Connect with us

NIL

What is your most unpopular opinion on college athletics?

From now until preseason camp starts in August, Land-Grant Holy Land will be writing articles around a different theme every week. This week is all about unpopular opinions. You can catch up on all of the Theme Week content here and all our “Unpopular Opinion” articles here. We all have some opinions that make people […]

Published

on


From now until preseason camp starts in August, Land-Grant Holy Land will be writing articles around a different theme every week. This week is all about unpopular opinions. You can catch up on all of the Theme Week content here and all our “Unpopular Opinion” articles here.


We all have some opinions that make people raise an eyebrow. It could be about sports, entertainment, or politics. Since you came to an Ohio State sports website, luckily you won’t have to deal with any opinions on politics. Instead, we are going to reveal our most unpopular opinions on college athletics. When we say unpopular, we don’t mean hurtful; more so, we mean opinions that are a bit unconventional.

When it comes to college athletics, there are plenty of areas to dive into. NIL, the Transfer Portal, how many teams should be included in the College Football Playoff/NCAA Tournament, and rules of the game and how they are interpreted are just the tip of the iceberg of areas that grind the gears of some people. Today, we don’t really need solutions to your unpopular opinions, since in many cases those fixes can be very complicated, we just want to know some things about college athletics that may be popular with others that have gotten under your skin.

Today’s question: What is your most unpopular opinion on college athletics?

We’d love to hear your choices. Either respond to us on Twitter at @Landgrant33 or leave your choice in the comments.


Brett’s answer: The Transfer Portal

Just to be clear, I’m not saying that I don’t think college athletes should be able to transfer. Having to wait a year to play after transferring was a bit ridiculous, especially when college coaches could move to another coaching position and not have to wait to coach. I don’t think that the transfer portal is currently utilized is what those in charge had in mind when they made it easier for student-athletes to transfer. Now you are seeing some college athletes transfer three or four times during their college career. At the very most, I think college athletes should be able to transfer twice during their college careers.

2025 CFP National Championship Presented by AT&T- Ohio State v Notre Dame

Photo by Todd Kirkland/Getty Images

I have no issues with what Will Howard did. He spent a lot of time at Kansas State and then came to Ohio State to close out his college career. I can’t say the same about Dillon Gabriel. After starting his career at UCF, he transferred to Oklahoma, followed by a spot at Oregon for the final season of his college career. It just seems odd to me that a college athlete can play for three different schools. I understand that he had a redshirt season due to an injury and a COVID year, but even with those, it’s hard to believe that things were so bad at times that he needed to transfer twice during his college career.

Things feel even worse when it comes to basketball. Usually, in the fall before the college basketball season begins, I need to take a crash course to remember who is playing where now. Then, just as soon as fans are getting used to having a player on their team, they have moved on to greener pastures. After transferring out of Auburn following the season, Chad Baker-Mazara is now playing for his fifth team, with four of them being at the Division I level.

That just seems crazy to me. As soon as you become comfortable with players, coaches, and a school, players are hitting the portal. At Ohio State, Aaron Bradshaw and Sean Stewart transferred to Columbus following their freshman season, and now both are elsewhere after spending one year with the Buckeyes.

I guess this is just how the world is these days. Our attention spans have become so short that it’s easy to see why college athletes are so quick to jump to a new school. Ohio State’s 2024 football season was so special because you had a bunch of players who were Buckeyes their whole college careers, finally getting to the top of the mountain after a number of close calls.

As the years go on, it feels like we’ll see less of that just because college athletes are constantly on the move these days, and there are no signs of it slowing down anytime soon.


Matt’s answer: College football should adopt relegation

On the Land-Grant Podcast Network this week, I spoke to The Athletic’s Editor in Chief for college football, Stewart Mandel. He ran me through some of the ridiculous proposals that the SEC and Big Ten commissioners are seemingly pushing for the next round of College Football Playoff tweaks.

While nothing has been decided, and Mandel notes that the seemingly disastrous proposals could just be a negotiating tactic (and a much more sane plan does appear to be gaining traction), but it got me thinking.

If the CFP were to go with a more robust automatic bid process, similar to what happens in the UEFA Champions League, where participants are determined solely by their finish in their respective home country leagues. In that case, college football should also adopt one of the aspects that makes European soccer so exciting: relegation.

Say, the B1G and SEC’s plan to expand the playoff to 14 teams goes through and the two power conferences get four autobids apiece, then two each for the ACC and Big 12, and the Group of 5 would get one. That would mean that conference rankings would determine the vast majority of playoff spots, rendering non-conference play irrelovent.

So, if the goal is to pick the best teams based on how they play in their league, then we should do everything possible to make sure that the play in those leagues is at the highest possible level.

For example, the Purdue Boilermakers finished 0-9 last season in B1G play. Due to that, they should be relegated to Big 12. They still have a chance at two AQ spots in the playoffs, but not the four afforded the Big Ten. Conversely, SMU went 8-0 in the ACC, so they would be bumped up to the SEC for this season, giving them an even better shot at a playoff berth, despite the stiffer competition.

This would also work at the lower levels. Army was 8-0 in the AAC last season, so the Black Knights would become members of the ACC for this season, and the 0-9 Oklahoma State Cowboys would be relegated out of the Big 12 and into Comferemce USA.

If the goal — as it would seem to be by this playoff berth proposal — is to emphasize conference performance, then the entire college football system should do everything in its power to keep those conferences competitive and interesting. Suddenly, the end of the season is important for the teams at the bottom of the barrel.

The 2024 version of Mississippi State would have been relegated out of the SEC thanks to its 0-8 conference record, but would the coaching staff and players approached the last month of the season differently if they knew relegation was on the table?

Sure, there would be things that would need to be worked out, including a team like Florida State who went 1-7 in the ACC last season; once the ‘Noles realize that their season is essentially done, would they tank to get bumped down into a conference with an easier path to a playoff berth? Not if you institute the rule that a team who gets relegated can’t go to the playoff the following year!

Regardless of what future playoff system the college football powers that be come up with, the entire landscape of the sport will be different, and they need to embrace more forward-thinking, innovative ways to keep the sport compelling to fans. I don’t know if relegation would work or not, but what I definitely don’t want is for the beautiful, chaotic sport that college football is to become another cold, cookie-cutter version of pro sports in America.

So, if that means we’ve got to kick some teams out of conferences every year, I’m all for it.





Link

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

NIL

Urban Meyer reveals key to utilizing bulletin board material as a head coach

New Florida State quarterback Thomas Castellanos made waves when he sat down for an interview with On3’s Pete Nakos and questioned Alabama’s dynasty status, in a way, providing some serious bulletin board material. He noted that the Crimson Tide “don’t have Nick Saban to save them” any more. The comments instantly flew around the Internet […]

Published

on


New Florida State quarterback Thomas Castellanos made waves when he sat down for an interview with On3’s Pete Nakos and questioned Alabama’s dynasty status, in a way, providing some serious bulletin board material. He noted that the Crimson Tide “don’t have Nick Saban to save them” any more.

The comments instantly flew around the Internet and social media. Bold claims from a quarterback now captaining a team that won only two games last year.

But the bigger-picture conversation is one about motivation and the merits of it. And there’s one former coach who would be itching to be in Kalen DeBoer‘s shoes right now. Urban Meyer knows a thing or two about how to manage bulletin board material.

“You said that coach DeBoer doesn’t care,” Meyer told his colleagues on The Triple Option podcast. “He does. When his name’s dragged in and there’s the whole country kind of talking about Nick Saban left and there’s a drop-off and all that. We’re all human beings. Coach DeBoer’s got one of the best records out there of any college football coach, but you’re damned right he cares. When I hear people say, ‘I don’t care,’ sure he does. He’s a human being and he sees a little dragging going on.”

Can DeBoer use that to power Alabama going into the season-opening matchup? Meyer said absolutely he can. He explained precisely how.

“Let me say this about the whole bulletin board, I’ve used it a million times,” Meyer said. “And there’s two reasons you use it. It’s for preparation for that game and for the start of the game. After the game, and (co-host) Mark (Ingram) will tell you, after the game gets going, you don’t, I mean, give a damn about what was said before the game, because you’re in it now.”

Meyer has some famous bulletin-board material from his coaching days. At Florida, he famously stewed over Georgia dancing in the end zone in a 2007 game for a full year. Florida came out and absolutely blasted Georgia the following year en route to a national title.

“But what I used it for was that preparation,” Meyer said. “And that was if I saw something, or people knew that I had plenty of people searching for things, coaching a pissed-off team in preparation and then the start of the game,” Meyer said. “But once the game gets rolling, go question those guys in the middle of the second quarter and say, ‘What did that guy say again?’ They’re going to be worried about the field pressure or the middle plug X or the split zone. Players and coaches are too caught up in it.”

That preparation time can be absolutely vital, though. Alabama and Kalen DeBoer can fuel themselves throughout fall camp with Thomas Castellanos’ bulletin board material.

So watch out. Florida State could face a highly motivated Alabama team come season’s start.



Link

Continue Reading

NIL

Ohio State football team loses out on big-time five-star recruit

The Ohio State football program has been trying to beef up its 2026 recruiting class as the summer continues. They continue to try to land some of the biggest recruits left on the board, despite some lacking NIL plans. The Buckeyes had the fifth-best recruiting class heading into Sunday. Five-star linebacker Xavier Griffin made his […]

Published

on


The Ohio State football program has been trying to beef up its 2026 recruiting class as the summer continues. They continue to try to land some of the biggest recruits left on the board, despite some lacking NIL plans. The Buckeyes had the fifth-best recruiting class heading into Sunday.

Five-star linebacker Xavier Griffin made his recruiting decision on Sunday afternoon. He was choosing between the Buckeyes, Texas, Alabama, and Florida State. Heading into the day, he was an Alabama lean, but Ohio State was hoping they did enough late to grab him.

Griffin is listed as the second-best linebacker in the country. He stands at 6’3 and 200 pounds and is from Gainesville, Georgia. Ohio State was the only northern team that he had in his final list of schools. That was always going to be hard to overcome. In the end, it was too much to overcome.

The Ohio State football team loses out on five-star linebacker Xavier Griffin

Instead of picking the Buckeyes, Griffin decided to commit to Alabama. The Crimson Tide were the favorites to land him, so they ended up with him anyway. Ohio State would have loved to have gotten Griffin, but they weren’t expecting to land him, nonetheless.

If the Buckeyes are going to land another five-star recruit in this class, they would prefer it to be Felix Ojo, the second-ranked tackle in the country. Even though he had a bad day during a recent Rivals camp, he is still good enough that he could start day one if they needed him to.

James Laurinaitis has done enough recruiting in the last couple of years to know that he certainly can recruit at an elite level. Losing out on one recruit isn’t the worst thing in the world. He landed a five-star recruit just last year.



Link

Continue Reading

NIL

Louisville Basketball gets great news from NCAA to cap off tremendous offseason

Throughout the college basketball offseason, one major storyline to watch has been the NCAA’s waiver process for select players. Just a few days ago, the NCAA denied a waiver for Memphis center Dain Dainja to get another year, which forced him to move on to the pros. Earlier this offseason, the NCAA had already denied […]

Published

on


Throughout the college basketball offseason, one major storyline to watch has been the NCAA’s waiver process for select players. Just a few days ago, the NCAA denied a waiver for Memphis center Dain Dainja to get another year, which forced him to move on to the pros.

Earlier this offseason, the NCAA had already denied a waiver to Louisville forward Aly Khalifa. This was originally a surprise, as he had redshirted this past season after transferring from BYU. However, reportedly, having already taken a redshirt year at Charlotte previously caused issues with his eligibility. 

The good news for the Cardinals is that, following an appeal of the original denial, the NCAA reversed its decision.

Louisville is a consensus preseason top-25 team, thanks in part to a great transfer portal haul that includes Isaac McKneely and Ryan Conwell. 5-star prospect Mikel Brown Jr. is set to run the offense, while Kasean Pryor returns after suffering a season-ending injury. 

The hope is that Khalifa will be the missing link to make the offense as good as possible. He’s one of the best passing big men in the country, and when he was at BYU, he played a key role in their elite offense, averaging 4.0 assists per game as a big man.

Khalifa and Pryor are the leading bigs for the Cardinals next season. Joining them in the frontcourt are a trio of international prospects, including Vanglis Zougris, Sanada Fru, and Mouhamaed Camara. If any of them break out into key contributors, then this team will be a contender to compete for another ACC title.

Khalifa’s stats don’t scream “all-league” on paper, but that won’t be his role. He gives the team another facilitator and takes pressure off the freshman Brown on the offense, which may be the biggest beneficiary. This news caps off what has been a great offseason for Coach Pat Kelsey and the Cardinals.





Link

Continue Reading

NIL

The College Basketball regular season is expanding to 32 games

More changes are coming to men’s and women’s college basketball. Over the past few months, multiple changes have occurred in college basketball, including the landmark revenue-sharing programs that will begin in July. Federal Judge Claudia Wilken approved the House v. NCAA settlement at the beginning of June. It allows schools to directly pay athletes from […]

Published

on


More changes are coming to men’s and women’s college basketball. Over the past few months, multiple changes have occurred in college basketball, including the landmark revenue-sharing programs that will begin in July.

Federal Judge Claudia Wilken approved the House v. NCAA settlement at the beginning of June. It allows schools to directly pay athletes from a revenue-sharing pool capped at $20.5 million for the 2025-2026 season.

The bulk of the money will be divided among men’s and women’s basketball, football, and wrestling, with the cap projected to increase every year.

In response, the four major sports formed “Flight Funds” programs as a charitable avenue for donors to give directly to the programs or a general fund.

In addition to the revenue-sharing programs, an NCAA oversight committee made multiple changes to men’s college basketball, focusing on the pace of play.

The rule changes that were put in place include adding a coach’s challenge that can be used at any point during the game in response to an out-of-bounds call, basket interference, goaltending, or a player in the restricted area.

After the new rules were put in place, the NCAA Division I Council also approved a regular season game expansion.

CBS Sports’ Matt Norlander reports that a committee approved expanding the regular season from 31 to 32 games, beginning in the 2026-2027 season. The move was made to encourage teams to schedule better non-conference games later in the season.

The expansion ends a 19-year span of a 31-game maximum for the regular season.

Starting in the 2026-2027 season, teams can schedule an extra game, but they will not be forced to do so. Most teams are expected to increase their schedule to the new 32-game maximum.

The extra game allows teams to play a better opponent later in the season and potentially add more highly-ranked Quad wins to their NCAA Tournament resume.

Norlander notes that money is a big driving factor for the 32-game maximum. With more games comes more revenue, which can be used to pay athletes.

More Hawkeyes News:





Link

Continue Reading

NIL

Latest I’m hearing on 5-star EDGE Trenton Henderson

Here’s the latest of what I’m hearing on Trenton Henderson: LSU has put together a significant NIL package that—to be as transparent as possible—the competitors weren’t willing to match. This is a fluid situation and lots can still happen. LSU feels confident in where it stands with Henderson in the final days, but it looks […]

Published

on


Here’s the latest of what I’m hearing on Trenton Henderson:

LSU has put together a significant NIL package that—to be as transparent as possible—the competitors weren’t willing to match.

This is a fluid situation and lots can still happen. LSU feels confident in where it stands with Henderson in the final days, but it looks as if LSU will likely be the destination if this ages consistently.

Would be a massive blow.



Link

Continue Reading

NIL

SEC Breakdowns

Kalen DeBoer came to Alabama with an impressive pedigree as an offensive coach, but his offense saw mixed results in 2024. QB Jalen Milroe was a square peg fit into a round hole in DeBoer’s system, and when it came down to it, that cost them from reaching the playoffs. Now Milore is gone, and […]

Published

on

SEC Breakdowns

Kalen DeBoer came to Alabama with an impressive pedigree as an offensive coach, but his offense saw mixed results in 2024. QB Jalen Milroe was a square peg fit into a round hole in DeBoer’s system, and when it came down to it, that cost them from reaching the playoffs. Now Milore is gone, and DeBoer’s old buddy Ryan Grubb steps in as offensive coordinator. What’s in store for this group in 2025?

The favorite to takeover for Milroe is redshirt junior Ty Simpson. The former 5-star has waited his turn, and the feeling is he can be the right guy to operate DeBoer and Grubb’s scheme. He’s a more natural passer than Milroe and still enough athleticism to make the occasional play on the ground.

That said, many felt he could have taken the job from Milroe last year, and he didn’t. Most likely it was as simple as Milroe’s play-making ability being too strong to leave off the field, but it’s certainly possible Simpson has his own flaws keeping him off the field. If Simpson can’t take control, former Washington transfer Austin Mack and 5-star freshman Keelon Russell will be ready to pounce.

Regardless of who wins the job, they’re going to have an excellent group of wideouts to throw to. Ryan Williams shined as a true freshman with 48 catches for 865 yards and eight TDs. He’s one of the nation’s best, and Germie Bernard and Miami transfer Isaiah Horton are strong options as well.

Lead RB Jam Miller (668 yards, 4.6 YPC, seven TDs) returns with redshirt sophomore Richard Young expected to compliment him. With Jalen Milore gone, this group will have to be more productive, but some of that hinges on the offensive line taking a step forward. That could be made tricky with the loss of 1st round guard Tyler Booker, but a projected 1st round pick returns in left tackle Kadyn Proctor, as does strong starting center Parker Brailsford. Talent isn’t an issue up front.

2025 Alabama offense could look more like what we expect from a Kalen DeBoer team

Alabama’s offensive philosophy in 2024 was essentially “hope Jalen Milroe makes more explosive plays than back-breaking ones.” It paid off in big wins over Georgia and LSU, but against the best defenses the Tide faced, it cost them.

Will more consistency at the QB position, even at the expense of play-making, lead to a playoff run? It’s certainly possible. Kalen DeBoer’s best teams have had deep groups of skill talent with a QB who can effectively distribute them the ball. The skill talent looks to be in place. If Ty Simpson or another QB can play point guard, this could look more like DeBoer’s teams at Washington and Fresno State.

They do need a few new pieces to step up along the offensive line and need more on the ground from non-QBs, but overall, the potential is there for this to be a special unit in Tuscaloosa.

Continue Reading

Most Viewed Posts

Trending