Connect with us

NIL

Some ‘what if’ scenarios for Michigan Football that could’ve changed everything

The Michigan football program has had its fair share of success the last few years. Even after a down season in 2024, it’s hard to argue against Michigan being one of (if not the) best programs in the sport over the last handful of years. Still, despite the success the Wolverines have had, there are […]

Published

on


The Michigan football program has had its fair share of success the last few years. Even after a down season in 2024, it’s hard to argue against Michigan being one of (if not the) best programs in the sport over the last handful of years.

Still, despite the success the Wolverines have had, there are plenty of places where things could have gone differently. As fans know, football can be a complicated sport where the mere bounce of the ball in a game can reshape the course of an entire season.

Last week, we took a look back through the recent history of Michigan’s men’s basketball program to see where things could have gone differently, and today we’ll be doing the same for the football program.

What if J.T. Barrett wasn’t given the first down in 2016?

The scene is Columbus, Ohio, Nov. 26, 2016. Up 27-24 in overtime, Michigan needed a stop on fourth-and-one to beat Ohio State for the first time since 2011. On the play, Ohio State quarterback J.T. Barrett was stopped right at the marker, and upon replay review, was given a first down. The Buckeyes scored a touchdown just one play later and won the game 30-27.

There’s no sense debating the call by the officials at this point, but how would history be different had it gone the other way? For starters, Michigan would have won, finished the season 11-1 overall and booked a trip to the Big Ten Championship to face Wisconsin. We can’t assume the Wolverines would have won, but they did beat the Badgers, 14-7, at the Big House earlier that year.

We can’t say for sure how things would have gone, but at the very least, Jim Harbaugh might have received less flak for being unable to beat the Buckeyes.

What if Michigan lost to Rutgers in 2020?

This will act as an interlude to our next scenario, but fans were likely sweating out the 48-42 overtime victory over Rutgers in 2020, something that could have been a big turning point for the program.

If the Wolverines had lost that game, their record would have fallen to 1-4 and the chances of Harbaugh making out of the season with a job seemed slim. Even by winning the game, he did little to convince fans he deserved to stick around. Nonetheless, Michigan held onto Harbaugh, but it’s fair to wonder how things might be different if it didn’t.

What if Jim Harbaugh left after 2020?

Any way you slice it, the 2020 season was a disaster. The Wolverines went 2-4 and looked uncompetitive in most games. At the time, the criticism of Harbaugh was at its peak. Another part of the equation was Harbaugh didn’t have a long-term contract to keep him in Ann Arbor beyond 2021, only fueling speculation he would soon be out the door.

Instead, Harbaugh signed a contract with a reduced salary, reflective of the underachievement to that point. His return would ultimately spur Michigan on to its major run of success from 2021-23. But how might things have transpired if he did leave?

Well, fans spent the fall and winter of 2020 sorting through potential head coaching candidates. From Luke Fickell to Matt Campbell, fans were envisioning a new future that probably wouldn’t have been so bright. Needless to say, Michigan made the right call in bringing Harbaugh back, as Fickell has underperformed — 13-13 in two seasons at Wisconsin — while Campbell has gone 29-23 at Iowa State since 2020.

What if literally anything went differently in the Fiesta Bowl?

For the truly masochistic fans, I urge you to go back and watch the highlights from Michigan’s loss to TCU in the College Football Playoff. You’ll find countless places where the tide of the game could have turned.

What if Donovan Edwards didn’t get chased down on the first play of the game? What if J.J. McCarthy didn’t throw two pick-sixes? What if Roman Wilson was given a touchdown instead of being ruled down right before the goal line? And what if Kalel Mullings didn’t fumble after that replay review of Wilson’s overturned touchdown? What if anybody could make a tackle on defense? We could go on and on.

The loss marked one of the bigger upsets in the four-team era of the CFP. If the Wolverines had won the game like many experts had predicted them to, they would’ve faced Georgia in the National Championship.

While Michigan might have been a better matchup for Georgia than TCU — it lost to Georgia 65-7 — I still wouldn’t have bet on Michigan to win. While a victory in the Fiesta Bowl would have been great, it probably wouldn’t have given the Wolverines all that much better a shot at winning the National Championship.

What if literally anything went differently in the Rose Bowl?

If the Fiesta Bowl featured many unfortunate events for Michigan, the Rose Bowl featured some favorable ones. What if McCarthy had been intercepted on the first play, or didn’t catch the pass from Edwards on the trick play? What if Michigan hadn’t flawlessly executed it’s legendary fourth-quarter drive? What if Jake Thaw let the ball bounce into the end zone?

As you can see, perhaps the most memorable win from the last five years might not have happened at all. Had the ball not bounced in Michigan’s favor in this game, the program would have been looking at a third straight semifinal exit, and the legacies of Harbaugh and many legendary players like McCarthy, Blake Corum, Mike Sainristil and others would look much different without a national championship on their resumes.

It’s fair to wonder if Harbaugh or any of his players would have opted to try and run it back in 2024 for another shot at a title, but I’ll settle for winning it all in 2023.

What if Michigan didn’t upset Ohio State in 2024?

I guess we’ll never know…



Link

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

NIL

Athlon Sports ranks Top 10 LB units in college football for 2025

The 2025 college football season is still roughly two months away from offically kicking off, but that leaves plenty of time for Ranking Season to continue. And Athlon Sports more than provided with its 2025 preseason college football preview magazine. As part of its annual preseason preview, Athlon Sports identified the Top 10 positional groupings […]

Published

on


The 2025 college football season is still roughly two months away from offically kicking off, but that leaves plenty of time for Ranking Season to continue. And Athlon Sports more than provided with its 2025 preseason college football preview magazine.

As part of its annual preseason preview, Athlon Sports identified the Top 10 positional groupings entering the 2025 regular season, including the Top 10 linebacker units. To little surprise, the SEC leads the way with four of Athlon’s Top 10 linebacker rooms, including the Top 2 overall units. The Big Ten was also well-represented with three teams in the Top 10, including the last two College Football Playoff national champions.

Reigning national runner-up Notre Dame also managed to crack Athlon’s Top 5, while the ACC earned a pair of Top 10 spots. Check out Athlon Sports’ full Top 10 list of best linebacker units below:

CLICK HERE to buy Athlon’s 2025 magazine online.

Projected starters: MLB Jaishawn Barham, WLB Ernest Hausmann, EDGEs TJ Guy, Derrick Moore

The Wolverines return a particularly experienced group in the heart of its defense, including starting linebackers in Barham (66 tackles) and Hausmann (team-high 89 tackles, both of whom started all 13 games last season. Michigan also returns veteran pass rushers in Moore (4 sacks, 6 TFL) and Guy (5.5 sacks, 7 TFL), who combined for 9.5 sacks and 13 TFL in 2024.

Linebackers Harold Perkins and Whit Weeks
Whit Weeks | Maria Lysaker-Imagn Images

Projected starters: MLB Whit Weeks, WLB Harold Perkins

The heart of the Tigers’ defense rests with Perkins and Weeks in 2025. Perkins, a former 5-star recruit in 2022, has had his once-promising collegiate career derailed by injuries, including being limited to just four games in 2024. Meanwhile, Weeks has emerged as one of the SEC’s top tacklers after finishing second in the league with 125 total tackles in 2024, including 10 for loss.

Projected starters: MAC Bryce Boettcher, MONEY Devon Jackson, JACK Teitum Tuioti

Much likes others on this list, the Ducks return all three of their projected starters from last season, including 13-game starting ‘backers Boettcher and Tuiioti. Boettcher, a two-sport star and former walk-on to the football team, led Oregon with 94 total tackles in 2024, while Tuitoti added 58 tackles and 5.5 sacks. Jackson started one game in 2024 and will replace Kansas City Chiefs draft pick Jeffery Bassa.

Projected starters: WLB Rasheem Biles, STAR Kyle Louis, MLB Braylan Lovelace

Louis returns after receiving All-American honors and a first-team All-ACC selection after racking up 101 total tackles, including a team-high 15.5 TFL and 7 sacks, while making 13 starts in 2024. Biles wasn’t far behind him with 82 tackles, 14.5 for loss, and 5.5 sacks across 8 starts last season, while Lovelace appears in line to replace Brandon George as the Panthers’ starting middle linebacker in 2025.

Alabama LB Deontae Lawson
Deontae Lawson | Photo courtesy of UA Athletics

Projected starters: MLB Justin Jefferson, STING Deontae Lawson, WOLF Qua Russaw

Lawson and Jefferson both opted to return for their fifth season, giving the Crimson Tide one of the SEC’s most experienced LB units. Lawson (76 total tackles, 6.5 TFL) is back after suffering a season-ending injury against Oklahoma, while Jefferson (60 tackles, 6.5 TFL) earned a NCAA waiver following Vanderbilt QB Diego Pavia‘s court win last year. Russaw becomes a full-time starter after tallying 36 tackles in limited role as a true freshamn.

Projected starters: MLB Wade Woodaz, WLB Sammy Brown

While they might not have the star power of their peers in the trenches, Brown and Woodaz are arguably the true heart of the Clemson defense after combining on 163 total tackles in 2024. Woodaz started 13 games last season and led the team with 83 stops, while Brown won ACC Defensive Rookie of the Year after ranking second to superstar DE T.J. Parker with 11.5 TFL, 5 sacks and 80 tackles last season.

Projected starters: ROVER Jaiden Ausberry, MLB Drayk Bowen, WLB Jaylen Sneed

The Fighting Irish lost leading tackler Jack Kiser to the NFL, but still returns serious talent in the middle of its defense, including rising juniors Bowen (78 total tackles, 3 forced fumbles) and Sneed (51 tackles). But arguably the most impactful returner is Ausberry, who splashed as sophomore with 58 total tackles, 6.5 TFL, and two QB hurries despite just two starts in 2024.

Sonny Styles-Ohio State-Ohio State football-Buckeyes
Sonny Styles | Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images

Projected starters: EDGE Beau Atkinson, WLB Sonny Styles, MLB Arvell Reese

Despite significant turnover within the Buckeyes’ championship defense, including losing leading tackler Cody Simon, Ohio State still features plenty of talent and experience at LB. Styles has started 28 straight games and ranked second on the team with 100 total tackles last season, while Reese will replace Simon after making two starts in 2024. Atkinson transferred in from North Carolina after racking up 7.5 sacks, 5 QB hurries, 12 TFL and 35 tackles last season.

Projected starters: MONEY CJ Allen, JACK Elo Modozie, MAC Raylen Wilson

While the Bulldogs’ 2024 defense took its share of lumps, the heart of the unit more than held its own last season. Led by Allen (76 total tackles, 5 QB hurries, 4 PBUs) and Wilson (47 tackles, 7 TFL) in the middle, Georgia’s linebackers made plays all over the field. After losing some of its best pass rushers off last season’s squad, the Bulldogs added 6-foot-3, 245-pound EDGE Modozie (6.5 sacks, 8 TFL) from Army out of the transfer portal.

Projected starters: MLB Anthony Hill Jr., WLB Trey Moore, BUCK Colin Simmons

Given the sheer wealth of returning talent, it’s no surprise the Longhorns would have college football’s top-ranked LB room. After opting to forgo the NFL, the senior Hill comes back as arguably the best individual linebacker in college football after racking up 113 total tackles and a SEC-leading 16.5 TFL in 2024. Simmons added a team-high nine sacks and 14 TFL despite not starting a single game as a true freshman. That’ll change in 2025. On the other side, Moore has made 15 consecutive starts after adding 5.5 sacks and 9.5 TFL last season.



Link

Continue Reading

NIL

Grok predicts college football’s 12 playoff teams based on new seeding model

A big change is coming to the College Football Playoff with a new seeding model ready to debut this season, as the committee will forgo the distinction between rankings and seedings, and simply award the 12 highest-ranked teams a place in the postseason field. “After evaluating the first year of the 12-team playoff, the CFP […]

Published

on


A big change is coming to the College Football Playoff with a new seeding model ready to debut this season, as the committee will forgo the distinction between rankings and seedings, and simply award the 12 highest-ranked teams a place in the postseason field.

“After evaluating the first year of the 12-team playoff, the CFP Management Committee felt it was in the best interest of the game to make this adjustment,” College Football Playoff executive director Rich Clark said.

“This change will continue to allow guaranteed access to the playoff by rewarding teams for winning their conference championship, but it will also allow us to construct a postseason bracket that recognizes the best performance on the field during the entire regular season.”

What can we expect in what should be another historic College Football Playoff field? For that, we turned to Grok to get a preview of who will be seeded where.

1. Ohio State





Link

Continue Reading

NIL

Kentucky baseball facing a recruiting rankings reality check with stunning SEC numbers

Kentucky baseball has a Top 10 transfer class — and still just 7th in the SEC If you needed another reminder of how brutal life in the SEC is, Kentucky baseball just gave you one: the Wildcats landed the 7th-best transfer portal class in the country, per 64Analytics — and still rank only 7th in […]

Published

on


Kentucky baseball has a Top 10 transfer class — and still just 7th in the SEC

If you needed another reminder of how brutal life in the SEC is, Kentucky baseball just gave you one: the Wildcats landed the 7th-best transfer portal class in the country, per 64Analytics — and still rank only 7th in the conference.

Kentucky baseball

University of Kentucky players wave between innings playing Clemson during the bottom of the fourth inning at the NCAA baseball Clemson Regional at Doug Kingsmore Stadium in Clemson, S.C. Sunday, June 1, 2025. | Ken Ruinard / staff / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

That’s not an indictment of Kentucky. That’s a reflection of how loaded the SEC remains, fresh off LSU sweeping the College World Series and the league sending a record number of teams to the NCAA Tournament.

Here’s how the SEC dominates the national transfer rankings:

1. Mississippi State
2. Tennessee
3. Georgia
4. Texas
5. South Carolina
6. Auburn
7. Kentucky
8. Alabama

Nick Mingione’s squad might not have the flashiest class, but it’s deep, balanced, and built for postseason baseball. Kentucky reloaded the pitching staff with Kaden Echeman (Northern Kentucky), Burkley Bounds (Eastern Kentucky), Jack Bennett (Western Kentucky), Ryan Mullan (Loyola Marymount), and Bryson Treichel (North Florida). That’s five arms with college experience and toughness.

Jackson Soucie joins from South Carolina to bolster the left side. In the infield, Tyler Cerny (Indiana) and Connor Mattison (Grand Canyon) bring versatility. Alex Duffey (Elon) adds pop behind the plate, while Scott Campbell (USC Upstate) is a name to know in the outfield.

On the freshman front, Kentucky’s class is ranked 24th nationally, headlined by Owen Jenkins, a top-30 national prospect and a big-time catcher out of Lexington Catholic. Add in pitching depth with righties Joshua Flores, Lucas Hall, and Jacks Sams, plus lefties like Will Coleman and Toby Peterson, and the foundation is set.

Let’s not forget — the Bat ‘Cats reached a Regional Final last season, coughing up two separate five-run leads in a gutting elimination loss. That stung. But with this infusion of talent, the goal is clear: win those close games in 2025 and make a deeper postseason run.

In the SEC, standing still means falling behind. But Kentucky isn’t standing still. They’re building a roster that can go toe-to-toe with anyone.



Link

Continue Reading

NIL

What Matt Ponatoski Can Do for Kentucky Baseball

To steal a line from Freddie Maggard, “Play ’em all!” You probably know him as an exceptional KSR Football Podcast host who spent a couple of years starting under center at Commonwealth Stadium. What you probably didn’t know is that Freddie nearly skipped college to play Major League Baseball. Scouts filled the Cumberland stands when […]

Published

on


To steal a line from Freddie Maggard, “Play ’em all!” You probably know him as an exceptional KSR Football Podcast host who spent a couple of years starting under center at Commonwealth Stadium. What you probably didn’t know is that Freddie nearly skipped college to play Major League Baseball. Scouts filled the Cumberland stands when he threw a no-hitter and hit three home runs. Matt Ponatoski is the modern day Maggard, but better (no offense, Freddie).

We’ve spent plenty of time dissecting what Ponatoski can bring to the Kentucky football team, but what exactly could he do for Nick Mingione’s baseball program?

Playing two sports at the Power Conference level is a challenge rarely accepted. Austin Simmons spent one year on the diamond at Ole Miss before focusing all of his attention on learning the quarterback position for Lane Kiffin. The merits of this undertaking will be discussed thoroughly in the coming months and years. We can save that for another day.

Professional baseball scouts have eyed Ponatoski for years. As you might suspect, the quarterback is also a pretty good pitcher who can throw it up to 97 mph. He can also swing the bat. According to the Cincinnati Enquirer, Ponatoski hit .462 as a junior with seven doubles, four home runs, 37 RBIs, and a .556 on-base percentage. 

Following his junior season, Ponatoski was the Ohio Gatorade Player of the Year in football and baseball. He was a Second Team All-American selection as a shortstop, the position he’s projected to play at the next level.

Prep Baseball Report ranks Ponatoski as the No. 14 recruit in the 2026 class. Ohio Scouting Director Kyle Weldon shared with Bat Cats Central’s Derek Terry what makes him such a special prospect.

“Matt has elite arm strength,” Weldon said. “He has a plus hit tool with the potential to be a plus power guy eventually. He’s a winner profile, which has been seen on the football field too. This is a guy that’s highly competitive, highly skilled and has a lot of natural talent. When you combine all those things, it makes him a really sought-after prospect.”

Today was a big win for Mark Stoops and Nick Mingione. The talented athlete made the short drive from Cincinnati to Lexington often, but actually used his official visit for baseball. Before the baseball vs. football debate begins, Ponatoski made it clear to Jacob Polacheck that he wants to play ’em all.

“I’m going to try and do both for as long as possible,” he said. “The goal for me is to be drafted in both [sports]. It sounds crazy, but Kyler Murray did it not too long ago.”

In a conversation with reporters following his decision, he added, “I think people might think it might be too much, but it’s what I signed up for and I’m ready to go.”

Subscribe to the KSR YouTube Channel for press conferences, interviews, original shows, fan features, and exclusive content.



Link

Continue Reading

NIL

Urban Meyer makes it clear where he stands on returning to college football

One of the significant shifts of the NIL and transfer portal era, some college football programs have turned to general manager roles to help lead the way in roster management. Programs have hired from within the assistant ranks while others have plucked former head coaches and NFL executives. Most recently, Ron Rivera, a two-time NFL […]

Published

on


One of the significant shifts of the NIL and transfer portal era, some college football programs have turned to general manager roles to help lead the way in roster management.

Programs have hired from within the assistant ranks while others have plucked former head coaches and NFL executives.

Most recently, Ron Rivera, a two-time NFL Head Coach of the Year, is back at his alma mater Cal as general manager. And Oklahoma hired former NFL executive Jim Nagy to the same position.

Three-time national champion head coach Urban Meyer, now with Fox Sports as an analyst, admitted he was approached by a college program for their general manager role. The former Utah, Florida, Ohio State and Jacksonville Jaguars head coach even met with leadership to hear the program’s pitch.

“I had a school come see me this year and ask if I wanted to be the GM,” Meyer said on “The Triple Option.” “And a couple other phone calls. And you start to think, ‘OK, they actually came to see me,’ so I said, ‘Yeah, I’ll meet and I’ll sit down with you guys.’”

Despite Meyer’s early interest, he wasn’t inclined to take the offer after learning about the job description. In fact, Meyer would rather “step on a rusty nail” than dealing with players’ agents.

“I said, ‘OK, what is the job description?.’ “They said, ‘Well, basically you meet with all the agents of the 17-, 18-year-olds,’” Meyer said. “And I thought, ‘I’d rather step on a rusty nail and pull it out myself.’”

Meyer’s name is regularly mentioned when major head coaching roles open, and it wouldn’t be a big shock to see the 60-year-old return to college football at some point. As a general manager, though, it’s safe to say Meyer won’t be taking up that title.



Link

Continue Reading

NIL

Dual-Sport Star Matt Ponatoski Commits to Kentucky

Not all recruiting wins are created equally. This time, it’s not just a win for Mark Stoops, but for Nick Mingione. Matt Ponatoski has committed to Kentucky. “I’ll be committing to the University of Kentucky to play baseball and football,” Ponatoski tells KSR+. “Big Blue Nation, I’m ready to work. I’m coming not to change […]

Published

on


Not all recruiting wins are created equally. This time, it’s not just a win for Mark Stoops, but for Nick Mingione. Matt Ponatoski has committed to Kentucky.

“I’ll be committing to the University of Kentucky to play baseball and football,” Ponatoski tells KSR+. “Big Blue Nation, I’m ready to work. I’m coming not to change the program, but we’re going to put the program on the map.”

The Cincinnati Moeller athlete is an expert at throwing balls. He was tabbed as the most accurate quarterback in the country during last week’s Elite 11 camp. He’s also an All-American shortstop, ranked as one of the Top 20 baseball recruits in the country.

Mark Stoops secured a commitment from Ponatoski without actually hosting him for an official visit. Nick Mingione hosted him on behalf of the Bat Cats this spring. That’s right around the time his football recruitment really blew up. Alabama and Oregon entered the picture, and each school was able to get him on campus. Prior to his trip out west for the Elite 11 and his Oregon OV, he made a crucial pitstop in Lexington. That trip to meet with Bush Hamdan and the rest of the offense set the wheels in motion for this historic commitment.

Ponatoski is the most prolific quarterback recruit to commit to Kentucky since Tim Couch. He’s the ninth-ranked quarterback in the country and No. 100 overall player, according to On3. That ranking is going to soar once all of the recruiting services complete their next round of updates.

Often considered a baseball-first prospect, he might not have even been ranked when he camped at Kentucky last summer. Then he went out and dominated the most competitive division in Ohio high school football.

Ponatoski threw for 4,200 yards, 58 touchdowns, and only three interceptions in the Greater Catholic League. He was often the best player on the field in front of sold-out crowds. The College GameDay crew was in the stands when Ponatoski outdueled St. X’s Chase Herbstreit in a 45-37 playoff shootout. In the semifinals the following week, Ponatoski had 431 yards and six touchdowns in the first half. Moeller ultimately fell short in the Ohio Division I State Championship Game, a 28-14 loss to Olentangy Liberty.

In 2024, Ponatoski was Ohio Mr. Football. He earned Ohio Gatorade Player of the Year honors in both baseball and football.

What People Say About Ponatoski’s Game

The Elite 11 Camp earlier this month put Ponatoski on center stage in front of noteworthy talent evaluators and reporters around college football. Even though he did not win the event, it was clear that he was one of the best players on the field.

“Ponatoski looked like the most accurate Elite 11 Finalist throughout the week,” On3’s Director of Scouting Charles Power wrote. “The Cincinnati native was a smooth operator each day. He made drill work look easy, consistently delivering well-placed, catchable passes. Ponatoski carried that into Day 2, turning in one of the more impressive pro day showings while earning the highest score from the Elite 11 staff. The capped the week off with a solid showing in 7-on-7 that saw him throw three touchdowns. A dual sport star who doubles as a top baseball prospect, Ponatoski is an accurate, rhythm passer with natural timing and feel.

The Athletic’s Bruce Feldman has been covering the event for more than 20 years, and this year’s group was one of the most talented he’s ever seen.

“The most pleasant surprise to me was Ohio’s Matt Ponatoski, ranked as the No. 29 QB by 247Sports. The two-sport star has an electric arm, having been clocked at 97 mph as a pitcher. That arm wowed me Thursday morning in his 7-on-7 performance. The 6-1, 196-pounder, who is uncommitted, made two ‘wow’ throws to receivers who didn’t look open at all, but he fired the ball into the only spot he could and completed the passes. It was impressive.”

Justin Hoover, one of the coaches at the event, told Feldman, “He had a couple of those every day we were here. He’s got some confidence to put it in places that others wouldn’t even attempt to throw. He really stood out.”

Want more Kentucky football recruiting intel? Join KSR Plus for the most comprehensive coverage of the Cats on the internet. With a KSR membership, you get access to bonus content and KSBoard, KSR’s message board, to chat with fellow Cats fans and get exclusive scoop.



Link

Continue Reading

Most Viewed Posts

Trending