ORLANDO, Fla — As if there was any more confirmation needed that Kyle Tucker wouldn’t be returning to the Chicago Cubs, manager Craig Counsell only reinforced the idea. When talking to members of the media Tuesday afternoon at the Signia by Hilton in Orlando, Counsell sure sounded like someone prepared to manage a team that didn’t include Tucker.
“From a position player standpoint, the loss right now is Tucker obviously,” Counsell said. “The rest of the group is back and likely with us.”
This shouldn’t come as a surprise to anyone paying attention. Tucker is expected to get the largest contract of the offseason. While multiple teams have been linked to the star right fielder, there has been nary a mention of the Cubs. Perhaps if the unexpected happens and Tucker’s market lingers into February, the Cubs will entertain a short-term deal should Tucker be willing. That seems unlikely at the moment.
Whether it’s the right move or not is a separate discussion, but it has been clear for a while now that Tucker would find the big-money contract he’s seeking elsewhere.
The front office has been clear that upgrading the pitching staff would be the priority. Both the bullpen and rotation are areas where the Cubs will look to improve, but even if it’s not at the top of the to-do list, adding a more established bat to the roster to make up for losing Tucker can’t be ruled out.
“You’re just trying to fortify the roster as a whole,” Counsell said. “You can think about it in different ways. But I think more depth from a position player standpoint would be helpful, absolutely. I do think we were extremely healthy there last year, so more depth there is important.”
Team president Jed Hoyer has said he’d prefer not to have young players sitting on the bench, so depth can’t come at the expense of player development. Counsell doesn’t seem to be pounding the table to add an established bat to the mix, not publicly at least. Building a better bench than last season seems important to everyone in the organization, but adding no-doubt offensive production won’t be forced.
That doesn’t mean it won’t happen, but Counsell seems intrigued by the idea of getting more playing time for young players, in particular Moisés Ballesteros and Owen Caissie.
Seiya Suzuki’s recent performance has made him one of the players the Cubs could lean on to help fill Tucker’s shoes. (Michael Reaves / Getty Images)
“We have young players that did contribute in a big way,” Counsell said. “I thought Moisés gave us the offensive production of Tucker essentially in the month of September. Between him and Owen, who was unfortunately hurt for most of that month, those are two important players as we sit right now.”
Ballesteros ended the season with a 143 wRC+ in 66 plate appearances. All but 20 of those came in September when he posted a 177 wRC+ and delivered four of his five extra-base hits on the season. Ballesteros got that playing time after Caissie went down with a concussion and Tucker was on the shelf with a calf injury that cost him most of September. The young DH/catcher parlayed that performance into a spot on the playoff roster.
“He’s at the point where if he can help the major-league team, he’s going to be in the major leagues,” Counsell said. “There’s not an everyday catching job in the major leagues for him. But as we’re constructed right now, we’ve got room for at-bats, so I would prioritize the major leagues right now. But that could change with roster stuff.”
Ballesteros’ September looked remarkably similar to what he’s shown for much of his minor-league career: a high-contact bat who can take walks and can hit the ball hard to all parts of the field with legitimate extra-base pop. Caissie didn’t get an extended opportunity to show what he can do, but that could change in 2026. He brings elite power to the table but also plenty of swing-and-miss concerns.
Counsell was also very complimentary of Seiya Suzuki, who had an offensive power breakout in the first half before hitting an extended slump that ended just in time for a brilliant postseason. The veteran had a career-high 32 homers and .233 ISO, then hit three home runs and three doubles in eight playoff games.
“I’m really happy for Seiya with how he performed in the playoffs,” Counsell said. “He was a very dangerous hitter and showed what he can do and the impact he could have.”
Due to Tucker’s injury, Suzuki was able to get a decent amount of playing time in right field down the stretch, something Counsell said Suzuki “did a really good job” handling. This, after a 2024 where Suzuki seemed to lose his confidence in the field and eventually his job there to Cody Bellinger and, of course, Tucker this past summer.
Even if there isn’t an impactful, established bat added to this roster, Counsell sees a pathway to a strong offense, but there’s an obvious risk. Michael Busch’s breakout has to be real. It felt as much considering that, like Suzuki, he dominated in the postseason and truly built upon a solid first season with Chicago in 2024.
Pair that with Suzuki, the continued development of young players like Matt Shaw and Pete Crow-Armstrong, along with less-established kids in Ballesteros and Caissie, and there is hope that the group can be dynamic even without Tucker.
“It’s a tough league,” Counsell said. “Even the veteran players can struggle. You see in giving young players opportunities, they’re the guys that are going to improve as the season goes and turn into better players. Then turn into very important players on your club.”
There could still be an addition that moves the needle on offense, but the Cubs also seem prepared to go with a youth movement if the right acquisition doesn’t come along. Counsell understands that with youth, the production may not happen immediately. However, after watching these things happen in Milwaukee and across the league with various other strong organizations, he trusts that patience with the kids will pay off.
“You have to be patient with those opportunities,” he said. “You have to create the opportunities for players of that caliber.”
