall.

State of Play

  • The NIL compensation levels are reshaping recruitment strategies and player decisions.
  • Wide receivers are now among the highest-paid positions in college football.
  • Schools and collectives are actively competing to attract top talents through lucrative offers.

What’s Next

The trend of rising NIL salaries is expected to continue, as colleges seek to leverage top talent for competitive advantage. We may see more strategic recruitments emphasizing NIL potential, influencing player transfers and commitments. As regulations around NIL evolve, this space could become even more lucrative for athletes.

Bottom Line

The surge in NIL salaries for wide receivers signifies a fundamental shift in college athletics. Players are beginning to reap substantial financial benefits, which not only impacts recruitment but also sets a new standard for compensation in college sports. The landscape is changing, and the financial stakes are higher than ever.





Link

Continue Reading

NIL

FSU star Micahi Danzy signs NIL deal with Adidas

Published

on


Florida State Seminole star Micahi Danzy has signed an NIL deal with Adidas running. The Tallahassee native stars for the track program and football program, where he plays wide receiver. The deal is focused on his track career.

Danzy had a phenomenal freshman season on the track, winning the 400-meter dash at the ACC Championships with a time of 44.38, setting the FSU record, meet record, and conference record. He made the 2025 Outdoor All-ACC 1st Team and was set to compete for a national championship before an injury ended his season.

While the track season forced him to miss parts of pre-season camp, he has been one of their top players through two games, despite transitioning from running back to wide receiver. He has run the ball four times for 109 yards and two touchdowns and caught two passes for 14 yards.

His speed makes him an excellent fit for Gus Malzahn’s offense, which loves to use fast wide receivers in a variety of ways to stretch the field and create explosive plays.

Follow us @FSUWire on X and like our page on Facebook to follow ongoing coverage of Florida State news, notes, and opinions.





Link

Continue Reading

Most Viewed Posts

Trending