The Sheldon High School esports team passed another level to end the 2024-25 season.
It’s only the third year of the program, and Sheldon already had qualified for two Iowa High School Esports Association state events — “Rocket League” in winter of 2023-24 and “Super Smash Bros. Ultimate” in the fall.
But Sheldon still was looking for a top-three finish at state going into the spring season for “Mario Kart 8 Deluxe.”
After losing the season opener, Sheldon went on a winning streak that stretched all the way to the IAHSEA Spring Finals on May 21 in Marshalltown, including a spot in the championship against Estherville Lincoln Central.
While the winning streak came to an end as Sheldon lost, the runner-up finish in “Mario Kart 8 Deluxe” is the highest in the program’s history.
“The guys were bummed that they lost the finals but were still in great spirits on the way home,” said Sheldon esports coach Toby Maggert. “We set the goal to come home with some hardware, and we met that goal. This is the highest a team sport has placed at state at Sheldon in a long time, and they are carrying that with pride.”
“Mario Kart 8 Deluxe” is played on the Nintendo Switch and Sheldon had 13 players out for the spring season. Four players make up the varsity roster and four more are allowed for substitutes. Juniors Dawsin Merley and Ethan Vogelaar, sophomore Weston Smith and freshman Aaron Verburg made up Sheldon’s varsity “Mario Kart” roster.
The games are four versus four with all players scoring. In an eight-player race, points are awarded from first- to eighth-place. Ten points are awarded for first place, eight for second, six for third, five for fourth, four for fifth, three for sixth, two for seventh and one for eighth.
Teams play a best out of three cups and each cup is a series of four races. Whichever team has the most points at the end wins the cup.
All races are on courses of 150cc, the fastest courses, with normal rules for racing. Each player chooses their own kart combo, which consists of a character, the kart, the wheels and the glider. There are more than 8,000 combos to build from.
“The online community did the math and determined the best few combos, so you see the same five combos a lot,” Maggert said.
The start of the season got off on the wrong foot for Sheldon, which lost to Westwood 101-55 and 83-73.
Maggert said the team had a “double disadvantage” going into the match.
“First, we had connection issues and could only get three players to race online, so we were racing three versus four in the first six races,” he said. “We also had our team-voted MVP gone that day, so we were already handicapped in personnel. The last two races our tech guy figured out the issue, and we were able to have four guys, in and you can see the score was closer in that second game.
“It just goes to show that even at a handicap, our team was able to compete against another team that made it to state and won a match there as well.”
Sheldon bounced back with a 109-47 and 110-46 win over River Valley in the second week, which started a nine-match winning streak. For the rest of the regular season matches, only two cups were within 20 points of Sheldon’s total.
Sheldon earned the sixth seed in the postseason and faced WACO of Wayland in the state qualifier.
“We were the sixth seed, which I felt made us a bit of a sleeper team,” Maggert said. “I knew our only loss was at a huge disadvantage, so if not for that, we would have been a higher seed.”
Sheldon dominated WACO, winning 100-56 and 97-56 to advance to Marshalltown.
The Orabs almost did not make it out of the first round at state though. They faced third-seeded West Fork of Sheffield and trailed throughout the first cup before making a major comeback to force a 78-78 tie. Sheldon won the second cup 88-68 but lost the third cup 82-74.
“Since it is a best of three, we had to go back and replay the first cup again and that time we won 83-73,” Maggert said.
Sheldon faced second-seeded Woodward in the semifinals and won the first cup 82-74. It dropped the second cup 87-69 but pulled out an 84-72 victory to get to the championship match.
“Going into the last race, we were down by one but managed to take first and second place, which was enough points to lock up the victory,” Maggert said. “Honestly, we were underdogs all day. We hands down had the hardest competition of the day, and all of those teams came into the tournament undefeated.
“Our first match win had the guys almost relieved to know they had what it takes to compete at state, and after the second-round victory, they were on cloud nine.”
That set up the match against top-seed Estherville Lincoln Central and Sheldon won the first cup. It was the first cup loss of the entire year for ELC.
“You could see in their faces that they had just considered for the first time that they might not win,” Maggert said. “After that, ELC came back strong and focused and raced two great cups. The last cup was even one of the sets we had gotten lots of practice on so I was hopeful we could take the win, but it wasn’t meant to be.”
Estherville Lincoln Central took the next two cups to win the title with Sheldon in second place.
For Maggert, the runner-up in “Mario Kart” was a fitting end to a strong year of esports at Sheldon.
“We qualified for state in ‘Smash Bros.’ and had a winning record in all of our seasons,” he said. “We did not make state for ‘Rocket League’ but still walked off with a positive record. Ending the ‘Mario Kart’ season at 9-2 is awesome, and our only losses were to a state qualifier and state champ.
“I am putting a big W for this year for the esports team.”
This kind of season can vault a program forward. It’s still a young program at Sheldon, and Maggert continues to encourage his players to spread the word about esports.
“We take a group of kids that typically game for fun and teach them about structured and rigorous practice, how to research skills to self-improve, communicate effectively with peers in times of stress and build a positive environment in a context that kids are usually left to themselves,” he said. “I have seen tremendous personal and competitive growth from my students, and I would love to have even more students get that experience.”
Sheldon should be poised for another successful esports year in 2025-26 since it did not graduate any starters.
“On our varsity lineup, we didn’t have any seniors starting in ‘Smash Bros.’ or ‘Mario Kart,’ so we are bringing back a lot of talent,” Maggert said. “I am looking forward to seeing how they improve over the summer and are ready to keep climbing the ladder. They are all motivated to have at least as much success next year, and I believe they can do it.”